Improving Development Evaluation - podcast cover

Improving Development Evaluation

David Wandrss.com

Join Dr. David Wand as he takes you on a provocative, investigative journey challenging Canadian & American international development organizations as well as international organizations to improve their performance measurement frameworks (PMFs) or Activity Monitoring and Evaluation (MEL) Plans. In Season 1, part 1 of the episode, Dr. Wand will introduce you to an international development organization and one of its projects where flaws in their PMF will be identified. In part 2 of the episode, the international development organization and evaluation experts will be invited to discuss Dr. Wand's critique and offer solutions to improving the evaluation of the project.

For Season 2, Dr. Wand expands the scope of his podcast to include USA government funded international development projects by acquiring Activity Monitoring Evaluation Learning Plans (MEL Plans) or their equivalent as well as continue acquiring Canada government funded international development projects that require PMFs or their equivalent. For Season 2 the focus of the podcast has also been improved whereby several projects from the same international development organization are covered in the same episode exposing how the international development organization fails to properly measure and evaluate whether its expected outcomes have been achieved. This is despite these organizations falsely claiming on their websites that they have achieved these outcomes at the expense of the taxpayer.

Last refreshed:
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

GCERF fails to validly measure rehabilitation of Returning Foreign Terrorist Fighters - Western Balkans

The Global Community Engagement Resilience Fund (GCERF) ( gcerf.org ) has been funding organizations in Bosnia & Herzegovina, Kosovo, Albania, and North Macedonia to deliver psychological services to Returning Foreign Terrorist Fighters to enable them to become first, rehabilitated, and then reintegrated into their communities. Unfortunately, GCERF has failed to provide any valid measures of rehabilitation for these foreign terrorist fighters despite making claims of achieving subsequent rei...

Jun 01, 202629 minSeason 2Ep. 10

GCERF reports percentage increases but fails to do the statistical analysis to support statistical significance: Ghana Results Paper Emergency Grant

In this episode, Dr. Wand thanks the Global Community Engagement Resilience Fund (GCERF) ( gcerf.org ) for 'improving development evaluation' by, six years later, finally publishing their results frameworks, including outcome statements, outcome indicators, as well as actually data on these indicators. A marked increase in data transparency!!! In this episode, Dr. Wand reviews the GCERF report Ghana Results Paper: Emergency Grant and identifies 4 areas of weakness in the results paper as follows...

May 26, 202625 minSeason 2Ep. 9

Humber Polytechnic International Development Institute fails to properly evaluate its $4.9 Million Bhutan Education and Skills Training project

In this episode, Dr. Wand reviews the Humber Polytechnic International Development Institute ( https://humber.ca/global/international-development-institute-idi ) $4.9 Million Bhutan Education and Skills Training project Performance Measurement Framework (PMF). He concludes that Humber Polytechnic cannot make the claim that it has achieved 9 of the 11 expected Outcomes for the project since the outcome indicators are either not valid measures of the Outcomes and/or contain conflicts of interest f...

Apr 24, 202652 minSeason 2Ep. 8

World Vision Canada fails to show Impact in its $41 Million Gender Equality Nutrition program but potential to show project effectiveness is there

In this episode we review the $41 Million World Vision Canada project ( www.worldvisioncanada.ca ) entitled Realizing Gender Equality, Attitudinal Change, and Transformative Systems in Nutrition. More information about this project can be found at https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/project-projet/details/p011791001. A critique of the Performance Measurment Framework (PMF) for this project reveals 13 expected Outcomes for this project with 38 Outcome Indicators developed...

Mar 31, 202647 minSeason 2Ep. 7

Failure of CUSO International to properly evaluate its 2 projects worth $7.5 Million

Please sign the petition here https://www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid to have the Government of Canada require all Canadian taxpayer funded international development organizations release on their websites their Performance Measurement Frameworks (PMFs) or its equivalent and data for all output and outcome indicators listed in the PMF. CUSO International ( www.cusointernational.org ) has failed to properly measure and evaluate its 2 projects costing the Canadian taxpayer $7.5 Million. CUSO Inte...

