Hoosier Homicide - podcast cover

Hoosier Homicide

Danielle, Daniel, & Karlahoosierhomicide.podbean.com
A true crime comedy podcast by Hoosiers, for Hoosiers, or for anyone that doesn't know what a Hoosier is...we sure as hell don't!
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

All Good Things

All good things must come to an end. Thank you for the love and support you have given this podcast over the past 2.5 years!!! We never could have done this without you. The live show is still taking place at the Vogue on July 18th but we will not be performing... we are so sorry to make this announcement, but please still attend the live show!! It will be amazing and the other podcasters deserve all the support. And for Honest to Goodness, Stay Out of the Corn! -Danielle, Daniel, and Karla...

Jul 10, 20202 minSeason 3Ep. 118

Sarah Jo Pender Update Part II

This episode picks up directly where part I left off so listen to that first!! Why would prosecutes refer to Sarah as the "Female Charles Manson?" She was convicted along with her former boyfriend of murdering their roommates in Indianapolis in 2000. She didn't pull the trigger, but she pulled the strings...maybe?...probably not though. Disclaimer: Unoffendable Adults Only! Explicit content provided by three unbalanced family members...proceed at your own risk! Live show!!!! July 18th buy ticket...

Jun 26, 202056 minSeason 3Ep. 117

Sarah Jo Pender Update Part I

Why would prosecutes refer to Sarah as the "Female Charles Manson?" She was convicted along with her former boyfriend of murdering their roommates in Indianapolis in 2000. She didn't pull the trigger, but she pulled the strings...maybe?...probably not though. Audio clips from Oxygen's Snapped First things first! Roosters get cockblocked, problematic middle school homework, and who even started turnitin.com? We hate that person. But skip to 14:30 minutes because it's all so dumb! Disclaimer: Unof...

Jun 18, 202050 minSeason 3Ep. 116

The Nose Knows Part II

In part II of this episode, an ENT doctor from Chicago has decided that over 300 malpractice lawsuits are enough justification to abandon his current life in pursuit of something a little more adventurous. Karla goes to an impromptu wedding, food trucks, and Disney's porn collection. Please skip all of this at 15 minutes in for your own sanity I beg you!! Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! Explicit, crude, graphic content provided by three unbalanced family members...proceed at your own risk! For m...

Jun 04, 202054 minSeason 3Ep. 115

The Nose Knows Part I

The nose knows except when an entitled and ruthless ENT doctor in Merryville, IN decides that the more unnecessary sinus surgeries he performs, the more money he will make. Where's Karla? No 500 and a listener story! Blow right on by to 17 minutes in if that makes you feel better!! Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! Explicit, crude, graphic content provided by three unbalanced family members...proceed at your own risk! For more of our Patreon episodes, follow the link below for just a $1 a month ge...

May 28, 20201 hr 4 minSeason 3Ep. 114

Wacko Waco Part II

In part II of this episode the final assault on the Waco compound, known as Mount Carmel, and the Branch Davidians inside it takes place. Followed by the legal battle that ensued to find the answer to one burning question, "who started the fire?" This episode contains SPOILERS on the Netflix series Waco!!! Daniel gets a golden shower, fish cakes, and Mother's Day kick off the episode but you can skip to your hearts content to 10:30 minutes to avoid that nonsense. Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! ...

May 14, 20201 hr 5 minSeason 3Ep. 113

Wacko Waco Part I

In part one of this episode we discuss events leading up to the 1993 ATF raid on a religious faction known as The Branch Davidians. The leader of this suspected cult was David Koresh who's prophecies on the impending apocalypse are justified as the two groups exchange massive amounts of gunfire during a 51 day stand off. This episode contains SPOILERS on the Netflix series Waco!!! First! We talk about our religious experiences in the form of song...so skip to 14 minutes in and save yourself from...

