Episode 46: Blackout or MURDER?! Who Killed Sarah Gonstead
Episode description
This week we're closing out pride month with another LGBTQI+ murder case. How precious!
Sam tells the tale of a boozy night of fun gone wrong. In 1994 in Madison, Wisconsin Penny Brummer goes out for a night of partying with Sarah Gonstead. According to Penny, they had a seemingly good night. But what happens at the end of the night is anyone's guess or is it? Penny Brummer is charged with the execution style murder of Sarah Gonstead a good friend of her former girlfriend.
Penny claims she blacked out drunk and has no recollection of the murder taking place and she couldn't have done it. The prosecution claims she's a cold blooded killer.
We end the episode with a little true crime "would you rather?" and Sam discloses her abnormal attraction and love for an infamous serial killer.