Dec 17, 202551 minSeason 2Ep. 6

GCERF fails to show it is achieving its outcomes from spending $1.1 Million USD from Global Affairs Canada

In this episode, the Global Community Engagement Resilience Fund (GCERF) ( www.gcerf.org ) fails to evaluate the effectiveness of its $ 1.1 Million USD received from Global Affairs Canada. GCERF claims to be achieving its 4 outcomes by funding organizations in developing countries to deliver services to achieve those outcomes. But GCERF provides no measures on these outcomes through outcome indicators nor any data related to those outcome indicators in the document they sent to Dr. Wand. This do...

Nov 13, 202522 minSeason 2Ep. 5

Oxfam Canada (www.oxfam.ca) fails to evaluate its 2 projects worth $13,140,000: Care Connect and Camino Verde

Sign the petition here to require Oxfam to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode, Dr. Wand reviews the Performance Measurement Frameworks (PMFs) for 2 Oxfam Canada ( www.oxfam.ca ) projects: Care Connect https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/project-projet/details/p012493001 at a cost of $5,950,000 and Camino Verde https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/project-projet/details/p005232001 at a...

Sep 19, 202545 minSeason 2Ep. 4

Global Community Engagement Resilience Fund (www.gcerf.org) fails to evaluate its $5 Million USAID funding

In this episode, the Global Community Engagement Resilience Fund ( www.gcerf.org ) fails to evaluate its $ 5 Million USD received from the United States Agency for International Development. Although GCERF claims on its website to be achieving its 4 expected outcomes through funding its implementing partners in developing countries to deliver services to achieve those outcomes, they provide no evidence in the form of outcome indicators and any data related to those outcome indicators on its webs...

Feb 07, 202515 minSeason 2Ep. 3

Doctors of the World: Flaws in its Performance Measurement Framework - Access to health rights Burkina Faso

Sign the petition here to require Doctors of the World to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode, Dr. Wand reviews the Government of Canada-funded $14 Million Doctors of the World https://medecinsdumonde.ca/ project entitled Access to health rights in Northern Burkina Faso. Details about the project can be found here: https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/project-projet/details/P008979001 From a review of the proj...

Nov 13, 202431 minSeason 2Ep. 2

UNFPA Somalia reproductive health project: Flaws in the Performance Measurement Framework

Sign the petition here to require UNFPA to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode, Dr. Wand reviews the Government of Canada-funded $10 Million UNFPA Somalia project entitled Strengthening Sexual Reproductive Health and Rights through Midwives. Details about the project can be found here: https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/project-projet/details/p007483001 He reviews the Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) ...

Oct 25, 202427 minSeason 2Ep. 1

Season 2: Trailer

In this trailer, Dr. Wand outlines the following focus and changes in format and content for Season 2: The focus of the this podcast is to expose those Government of Canada funded international development organizations that are falsely claiming that their development outcomes are being achieved by reviewing their Performance Measurement Frameworks (PMFs). The podcast will not be reviewing charity or emergency projects such as the payment of school fees or cash transfers or the delivery of emerg...

Oct 12, 202415 min

UNDP Bangladesh: Episode 8 Part 2 Evaluation experts discuss flaws in the PMF and provide solutions on how the evaluation of the project can be improved

Sign the petition here to require UNDP to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode 8, part 2, Dr. Wand critiques the UNDP Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $30 Million project in Cox's Bazar District Bangladesh entitled Fighting environmental degradation and promoting greener energy. You can learn more about the project here: https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/project-projet/details/p010741001. He con...

Jun 28, 202421 minSeason 1Ep. 17

UNDP Bangladesh- Flaws in its Performance Measurement Framework PMF

Sign the petition here to require UNDP to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode 8, part 1, Dr. Wand critiques the UNDP Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $30 Million project in Cox's Bazar District Bangladesh entitled Fighting environmental degradation and promoting greener energy. You can learn more about the project here: https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/project-projet/details/p010741001. He con...

Jun 10, 202416 minSeason 1Ep. 16

Equitas: Episode 7 Part 3 Evaluation experts discuss flaws in their PMF and provide solutions on how the evaluation of the project can be improved

Sign the petition here to require Equitas to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode 7, part 3, Dr. Wand continues his discussion with evaluation expert Yvonne Okeke about Equitas www.equitas.org Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $18 Million project in Burkina Faso, Haiti, Kenya, Tanzania, Senegal entitled Achieving Equality through Human Rights Education. You can learn more about the project here: https://w05.international.g...