May 07, 20201 hr 13 minSeason 3Ep. 112

The Eleven Month Rule Part II

Dawn was told it would all be over soon, her stalker would be gone, and she just had to hold on a little longer. How long would it take to get this madman out of her life? And would he ever be prosecuted for his crimes? But first! Patreon members need stickers (resend your addresses please), a few good reviews, and some "shelter in place" activities... skip to 9:30 minutes in to get this show on the road! https://www.safehorizon.org/ https://hidinghilda.com/blogs/stalked Unoffendable Adults Only...

Apr 30, 20201 hr 10 minSeason 3Ep. 111

The Eleven Month Rule Part I

Michael understood that he was just a casual dating partner and when the relationship ended it was on good terms with no hurt feelings or resentment… until 11 months later that is. Which would result in an on slot of never-ending emails, text messages, and unwanted appearances. Danielle goes on a strange adventure and is also exposed as a juvenile delinquent… spare her the embarrassment of this story by jumping to 11 minutes in. https://www.safehorizon.org/ https://hidinghilda.com/blogs/stalked ...

Apr 23, 20201 hr 8 minSeason 3Ep. 110

A Stalker Exposed

Stalking is a crime and so is exposing yourself to the unsuspecting public. When a man decides he can bare it all from his windows and front yard, the town of Dillsboro, Indiana is none too pleased with his escalating antics. Then we talk about a few strange cases of erotomania and celebrity stalking. Karla is back!! Followed by a couple emotional break downs, getting punked by a four-year-old, and you might be able to listen to audio books through your local library for free! You can skip all t...

Apr 16, 20201 hr 27 minSeason 3Ep. 109

Dirty Mary (Patreon Preview)

In the spirit of communicable diseases we talk about an Irish immigrant who spread the bacterium Salmonella Typhi around New York in the early 1900's. This immigrant would be labeled Typhoid Mary throughout history for her part in spreading the disease. Still no Karla! She's ok though, Daniel gets a telemarketer call, and we talk about the only thing that matters now...Tiger King!! Things get exotic at 15 minutes in if you want to skip. For more of our Patreon episodes, follow the link below for...

Apr 02, 202056 minSeason 3Ep. 108

Astro-nuts!

In the first part of this episode we discuss the first active duty astronaut to be charged with a felony. It is a twisted story of dedication, determination, and…diapers? Next Daniel discusses the Challenger shuttle disaster and how it might have been more preventable than not. No press is bad press, unless you are NASA! Before we blast off: Karla is still missing and New York has fascinating Corona virus sex guidelines!! But you can skip to lift off at 14 minutes in. Unoffendable Adults Only! N...

Mar 26, 20201 hr 13 minSeason 3Ep. 107

The Bloodiest of Benders

In 1870, travelers continue to go missing off the Great Osage Trail in Kansas. A family of five immigrants happened to live off this same trail and often allowed travelers into their cabin for the night. Strange as this family may seem, no one suspected that the Benders could cause any real harm…could they? Nobody will shut up about this god damn virus, including us! You can always skip the insanity by jumping to 15 minutes in. For perspective, this episode was recorded on Sunday night March 15t...

Mar 19, 202059 minSeason 3Ep. 106

D.B. Cooper Cash and Burn Part II

Portland International Airport in 1971 D.B. Cooper hijacked Flight 305, a Boeing 727, bound for Seattle. Almost 1,000 different suspects were questioned by the FBI and yet none of them have been definitively linked to the hijacking. But how many men subsequently felt the need to be a D.B. Cooper copycat? We talk about child birthday parties, thongs, clogged toilets, and Dr. Pepper... we hijack this episode and can't shut up until 22:30 so skip if you need to save your soul from our stupidity!! U...

Mar 12, 20201 hr 6 minSeason 3Ep. 105

D.B. Cooper Cash and Burn Part I

Portland International Airport 1971, D.B. Cooper hijacked Flight 305, a Boeing 727, bound for Seattle. A polite man in his mid-40’s with dark sunglasses requested $200,000 in “negotiable American currency” and four parachutes. Did he survive the jump to spend the cash? Or is this still a mystery that may never be solved? First: possum dog, Instagram advertisement, home remodeling, lost soap, and airplane flight fun. It is all funny but skip the laughs and jump to 15 minutes in if you want! Crash...

