I Think Not! - podcast cover

I Think Not!

I Think Not!www.ithinknotpod.com
From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Ellyn, Joey – and all the characters that live inside their gorgeous heads – for true stories and the campy television that covers them. Get ready to laugh, cry and think about true crime in a whole new way.
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

51: The Disappearance of Lily Aramburo (S4 EP 12)

24-year-old Lily Aramburo vanished on June 1, 2007. Shortly before 2am, she and her fiancée Christian Pacheco had an argument and, according to Christian, Lily left—wearing only a nightgown—and leaving all her things behind, including money, credit cards, and her cell phone. But if Christian was the last person to see her alive, can he be trusted? What Happened? And Where. The Hell. Is Lily? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after ...

May 19, 202157 minEp. 51

Introducing "Murder in Alliance: Ep. 1 Dead in the Water"

Hey, Fam! We're so excited to bring you the new show from the Obsessed Network, "Murder in Alliance." We've got the first episode here for you in this feed, and two more available right now wherever you get your podcasts. Listen to the first three episodes and follow "Murder in Alliance" on your favorite podcast player HERE ( https://lnk.to/98BXWuip ). In the podcast, investigative journalist Maggie Freleng reinvestigates the 1999 murder of Yvonne Layne. Though her ex-boyfriend David Thorne was ...

May 13, 202131 min

50: The Disappearance of Brianna Maitland (S4 EP 11)

After moving away from her family farm and dropping out of high school, 17-year-old Brianna Maitland vanishes in the middle of the night. AND. IT. WAS. DAYS. BEFORE. ANYONE. NOTICED. Her car was found on the side of a rural road, backed into the side of an abandoned farmhouse, and nobody realized it was a crime scene. We can't, you guys. WE SIMPLY CANOT. So, what happened? And Where. The Hell. Is Brianna? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Thi...

May 12, 202156 minEp. 50

49: The Disappearance of Mike Williams (S4 EP 10)

31 year-old Mike Williams went duck hunting on a Florida lake and disappeared. Some said alligators ate him, but his mother isn't buying it. She convinces police to investigate, and when they dig deeper, they turn up suspicious evidence of foul play. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok ...

May 05, 202158 minEp. 49

48: The Disappearance of Colleen Orsborn (S4 E9)

Oh my god, you guys, this one is called "Spring Break Nightmare." And it lives up to its 1980s horror movie title. When 15 year old Colleen skips school for a day at the beach, she imagines the worst that can happen is a fight with her mother. But when Colleen never makes it home, the family knows something far more sinister has happened. And when the police realize that there was an active serial killer in town on the day Colleen vanished, everyone fears the worst. Hey, DBs! A message from the ...

Apr 28, 202155 minEp. 48

47: The Disappearance of Amber Gerweck (S4 E8)

Amber Gerweck, a 32-year-old mother of 4 vanishes in the middle of the day. Two days later, her car is found 600 miles from her home in the parking lot of a discount store. Amber is seen on the store's surveillance video, but the images offer no clues to what happened to her. So What Happened? And Where. The Hell. Is Amber? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our socia...

Apr 21, 202155 minEp. 47

46: The Disappearance of Leah Peebles (S4 E7)

23 year old Leah Peebles was looking for a fresh start when she moved to Albuquerque, New Mexico in May of 2006. But when she mysteriously vanished after a night out with a new friend, her family and friends knew something was terribly wrong. Leah’s father, John, spent months searching the city’s darkest corners looking for his daughter but came up emptyhanded. What happened? And Where. The Hell. Is Leah? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Thi...

Apr 14, 202159 minEp. 46

45: The Disappearance of Mandy Stokes (S4 E6)

On November 24, 2007, 33 year old Mandy Stokes was seen having an argument with her brother Aaron outside of their shared apartment in Oakland, California. According to Aaron, she later left to run errands, and she was never seen again. Neighbors would later report that the fight had been heated and aggressive and nobody but Aaron actually saw her leave. And after she's reported missing, Aaron refused to let the police search the apartment. All signs point to Aaron as being responsible for Mandy...

Apr 07, 202154 minEp. 45

Introducing "Strange and Unexplained: Ep. 1 The Watcher House"

Hey, Fam! We're so excited to bring you the new show from the Obsessed Network, "Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan." We've got the first episode here for you in this feed, and two more available right now wherever you get your podcasts. Listen to the first three episodes and follow "Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan" on your favorite podcast player HERE . From Executive Producer Patrick Hinds and the Obsessed Network comes a new podcast about all the weird stuff happening around us...

Apr 02, 202139 min

44: The Disappearance of Patricia Viola (S4 E5)

On February 13, 2001, James Viola came home with an armful of Valentines gifts. He found the backdoor open, and no sign of his wife, Patricia. Patricia's mother would tell authorities she'd spoken with her daughter on the phone just hours before, and everything was fine. Her family can't imagine that she would have just taken off, but there's no sign of foul play. So what happened? Where. The Hell. Is Patricia? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into...

