4-21 Judgment Day

The proverbial chickens come home to roost when the Watchers decide to punish Joe for his reckless fraternization with his subject, Duncan MacLeod, by locking him in a cartoon fun house and scheduling him for summary execution. Mac and Methos dust off their favorite reused clips of previous episodes in an effort to save Joe's life, while a mysterious rider in a Canadian Tuxedo goes on a Watcher assassination spree. The Rewatchers discuss Joe's sham trial in the poorly lit basement of Watcher HQ, whether Joe is trapped in a surprise bottle episode, and how this episode holds up as an unintentional Season 4 finale.