May 20, 202428 minSeason 1Ep. 15

Equitas: Episode 7 Part 2 Evaluation experts discuss flaws in their PMF and provide solutions on how the evaluation of the project can be improved

Sign the petition here to require Equitas to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode 7, part 2, Dr. Wand discusses with evaluation expert Yvonne Okeke Equitas www.equitas.org Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $18 Million project in Burkina Faso, Haiti, Kenya, Tanzania, Senegal entitled Achieving Equality through Human Rights Education. You can learn more about the project here: https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-b...

May 20, 202431 minSeason 1Ep. 14

Equitas - Flaws in its Performance Measurement Framework PMF

Sign the petition here to require Equitas to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode 7, part 1, Dr. Wand critiques the Equitas Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $18 Million project in Burkina Faso, Senegal, Kenya, Tanzania, and Haiti entitled Achieving Equality through Human Rights Education. You can learn more about the project here: https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/project-projet/details/P0068520...

Apr 24, 202415 minSeason 1Ep. 13

Colleges & Institutes Canada: Episode 6 Part 2 Evaluation experts discuss flaws in their PMF and provide solutions on how the evaluation of the project can be improved

Sign the petition here to require Colleges & Institutes Canada to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode 6, part 2, Dr. Wand discusses with evaluation expert Dr. Jenny Jorgenson Colleges & Institutes Canada www.collegesinstitutes.ca Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $18 Million project in Senegal entitled A Thousand women: I am woman, I exist, I participate. You can learn more about the project here: https://w05.inte...

Mar 30, 202443 minSeason 1Ep. 12

Colleges & Institutes Canada: Flaws in its Performance Measurement Framework PMF

Sign the petition here to require Colleges & Institutes Canada to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode 6, part 1, Dr. Wand critiques the Colleges & Institutes Canada www.collegesinstitutes.ca Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $18 Million project in Senegal entitled A Thousand women: I am, I exist, I participate. You can learn more about the project here: https://w05.international.gc.ca/projectbrowser-banqueprojets/...

Mar 07, 202414 minSeason 1Ep. 11

Mennonite Economic Development Associates (MEDA): Episode 5, Part 2 Evaluation experts and MEDA discuss flaws in their PMF and provide solutions.

Sign the petition here to require MEDA to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this episode 5, Part 2, Dr. Wand discusses with evaluation expert Benjamin Serebour and MEDA representative Yasir Dildar the Mennonite Economic Development Associates www.meda.org Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $19,040,307 Million project in Africa, Americas, and Asia entitled A New Partnership for Sustainable Impact Investing in Frontier Markets. You can...

Feb 25, 202459 minSeason 1Ep. 10

Mennonite Economic Development Associates: Flaws in its Performance Measurement Framework PMF

In this episode 5, Part 1, Dr. Wand critiques the Mennonite Economic Development Associates www.meda.org Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $19,040,307 Million project in Africa, Americas, and Asia entitled A New Partnership for Sustainable Impact Investing in Frontier Markets. He concludes that the PMF is flawed and that the Mennonite Development Associates cannot make the claim that its project services have achieved its project outcomes. He also describes the services that the proj...

Feb 05, 202410 minSeason 1Ep. 9

Ghana Rural Integrated Development Episode 4, Part 2: Dr. Wand discusses flaws in their Performance Measurement Framework and provides solutions.

Sign the petition here to require Ghana Rural Integrated Development to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this Part 2 of Episode 4, Dr. Wand discusses flaws in the Ghana Rural Integrated Development international development organization https://grid-nea.org/ Performance Measurement Framework PMF for its $1,337,797 project in Ghana entitled Improving the Well-Being of Rural Women and Girls in Ghana. Dr. Wand concludes that their PMF is not suff...

Jan 27, 202423 minSeason 1Ep. 8

Ghana Rural Integrated Development: Flaws in its Performance Measurement Framework PMF

In this episode 4, Part 1, Dr. Wand critiques the Ghana Rural Integrated Development www.grid-nea.org Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $1.337 Million project in Ghana entitled Improving the Well Being of Rural Women and Girls in Ghana. He concludes that the PMF is flawed and that the Ghana Rural Integrated Development cannot make the claim that its project services have achieved its project outcomes. He also describes the services that the project delivers and invites listeners to r...

