How To Live Like A Monk - podcast episode cover

How To Live Like A Monk

Nov 27, 202136 minEp. 56
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Summary

Matt Lewis and historian Danièle Cybulskie delve into the world of medieval monks, defining their purpose, vows, and daily routines while distinguishing them from friars. They explore the practical and spiritual motivations for joining a monastery, the challenges of cloistered life, and how monks managed issues like human frailty and mental health. The discussion highlights the surprising relevance of monastic practices like mindfulness, structured living, and communal support for contemporary well-being, suggesting how ancient wisdom can offer lessons for finding purpose and balance in today's world.

Episode description

Monks. We know that they dedicated their lives to serving God, but what did it mean to be a Monk? In today's, episode Matt is joined by the Five-Minute Medievalist, Danièle Cybulskie. Author, historian, and Podcaster (to name a few), Danièle is well known to many Medieval history enthusiasts. We explore the lives of Monks, from mindfulness to identity and purpose. What can we learn from the Monks, to be happier in today's world?


If you’re enjoying this podcast and looking for more fascinating Medieval content then subscribe to our Medieval Monday newsletter here.


Music by: Katcamusic

Title: Spiritual Lords

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

Intro / Opening

Hello, I'm Matt Lewis. And I'm Dr. Eleanor Janaga. And we're just popping up here to tell you some insider info. If you would like to listen to Gone Medieval ad-free and get early access in bonus episodes, sign up to History Hit. With the History Hit subscription, you can also watch hundreds of hours of original documentaries. Such as my new series on everyone's favourite conquerors, the Normans. Or my recent exploration of the castles that made Britain.

There's a new release to enjoy every week. Sign up now by visiting historyhit.com forward slash subscribe or find the link in the show notes for this episode. Did you order the new iPhone 17 Pro? Got it from Verizon, the best 5G network in America. It never looked so good. You look the same. But with this camera, everything looks better, especially me. You haven't changed your hair in 15 years. Selfies?

Check, please. New and existing customers can get the new iPhone 17 Pro. Designed to be the most powerful iPhone ever. With eligible phone trade-in and unlimited ultimate. Any condition guaranteed. Best 5G source, root metrics, data, United States, 1H, 2025. All rights reserved. Trade-in and additional terms apply for all offers. See verizon.com for details. AI had the time of my life

From building timelines to assigning the right people and even spotting risks across dozens of projects, Monday Sidekick knows your business, thinks ahead, and takes action. One click on the star and consider it done. And I owe it all to you. Try Monday Sidekick. AI you'll love to use on Monday.com.

Hey, what's up? It's Mario Lopez. Back to school is an exciting time, but it can also be overwhelming and kids may feel isolated. A vulnerability that human traffickers can exploit. Human trafficking doesn't always look like what you expect. Everyday moments can become opportunities for someone with bad intentions. Whether you're a parent, teacher, coach, or neighbor, check in. Ask questions. Stay connected.

Blue Campaign is a national awareness initiative that provides resources to help recognize suspected instances of human trafficking. Learn the signs and how to report at dhs.gov slash blue campaign. Welcome to this episode of Gone Medieval from History Hit. I'm Matt Lewis. Danielle Cebulski needs no introduction to many of you who are interested in the medieval period. She's an author, a historian, a YouTuber and a podcaster who also goes by the name of the Five Minute Medievalist.

Danielle's newest book is called How to Live Like a Monk and takes a look at how this significant portion of the medieval society organized their lives and spent their time. So I'm really looking forward to finding out more. And thank you very much for joining us, Danielle.

Thank you so much. It's a pleasure to be here on another medieval podcast. I love it. I know it's strange when you host your own to be a guest on another one, isn't it? It's a little nerve-wracking, yeah, but I'm going to do my best. Busman's holiday. So first of all, to start us off with this book.

Defining Medieval Monasticism

What is a monk? How did they fit into the structure of the clergy? And what was the purpose of being a monk? Okay, so these are all big questions. So I'm going to do my best here. So a monk is a member... of the clergy, the clergy being pretty much anyone that's associated with the church. So we're talking about clerks, we're talking about priests, bishops, monks, and friars. So monks are the ones that have agreed to live a cloistered life. So the main difference between monks and

everybody else is they are living in a monastery. And I use monks in this book. for shorthand, because monks and nuns would be a very long title, but let's remember that nuns are part of this as well. So they're the ones that have taken vows to live in a cloistered environment, and they've taken vows that usually involve poverty, chastity, and obedience.