Mar 31, 202158 minEp. 44

43: The Disappearance of Charlie Allen (S4 E4)

On October 27, 2007, college student Charlie Allen vanishes. Earlier in the day he told his sister that bad people were after him. He leaves messages for his parents saying he’s heading south for Florida or Texas, but nobody ever hears from him again. Was he in danger? Or did he set out to start a new life? What Happened? And where. The Hell. Is Charlie? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes...

Mar 24, 202159 minEp. 43

42: The Disappearance of Morgan Harrington (S4 E3)

On October 17, 2009, 20 year old Morgan Harrington and three friends went to a Metallica concert in Charlottesville, Virginia. Before the show even started, Morgan let her friends to find the bathroom and never returned. Witnesses would later say they saw Morgan in the parking lot acting strange. Other witnesses would say they saw her on a main road trying to hitch hike out of town. Buy why would she abandon her friends at concert she’d been excited about for weeks? What happened? Where. The Hel...

Mar 17, 202155 minEp. 42

41: The Disappearance of Steven Koecher (S4 E2)

On December 13, 2009, 30-year-old Steven Koecher parked his car in a cul-de-sac in a town called Henderson, Nevada—200 miles from home. A surveillance camera captured him sitting in the car for 6 minutes before getting out and walking away. He was never seen again. In the weeks that followed, his family poured over his online activity and discovered that Steven had been keeping secrets. So how did he end up in that neighborhood? What was he doing there? And Where. The Hell. Is Steven? Hey, DBs! ...

Mar 10, 202150 minEp. 41

40: The Disappearance of Rachel Cooke (S4 E1)

19-year-old Rachel Cook returned home to her small Texas town for Christmas break in 2002. An avid runner, she heads out on her daily 6 mile jog on January 2nd. She never came home. It would take her family several hours to realize that she was missing and even longer to get the local cops to take the case seriously. And it would be years before someone—an incarcerated murderer—came forward with clues. What happened? Where. The hell. Is Rachel? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed ...

Mar 03, 202150 minEp. 40

39: The Disappearance of Patty Vaughan (S3 E13)

Patty Vaughn, a 32-year-old Mother of three, was last seen on Christmas Day in 1996 at her home in La Vernia, Texas. Though she and her husband J.R. were separated, they spent they spent the day together at the family home with their three kids. According to J.R., the two spent most of the day fighting and Patty eventually left in her minivan. The minivan was found abandoned on the side of the road the next day. And Patty has never been seen or heard from again. What Happened? Where. The Hell. I...

Feb 24, 202153 minEp. 39

38: The Disappearance of Brandy Hall (S3 E12)

On August 17, 2002, Brandy Hall left her job and vanished. No on has seen her since. The 32-year-old mother of two was a beloved fire fighter and popular member of the community, so when her truck is found submerged in a local pond, her friends and family fear the worst. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, ...

Feb 17, 202153 minEp. 38

37: The Disappearance of Samantha Bonnell (S3 E11)

18-year-old Samantha Bonnell and her boyfriend Chris were selling magazines (MAGAZINES?) door to door with a company that took them to cities across the country. One night, Samantha went out with new friends in a strange city and never came back. It would take over a year and an unimaginable amount of internet sleuthing from Samantha's mother to find out what happened. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping a...

Feb 10, 202152 minEp. 37

36: The Disappearance of the Springfield Three (S3 E10)

Sherrill Levett, her daughter Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall, mysteriously vanished on Sunday, June 7, 1992—just hours after attending the girls’ high school graduation. All of their personal belongings, including cars and purses, were left behind. There were no signs of a struggle, except a broken porch light globe; there was also a message on the answering machine that police believe might have provided a clue about the disappearances, but it was inadvertently erased. It’s one of the most fa...

Feb 03, 202155 minEp. 36

35: The Disappearance of Ray Gricar (S3 E9)

On May 15, 2005, Ray Gricar took the day off. At 11:30 am he called his girlfriend at work and told her he wouldn’t be home until late afternoon—he was going on a drive in the back roads of Amish Country in Pennsylvania. Nobody has ever seen or heard from him again. What happened? Did he walk out of his life? Did he meet with foul play? Where. The hell. Is Ray? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the e...

Jan 27, 202157 minEp. 35

34: The Disappearance of Leah Roberts (S3 E8)

Get this episode ad-free, and all of our episodes ad-free, HERE ! On March 13, 2000, 23-year-old Leah Roberts packed her car, withdrew $3000 in cash from the bank, and hit the road in her Jeep Cherokee. Though she was close with her family and friends, she didn’t tell anyone she was leaving on a cross country journey. 5 days later, her car was found wrecked and abandoned 3000 miles from home in a ravine in Bellingham, Washington. There was no sign of Leah at the crash site and nobody has seen or...