Feb 27, 20201 hr 31 minSeason 3Ep. 104

Betty Broderick's American Cream Pie (re-release)

From the 2018 archives: You've probably heard this story, but this episode is a good one... Betty Broderick meets her future husband Dan at the legendary University of Notre Dame in 1965. One fateful fun filled football weekend leads to the bizarre story of love, adultery, rage, and the vow "until death do us part." Some mispronounced cities, Hitler cat, neighborhood awareness, and the Staircase. Also, Sister Mary Elephant is from Cheech and Chong we now know. Yes someone is moving their mic aro...

Feb 20, 20201 hr 26 minSeason 3Ep. 103

The Killer Club Kids

The Club Kids culture was thriving in New York, following the death of Andy Warhol in 1987, and brought into existence with the help of Michael Alig from South Bend, Indiana. He was a talented club promoter that eventually found himself addicted to drugs and with the murdered body of one of his friends in his apartment bathtub. Karla talks about some IU falls, Utah trip, a couple reviews, and some tattoos. Party starts at 17:30 minutes in! Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! Explicit, crude, graphic...

Feb 13, 20201 hr 18 minSeason 3Ep. 102

Nancy E. Clem's Wild Buggy Ride of 1868 (Re-release)

From the 2018 archives: When the bodies of a young couple are discovered by the White River in Indianapolis the police of 1868 follow the clues to an unlikely suspect. Listen now to find out exactly what a young Benjamin Harrison (the would be 23rd President of the United States) was doing there. The case starts at 15 minutes in! However, the first part connects to the rest of this episode so we suggest not skipping this time. Karla tells an outlandish story of loss, confusion, alcohol, and rede...

Feb 06, 20201 hr 7 minSeason 3Ep. 101

The Super Bowl of Murder

Fred Lane was an NFL running back traded to the Indianapolis Colts in April 2000. However, his wife shot him in the entryway of their home seven days after giving birth to their child. Was this a case of domestic violence that ended tragically or was there something more that his wife was after? We then discuss a former Carolina Panthers player, Rae Carruth, who really hated paying child support and would go to diabolical lengths to avoid handing over his hard-earned cash. First we need to talk ...

Jan 30, 20201 hr 16 minSeason 3Ep. 100

Shelia Davalloo and the Wrong Purdue

Shelia Davalloo met Nelson Sessler while working for the pharmaceutical company Purdue Pharma in 2001 and they began to have a romantic relationship. The only problem being that Shelia was already married, but this would not deter her from her devious ambitions in life that would ultimately result in one murder and one attempted murder. First! We talk about Karla's company party, Daniel's cockblock at Target, and then we thank our lovely Patreon supporters!!! Jump to 14 minutes in for your own s...

Jan 23, 20201 hr 42 minSeason 3Ep. 99

A Not So Happy Face

Keith Hunter Jesperson was a long-haul truck driver that used his profession as a means to abduct, murder, and dispose of his victims in several different states over the course of five years. Wanting to take credit for his crimes, Keith began writing anonymous letters to the media using a happy face as his signature and thus creating “The Happy Face Killer.” We talk about Blippi until 7:45 min... you can skip it Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! Explicit, crude, graphic content provided by three ...

Jan 16, 20201 hr 21 minSeason 3Ep. 98

I Did It For the Views Part I (Patreon Preview)

YouTube is a lawless wasteland of mind numbing content and people just can't get enough of it! Prompting thousands of attention seeking YouTubers to perform various stunts or gimmicks in hopes of garnishing the most viewership and to make it big as a social media entertainer. These are their stories... Danielle and Daniel ramble on until about 11 minutes in! If you'd like to listen to part II of this episode and to many others you can go to our Patreon and subscribe for as little as a $1 a month...

Jan 09, 202056 minSeason 2Ep. 97

A Diary of Fires (Re-release)

Thomas Sweatt uses his skills as an arsonist to satisfy his strange sexual urges for decades, until DNA connects him to several D.C. fires in 2005. Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! Explicit, crude, graphic content provided by three unbalanced family members...proceed at your own risk! We have some merchandise available! https://www.teepublic.com/user/hoosierhomicide Find us: instagram.com/hoosierhomicide and twitter.com/Hoosierhomicide Like us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/hoosierhomicide Check o...