But there's a difference between monks and friars, and I think they get kind of conflated a lot of the time. Friars are people that have taken these vows, usually poverty, chastity, and obedience, but they live out in the world. So someone who's wandering around... around a Franciscan, a Dominican.

an Augustinian, these are friars. They sometimes live in a monastery, but they don't necessarily have to, whereas monks are mostly Benedictines, Cistercians, Cluniacs, and they are the ones that are meant to live within the walls of a cloister. So that's the main difference. There are all sorts of shades of being as a monk, but that's the main difference. And their purpose in life is to serve God as best they can. So they do that by mostly praying, but also doing work.

like work that will support the monastery itself, work that will support the community outside of the walls, whether that's working in a hospital, whether that's writing things, writing chronicles, for example, or copying books, or just ministering.

as best they can. But most of the time, the way that they're serving God best is by praying in a monastery. So I think we're guilty sometimes, aren't we, of thinking monks, priests, bishops, all of these kind of things, they're pretty much the same thing, but they actually lived... quite different lives and live their lives in very different ways that we don't normally take account of. Sometimes we blur the lines sometimes and use the words interchangeably when we shouldn't.

Yeah, yeah. It's not always necessary to have strict divisions when you're talking about it because... People like monks and friars, they do have a lot of the same vows. But when we're trying to define what is a monk for a book that's about monks and nuns, the main difference is that they are cloistered. And was the life of a monk something that would appeal to a medieval person?

Were people keen to make the choice to go into that cloistered life? Did it have something about it that appealed? Or was it ever sort of not a choice? Was it something you had to do? Well, it was meant to be a choice. And in fact, this was something that theologians argued about quite a lot, because especially in the earlier part of the Middle Ages, you could give a child to the monastery. These are oblates. I'm never sure if I'm saying it's...

oblates or oblates but these are the children that are given to the monastery to be raised and actually this was a point of contention for a couple reasons boys can be very noisy and difficult to control they're not necessarily the best contributors to a monastic lifestyle that's supposed to be about serenity and contemplation. And then the other part of that is that if they've been given to the church into a monastery, they haven't had the choice. They haven't made the choice to live.

as a monk, they kind of are there by default. And so the... Fourth Lateran Council, I think in 1215, that the Pope says, you can't do this anymore. Oblation is not going to be something that happens. If you give a child to the monastery to be educated, then they still have to make the choice to be a monk later on, and they can leave if they want.

want. So sometimes they didn't have a choice, mostly in the early Middle Ages, but later on they were meant to definitely have a choice because it's a vocation that you are meant to choose so that you can serve God as best you can. It was appealing to people

for a whole bunch of reasons. I mean, at a very basic level, if you were impoverished, you could go to a monastery and you could get your meals every day. You could get clothing. You could have a place to stay. You could have a community. So I'm sure there were people that got in there. because it was a good option for them if they had nowhere else to go. So there's that.

Then there are people who might join a monastery because it's the place to get educated. They were really the ones who were in charge of education in the Middle Ages. So if you were a boy and your parents wanted you educated or you wanted to be educated, you could go to the monastery. And if you were a young man, you wanted to continue your education, you could do it there. You could perpetually just.

do lifelong learning at the monastery because they had all the books and they encouraged a lot of reading and study. So that would be something that was appealing as well. And these are very practical considerations. But the real reason that most people joined a monastery was because they were

They wanted to actually serve God with their lives. So while there are practical reasons, I think we should take them into account. Most of the people that joined a monastery, especially voluntarily, or they did it later in life, they did it because they wanted to serve God.

the purpose of their lives that they chose. And I think, again, we can sometimes, in our more secular world, forget the compulsion to live your life in a way that would get you to heaven. You know, this time on earth was incredibly brief and fleeting.

They were really concerned about what happened after that in a way that perhaps a lot of people aren't so much today. So we might think it's odd to sort of spend your entire life praying and hoping that something else nicer will come along afterwards. But that was a really serious... deeply felt and believed conviction that they held at the time yeah yeah and when i

took on this book so this book was pitched to me by the publisher abbeville press and i really went back and forth with them quite a lot trying to establish the fact that the book i wanted to write was to really be respectful to their faith so even if i'm writing it from a secular

perspective, I really wanted to make sure that as I went through the book, which has a lot of stuff about self help, it's a crossover between history and positive psychology and self help, that we really kept the focus on the fact that Whether we believe or not, the people who are living a monastic lifestyle in the Middle Ages, as the people who are living a monastic lifestyle today, are doing it for devotional.

reasons and we shouldn't discount that. It's a very important part of their lives and we should never forget that when we're considering monks. So there are practical and spiritual reasons.