Jan 07, 202417 minSeason 1Ep. 7

UNFPA South Sudan Episode 3 Part 2: Evaluation experts discuss flaws in their Performance Measurement Framework and provide solutions.

Sign the petition here to require UNFPA to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this Part 2 of Episode 3, Dr. Wand discusses with evaluation expert Benjamin Serebour flaws in UNFPA South Sudan's https://southsudan.unfpa.org/ Performance Measurement Framework PMF for its $37,000,000 project in South Sudan entitled Human Resources for Sexual Reproductive Health in South Sudan. They conclude that their PMF is not sufficient to support UNFPA's claim t...

Dec 18, 202344 minSeason 1Ep. 6

Canadian Bureau for International Education Episode 2 Part 2 Evaluation experts discuss flaws in their Performance Measurement Framework and provide solutions.

Sign the petition here to require Canadian Bureau for International Education to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this Part 2 of Episode 2, Dr. Wand discusses with evaluation expert Hayat Askar flaws in the Canadian Bureau for International Education http://www.cbie.ca/ Performance Measurement Framework PMF for its $5,000,000 project in Canada entitled African Leaders of Tomorrow Scholarships Fund. They conclude that the Outcome Indicators are...

Dec 03, 202332 minSeason 1Ep. 5

CARE Canada Episode 1 Part 2: Evaluation experts discuss flaws in their Performance Measurement Framework and provide solutions.

Sign the petition here to require CARE Canada to put all its PMFs and related data on its website: www.change.org/EvaluateCanadaAid In this Part 2 of Episode 1, Dr. Wand discusses with evaluation experts Donald Cole and Dr. Mark Degner flaws in CARE Canada's Performance Measurement Framework PMF for its $3,400,000 project in Vietnam entitled Advancing Women's Economic Empowerment. They conclude that 'stories of change' may be necessary but are not sufficient to support CARE Canada in its claim t...

Nov 27, 202339 minSeason 1Ep. 4

United Nations Population Fund UNFPA South Sudan: Flaws in its Performance Measurement Framework PMF

In this episode 3, Part 1, Dr. Wand critiques a United Nations Population Fund UNFPA www.unfpa.org Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $37 Million project in South Sudan entitled Human Resources for Sexual Reproductive Health Rights and Gender-Based Violence in South Sudan. He concludes that the PMF is flawed and that the United Nations Population Fund UNFPA cannot make the claim that its project services have achieved its project outcomes. He also describes the services that the proje...

Nov 18, 202326 minSeason 1Ep. 3

Canadian Bureau for International Education: Flaws in its project Performance Measurement Framework PMF

In this episode 2, Part 1, Dr. Wand critiques a Canadian Bureau for International Education www.cbie.ca Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $5,127,124 project in Canada entitled African Leaders of Tomorrow Scholarships Fund. He concludes that the PMF is flawed and that the Canadian Bureau for International Education cannot make the claim that its project services have achieved its project outcomes. He also describes the services that the project delivers and invites listeners to reques...

Oct 25, 202320 minSeason 1Ep. 2

CARE Canada: Flaws in its project Performance Measurement Framework PMF

In this episode 1, Part 1, Dr. Wand critiques a CARE Canada www.care.ca Performance Measurement Framework (PMF) for a $3,400,000 project in Vietnam entitled Advancing Women's Economic Empowerment. He concludes that the PMF is flawed and that CARE Canada cannot make the claim that its project services have achieved its project outcomes. He also describes the services that the project delivers and invites listeners to request a copy of the PMF and his critique. Finally, he invites CARE Canada as w...

Oct 19, 202319 minSeason 1Ep. 1

Trailer - Improving Development Evaluation

In this trailer, Dr. Wand will provide details covering 3 areas: 1 - What each episode (parts 1 and 2) will cover including explaining how international development projects are not being evaluated and how the podcast will offer solutions to improving the evaluation of the project; 2- The types of projects to be covered in Season 1; 3- How the listener can become involved with the podcast. https://mydeals.page/1hjl Donate here to increase the number of organizations that receive performance audi...

Oct 07, 202315 min
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android