Jan 20, 202156 minEp. 34

33: The Disappearance of Toni Lee Sharpless (S3 E7)

In the early morning hours of August 23, 2009, 29-year-old Toni Sharpless and her friend (THE DOWNEST BITCH OF ALL TIME) Crystal Johns left a party in the suburbs of Philadelphia. Toni was drunk—way too drunk to drive—and upset. Toni forced Crystal out of her car and then drove off into the night. Nobody ever saw her again. What happened? Where is Toni? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes ...

Jan 13, 202155 minEp. 33

32: The Disappearance of Jeremy Alex (S3 E6)

28-year-old Jeremy Alex had a carefree approach to life—He ‘worked to live rather than lived to work.’ His friends and girlfriend describe him as easy going and fun to be around. But suddenly there’s a dramatic change: the people around him notice that He’s paranoid, aggressive, and acting erratically. He starts telling people that bad guys are after him. And then, suddenly, he vanishes. His friends and family search for days, but come up with nothing. And it’s not until four years later that si...

Jan 06, 202155 minEp. 32

Interview: Rosa Schultz, sister of Roxanne Paltauf

In this interview, Rosa give us new information on her sister's case, shares new evidence that she uncovered herself, and tells us what she think happened to her sister. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the episodes of Disappeared - and our social media did, too! Follow us @ithinknotpod on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok and check out our website at www.ithinknotpod.com ! Learn more about your ad choi...

Dec 30, 202023 min

31: The Disappearance of Roxanne Paltauf (S3 E5)

Roxanne Paltauf vanished on July 7, 2006. She and her boyfriend had been staying at a Budget Inn in a rough section of Austin, Texas. According to the boyfriend, he and Roxanne got into a fight at about 8:30 pm and she stormed off, never to be seen again. But His story has holes and is impossible to verify. And when Roxanne's ID is found in the possession of another known sexual offender, her family fears the worst. WHERE. THE HELL. IS ROXANNE? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed ...

Dec 30, 202054 minEp. 31

30: The Disappearance of Brian Barton (S3 E4)

25-year-old Brian Barton vanished on March 10, 2005. He had a girlfriend, close friends, and was a member in a local Seattle band that was on the brink of making it big. So what happened? Could he have just up and walked out of his happy life? Is it possible, as the police would come to consider, that his girlfriend and bandmates murdered him? But why? And WHERE. THE HELL. IS BRIAN? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finish...

Dec 16, 202054 minEp. 30

29: The Disappearance of Molly Bish (S3 E3)

On June 26, 2000, 16-year-old Molly Bish vanished from the small Massachusetts pond where she was working as a lifeguard. Her mother Magi remembered seeing a strange man starting at Molly the morning before when Magi had dropped her off at the pond. Could he be involved? Soon, there were hundreds of law enforcement officials combing the woods, and searching the pond itself in what would be the largest manhunt in Massachusetts history. But very few clues emerge. So Where. The Hell. Is Molly? Hey,...

Dec 09, 202054 minEp. 29

28: The Disappearance of Patti Adkins (S3 E2)

June 29, 2001, PattI Adkins got into a pickup truck with a man she’d been seeing. PattI had told her family that the two were headed to a remote region of Canada for a week long getaway. There would be no cell service, so she’d be out of touch for the whole week. But when she never returned from the trip, and the man she’d left suddenly claimed the vacation never happened and that he hardly knew PattI, the family knew something was terribly wrong. Was the man lying? Had the trip never happened? ...

Dec 02, 202052 minEp. 28

INTERVIEW: Ellyn Talks With John Spira's Siblings, Stephanie and Tommy

In this exclusive interview, Ellyn chats with John's siblings about their reaction to the "Disappeared" episode, their feelings on what happened to John, and who may have been responsible. They tell Ellyn that this was never a missing persons case to them, it was always a homicide. What are the lingering questions in this case? Is it solvable? Was Renata involved? And WHERE. THE HHELL. IS JOHN SPIRA? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think No...

Nov 25, 202030 min

27: The Disappearance of the McStay Family (S3 E1)

Joseph and Summer McStay appeared to have it all--a thriving business, two beautiful kids that they adored, and a charmed life near the beach in southern California. But then, the family disappears from their San Diego home without a trace. Could the family have walked away from their seemingly perfect lives? Or could the McStay family have met with foul play? Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with: Disappeared transformed into I Think Not! after we finished recapping all the ep...

Nov 18, 202048 minEp. 27

26: The Disappearance of Kara Kopetsky (S2 E13)

Kara Koptesky, an out going and somewhat rebellious 17 year old, left for school on Monday May 4, 2007. She never came back. In the small town where she lives, rumors quickly circulate--she'd run away before, had she done it again? The police struggle to find any real leads. THEN ANOTHER LOCAL GIRL GOES MISSING. When the police find the body of a teenaged girl in a nearby forest, suddenly both families are locked in a grizzly waiting game. Hey, DBs! A message from the future here! Obsessed with:...

Nov 11, 202052 minEp. 26
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android