I Think Not! - podcast cover

I Think Not!

I Think Not!www.ithinknotpod.com
From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Ellyn, Joey – and all the characters that live inside their gorgeous heads – for true stories and the campy television that covers them. Get ready to laugh, cry and think about true crime in a whole new way.
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

79: The Disappearance of Amy Wroe Bechtel

Twenty-four year old competitive runner Amy Wroe Bechtel goes for a run in the forest outside of Lander, Wyoming and vanishes without a trace. WAS IT BIGFOOT? WAS IT HER HUSBAND? The investigation into her disappearance spans years and hundreds of square miles. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram ...

Dec 15, 20211 hr 1 minEp. 79

78: The Disappearance of Satara Stratton

Twenty-four year old aspiring actress, Satara Stratton disappears in Hollywood. In Tennessee, her mother Sharon is desperate to find her and launches a search to find Satara that takes her deep into the seedy side of a star studded city. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out...

Dec 08, 202156 minEp. 78

77: The Disappearance of Hatice Corbacioglu

Thirty-two-year-old Hatice Corbacioglu thought she'd met the man of her dreams. But when she traveled overseas with him to meet his family and didn't contact her own family for weeks, everyone knew something had gone terribly wrong. And when the fiance returns to the States without her, the frantic search for Hatice begins. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our socia...

Dec 01, 20211 hrEp. 77

76: The Disappearance of Colleen Wood (S6 E4)

52-year-old Colleen Wood has found love and a new life in South Florida. Her wealthy boyfriend offers her the chance of a lifetime--- a round the world trip on his yacht. Then Colleen suddenly vanishes and the boyfriend is the only one who knows why. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok ...

Nov 24, 20211 hr 4 minEp. 76

75: The Disappearance of Terrance Williams

When Terrance Williams goes missing, his family fears that he may have been arrested for driving without a license. But when they find that his car has been towed by a police officer, with no record Terrance having been arrested, an investigation reveals the disturbing truth. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twit...

Nov 17, 202154 minEp. 75

74: The Disappearance of Jesse Capen (S6 E3)

35 year-old Jesse Capen vanishes on a camping trip in Arizona's Superstition Mountains. While law enforcement searches the vast wilderness, his family finds a huge secret on his computer. His disappearance may have to do with the legend he is chasing. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok...

Nov 10, 20211 hr 3 minEp. 74

73: The Disappearance of Bethany Decker (S6 E2)

21-year-old Bethany Decker is a hard-working student, waitress, mother, and wife of a National Guardsman serving in Afghanistan. When she vanishes while pregnant with her second child, police discover her life was more complicated than anyone realized. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTo...

Nov 03, 202156 minEp. 73

72: The Disappearance of Mitrice Richardson

When 25 year-old college grad, Mitrice Richardson, goes missing after being released from a remote sheriff's station at 12:30 AM, a heated battle for answers ensues. Multiple sightings have family and authorities divided on the young woman's whereabouts. AND HER BADASS MOTHER IS NOT HERE FOR ANYONE'S S**T Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! F...

Oct 27, 20211 hr 4 minEp. 72

71: The Disappearance of Billy McGrath (S5 E 17)

FAM!!! WE FIIIIIIIIIIIIINALLLY HAVE OUR FIRST EPISODE ABOUT A GAY PERSON!! Billy McGrath is a wildly successful interior designer in Phoenix, Arizona. He's very close with circle of friends, so when nobody hears from him for over two weeks, everyone knows something is terribly wrong. Did he take off on his own--fleeing from an abusive boyfriend--or is it something even more sinister? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finis...

Oct 20, 20211 hr 5 minEp. 71

70: The Disappearance of Dana Pastori

In February 2002, 39-year-old Dana Pastori was living with her boyfriend John Morgan in New Orleans. She was happy enough, but then one day she vanished. John told friends she'd been in an accident. Then he said she went off to Europe to write a memoir. It would take over three years for anyone to even suspect that something else might have happened to Dana--something much darker. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished...

Oct 13, 20211 hr 2 minEp. 70

69: The Disappearance of Zebb Quinn

The last time Zebb Quinn was seen, on Sunday, January 2, 2000. He was leaving his work shift with a friend in Asheville, North Carolina. The friend would later tell police that Zeb got a text that panicked him and he took off into the night, after which he was never seen again. But there is nobody to corroborate this story, and as clues about Zeb's disappearance emerge, it's clear there is more to the story. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I ...

Oct 06, 20211 hr 1 minEp. 69

68: The Disappearance of Shannan Gilbert

In the early hours of May 1st, 2010, Jersey City escort Shannan Gilbert goes missing on the affluent shores of Long Island. Police launch a search through the dense underbrush, and what they find hidden in the weeds will spark a gruesome investigation. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTo...