Dec 26, 201948 minSeason 2Ep. 96

International Family Garbage

In part II we discuss a sex cult currently known as The Family International that originated in California in the late 1960's. Extra Disclaimer: child sexual abuse is referenced in this episode. We get right to the topic this time, but things go astray around 37 minutes in!! Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! Explicit, crude, graphic content provided by three unbalanced family members...proceed at your own risk! Subscribe to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/hoosierhomicide We have some mercha...

Dec 19, 201946 minSeason 2Ep. 95

Our's Is The One True Way

If you were in a doomsday cult, would you be able to recognize it? In part I of this episode we talk about a UFO cult that originated in Taiwan called The One True Way and how they decided Gary, Indiana was a holy place… First: Karla had a bad day, our crap high school, and Patreon people rock! If you hate laughter than skip to 18 minutes in...And please go subscribe to Vigils in the Dark now!! Instagram @dark_vigils twitter @vigilsinthedark and www.vigilsinthedark.com Unoffendable Adults Only! ...

Dec 12, 20191 hr 8 minSeason 2Ep. 94

Alfred Packer's Sweet Baby Ray's

"The Colorado Cannibal" spent some time during his childhood in Indiana before heading to Colorado in the winter of 1874. Alfred Packer would join a small group of men during their expedition for gold, offering himself as an expert guide...this was one of many lies he would tell. But first: the RV Christmas Miracle, baby Yoda, and Thanksgiving. Please skip all this and jump to 10 minutes in to get to the "meat" of the subject. Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! Explicit, crude, graphic content prov...

Dec 05, 20191 hr 6 minSeason 2Ep. 93

The Barefoot Bandit Can Fly

Colton Harris-Moore was a young kid with a troubled up bringing when he realized his special gift for breaking and entering homes or businesses. It was just for popcorn and a shower at first, but eventually he would decide to steal cash, guns, and as many airplanes as he possible could. We talk about recent family vacations and then we needed to hear all about Karla’s human sexuality class at IU…. Its’ gross and we are sorry….kinda. You can save yourself and skip to 23 minutes in!! Unoffendable ...

Nov 28, 20191 hr 13 minSeason 2Ep. 92

True Crime Podcasters of Indy

Four amazing Indiana based podcasts gathered together to share their motivation for starting a podcast and just how important this passion is to them. Listen now to hear unique stories, connections, and future plans from Circle City Crime, Infamous Indy, Cold Case Chronicles, and Hoosier Homicide. Please go subscribe and give these guys five stars!! Find them on Instagram: @3cpodcastindy @infamousindypod @coldcasechronicles @hoosierhomicide Unoffendable Adults Only! Proceed at your own risk! Sub...

Nov 21, 201947 minSeason 2Ep. 91

When Hackers Attack

In 2018, a young woman from Indiana follows her hacker boyfriend to the Philippines believing that she will be there to support his business ventures. However, her boyfriend’s long-time scheming friend has other plans once he senses that she might know too much about their criminal activity. To start us off: Daniel dabbles in ASMR, Danielle’s birthday, and Karla is back from Vegas! The episode really gets it together around the 11 minute marker. Unoffendable Adults Only! NSFW! Explicit, crude, g...

Nov 07, 20191 hr 11 minSeason 2Ep. 90

Barb and the Infamous Ghosts of Indy

Our good friend Barb joins us for this episode as we share spooky stories about the ghosts of Irvington, Indiana. A place haunted by infamous apparitions such as Abraham Lincoln, D.C. Stephenson, and H.H. Holmes. Then we travel to the House of Blue Lights where they are ever blinking in the distance, long after the strange Gatsby style building has been demolished. The lingering legends begin at 7 minutes in! And go check out Joe at Infamous Indy for more on Irvington and other great Indiana sto...

Oct 31, 20191 hr 18 minSeason 2Ep. 89
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android