9. It’s Called Psychopathy, Sweetie and A Pretty Groovy UFO

Beam us up, Scotty. This week Ariana and Alexandra discuss some truly bizarre characters. From the theft of a single bandaid to the drug-addled ravings of an obsessed man to a wine bottle with a mind of its own, there’s a lot of strange activity going on here. Ariana covers alleged serial killer and dead fish, Robert Durst. After that, Alexandra channels her inner Fox Mulder while telling the story of Granger Taylor who was definitely abducted by aliens. Trust us on this one, we’re experts.