Sep 29, 20211 hr 1 minEp. 68

67: The Disappearance of Chioma Gray (S5 E13)

HOLD ON TO YOUR BUTTS, FAM, THIS ONE IS WIIIIIIILLLLLLLDDDDDD . Fourteen-year-old Chioma Gray disappears with an older man in 2007 and crosses the border into Mexico. For four years, her family wonders how she disappeared and if she's still alive. In October of 2011, they get the answers they've been waiting for. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did...

Sep 22, 20211 hr 1 minEp. 67

66: The Disappearance of Suzy Lyall

On the night of March 2, 1998, 20-year-old Suzanne boarded a city bus in Albany, New York and headed back to her college campus. Another student saw her get off the bus at a place that was just a short walk to Suzy’s dorm. But she never made it home, and she was never seen again. Evidence suggests she may have been the first victim of serial killer Israel Keyes, but we’ll probably never know for sure. So what happened? Where. The Hell. Is Suzy? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed ...

Sep 15, 20211 hr 3 minEp. 66

The Vanishing Drowning Men (From "Strange and Unexplained")

We're off this week, but we wanted to share an amazing episode from another Obsessed Network show called "Strange and Unexplained With Daisy Eagan." For a decade or longer, young, fit men have been vanishing. The circumstances are usually the same: The young man is out with friends, usually they're drinking, he is somehow separated from the group, and he vanishes. Days or week later, his body is found a body of water near where he vanished. Often the condition of the body doesn't make sense for ...

Sep 08, 202134 min

65: The Disappearance of Ben McDaniel (S5 E11)

On August 20, 2010, 30-year-old Ben McDaniel attempted one of the most dangerous underwater cave dives in the United States--a cave called "The Vortex" in Ponce De Leon, Florida. Underwater witnesses saw him entering the cave, though when he never resurfaced, authorities believed his body would be recovered in the cave. But the most experienced cave divers in the world went down there looking for him and found nothing. So what happened? Did Ben fake his own death? Where is he? Hey, DBs! A messag...

Sep 01, 20211 hr 2 minEp. 65

64: The disappearance of Joey Lynn Offutt (S5 E10)

Joey Lynn Offutt vanishes after an argument with her on again off again boyfriend. Is she holding a grudge or overwhelmed by motherhood and taking a break? And when a fire breaks out in Joey's home, it leaves her family scrambling for answers. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and che...

Aug 25, 20211 hr 1 minEp. 64

63: The Disappearance of Clinton Nelson (S5 E9)

21 year old Clinton Nelson headed off to Louisiana to get to know his biological father and take a job in the oil fields. Six months later, family and friends are combing the swamps and the woods of the Louisiana bayou looking for him. He was last seen leaving a party and the last person to speak Clinton by phone was his father who reports that Clinton was speaking in a whisper hiding somewhere in the woods. So what happened? And Where. The Hell. Is clinton? Hey, DBs! A message from the future h...

Aug 18, 20211 hr 2 minEp. 63

62: The Disappearance of Noah Pippin

31 Year old Noah Pippin was an Iraq war veteran and a former member of the LAPD. On August 25, 2010, he said goodbye to his parents and siblings at the end of a family visit, and, he told them, took off for California where he was to report for duty with the US Coast Guard. But it was a lie. Instead, he drove to Montana and hiked into untamed wilderness of Glacier National Park. Though he was spotted by a few other hikers, he was never seen alive again. So What Happened? And Where. The Hell. Is ...

Aug 11, 202157 minEp. 62

61: ANNOUNCEMENT: WE'RE GOING ON (A VERY COVID SAFE) TOUR!

FAAAAAAAAM!!! WE'RE GOING ON TOUR AND WE WANT YOU TO COME SEE US! To grab your tickets, go here and grab them while you can! Here's where we're coming: Washington DC: Saturday, August 28 Philadelphia: Sunday, August 29 San Francisco: Thursday, September 2 Los Angeles: Friday, September 3 Seattle: Sunday, September 5 Denver: Monday, September 6 CLICK HERE FOR TICKETS AND COME SEEEEEEEEE US! IMPORTANT: For everyone's safety, full vaccination and mask wearing is a must at all shows! Proof of vaccin...

Aug 09, 20216 minEp. 61

60: The Disappearance of Margaret McEnroe (Season 5 Ep. 7)

Margaret McEnroe is known is a hometown hero: a volunteer known for her fearlessness. But she's also known for her firey temper. When she vanishes from her home in the middle of the afternoon, her family, and the authorities, are at a loss to figure out what happened. There's no way she'd abandon her small children, but there's also no sign that she was taken against her will. So what happened? And where. The Hell. Is Margaret? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared...

Aug 04, 20211 hrEp. 60

The Disappearance of Bison Dele and Serena Karlan

On July 6, 2002, Bison and Serena set sail from Tahiti on Bison's catamaran. Joining them was Bison's brother, Miles. Bison and Serena had been in regular communication with family and friends via satellite phone, but suddenly, all communication stopped. After weeks of silence, Miles appeared back in the United States. He claimed to have no idea where Bison and Serena were. But his story didn't add up, leaving everyone wondering: WHERE. THE HELL. ARE BISON AND SERENA? Hey, DBs! A message from th...

Jul 28, 202157 min

58: The Disappearance of Danice Day (S5 E5)

On January 9, 2002, 19-year-old Danice Day finished her shift at Dos Rios restaurant in Monte Vissta, Colorado, walked to her car, and was never seen again. At first, authorities believe she vanished on purpose--that she needed a break from her stressful life, but that she'd come back. A month later, with no word from Danice and no sightings of her, police begin to zero in on her boyfriend. What does he know? And Where. The Hell. Is Danice? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with...

Jul 14, 202157 minEp. 58

The Impossible Disappearances of Brian Shaffer and Ian Burnet (from "Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan")

Fam! We're taking the week off, but we wanted to share you a fascinating and terrifying episode from another Obsessed Network podcast called Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan. Columbus Ohio 2006, 1:15 am: 27-year-old medical student Brian Shaffer is seen on a surveillance camera walking into a bar with two friends. But he never comes back out. Somehow, in a bar packed with potential witnesses, Brian vanished into thin air seemingly INSIDE the bar. Then, in New York city in 2011, 22-year-o...

Jul 07, 202135 min

57: The Disappearance of Jackie Markham (S5 EP 4)

Jakie Markham was loving life. She was newly single, had a family she adored, a job she LOVED, and was having real fun for the first time in years. But the one night, she calls a freind and says "Richard" is over and he's been drinking, Jackie is never seen again. Who the hell is Richard? Did he do something to Jackie? What the hell happened? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappea...

Jun 30, 202158 minEp. 57

56: The Disappearance of Terrance Williams (S5 E3)

When Terrance Williams goes missing, his family fears that he may have been arrested for driving without a license. But when they find that his car has been towed by a police officer, with no record Terrance having been arrested, an investigation reveals the disturbing truth. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twit...

Jun 23, 20211 hrEp. 56

55: The Disappearance of Susan Walsh (S5 EP 2)

Susan Walsh was a loving mother, exotic dancer, and writer. She'd been writing about her life as a stirpper for the Village Voice and was starting to see some real success as a journalist. But the success came at a cost--the writing had put her in the cross hairs of some very dangerous people. One day Susan walked across the street from her house to use a pay phone and was never seen again. So what happened? And where. The Hell. Is Susan Walsh? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed ...

Jun 16, 202159 minEp. 55

54: The Disappearance of Ginny Wood (S5 E1)

On March 8, 2007, Virginia “Ginny” Wood hopped in her car for a solo 1400 mile drive to Brownsville, Texas where she was to meet up with her best friend, Kelly Gaskins and Kelly’s boyfriend, Erwin Williams. Ginny called a friend on March 10th to say she was headed across the border to Cancun with Kelly and Erwin. The three were never seen again. So what happened? Where. The Hell. Is Ginny (...and Kelly and Erwin...and why does this episode not seem to care about them….?) Hey, DBs! A message from...

Jun 09, 202159 minEp. 54

53: The Disappearance of Jamie Fraley

JUST WHEN YOU THINK THIS ONE IS OVER....S**T GOES BANANAS. Jamie Fraley vanished from her North Carolina apartment with no signs of foul play. Then detectives learn that her boyfriend's father had developed an obsession with Jamie while his son was in prison. AND THEN....AND THEN....(in my best Christopher voice) "a grim discovery changes the course of the investigation." Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recappin...

Jun 02, 20211 hrEp. 53

52: The Disappearance of Tina McQuaig (S4 E13)

Tina McQuaig, a 27-year-old wife and mother, left her job just after 5:00 pm on March 15, 2000. She called home to tell the babysitter she'd be a little late. But she never showed up. A few day later, her car was found in a Walmart parking lot, but yielded no useful clues. Police speculate that she was meeting someone else at Walmart and took off with them, but her family doesn't buy it. Sow what happened? And Where. The Hell. Is Tina? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Dis...

May 26, 202159 minEp. 52
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android