Vows, Challenges, and Daily Life

to become a monk and things that you gained from that experience? Were there things that you lost from that? What did you have to give up to become a monk? Well, the biggest thing was you had to be chased. And this is something that both monks and nuns struggled with. So there's always people who are getting in trouble for not being chased. So giving up your sexuality.

is something that you have to do if you're going to become a monk. But you also have to give up your life to obedience. And so this is something that is really...

At the forefront of the rules of St. Benedict, and the rules of St. Benedict are a real foundation for Western monastic lifestyle, especially in the Middle Ages. So in the rules for St. of saint benedict he mentions that you need to obey your abbot in all things so you basically are giving up yourself you're giving up your free will whatever the abbot tells you to do you must

do. And so that can be difficult. It was difficult for people then. And I think a lot of people now would find that very difficult as well. So it was a struggle that people had. And they had to do things like getting up in the middle of the night or eating the same food over and over.

and over again. So these were things that were challenges. You gave up a lot of the free will that you had as a purposeful act of serving God. So it's not something that was an easy life and that was deliberate. It was meant to be a difficult life because that was...

the way to serve God best. So these are like the major athletes of the spiritual world. They are the ones that are doing the hard work for everybody else. They're praying for everybody else to help everyone get into heaven as well as themselves. So it's a difficult...

life, but that was on purpose. What would a monk's daily life have looked like? I guess I fluctuated my head between thinking it was this rigidly structured and incredibly monotonous thing that follows the hours of the day, for example.

But does it also change with the season? So the farming seasons, they worked quite often in the fields or they were affected by longer days of light if they're working or writing or anything like that. Was it kind of monotonous or did it change or is it a bit of both? It's both. It's both. It's monotonous. So you do have to follow the canonical hours. So at certain hours during the day, you must stop what you're doing and you must pray. This is...

Non-negotiable, everybody has to do this. Well, there are some exceptions, depending on whether you are a brother that maybe was taking care of visitors, for example. You might be excused from a mass, but everybody else has to go and pray at these certain times. But as you say, they did...

have a huge involvement in creating their own food, for example, or working. So those tasks would change over the course of the year. So sometimes you'd be planting, sometimes you'd be harvesting, sometimes you would be, you know, chopping firewood or bringing firewood to the monastery. So these things changed over the course.

of the seasons and they also changed a little bit over the course of the christian religious year so there is more of a focus on reading during lent for example so i think that would probably be my favorite time of the liturgical year where you get to spend a bit more time reading at

and everybody would be given a library book which they were supposed to take care of in return so there were things that did change over the course of the year but it was a very monotonous life and again this was on purpose this was to make sure that no prayers were missed and that nobody was living such a free life that they would get distracted from their duties. So it is both monotonous and it did change seasonally. As long as no one was happy, it was okay. Yeah, yeah. Well, we know that...

Human Nature in Monastic Life

Monks did a whole bunch of things to get around rules. I mean, St. Benedict says like no frivolity. So one of the things I think is funny and I put in the book was that when the bells ring. for the canonical hours, you're supposed to drop what you're doing and you're supposed to go and go to the church and you're supposed to pray. But St. Benedict specifically says you should do this in a way that does not spark frivolity.

So like no racing your brothers to church and seeing like who could get there faster while still looking like they're not rushing. Like you're not allowed to do that stuff. So St. Benedict, he tries to really tamp down on fun and in lots of ways. And to me, I think. When you're looking at historical records like this, so many of us historians will look at law codes, for example, or guidelines and realize that these are in place in part because people are being too silly in the monastery.

And they were doing things like sneaking in pets or, you know, spending money they weren't supposed to. So they weren't always as serious as they were supposed to be, but they were supposed to be quite serious all the time. And I think if there's elements of the monk's life that we can't identify with, that we struggle to get to grips with or relate to, those elements of being naughty and being told off for breaking the rules and finding ways to be naughty within the rules.

It's probably something that most of us can still identify with today. Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. So these are human beings and they're awesome. do things that are very difficult. I mean, you have to get up in the middle of the night to pray, for example. That would be very difficult for me. And it was very difficult for lots of monks. So they're getting in trouble for oversleeping. And if they oversleep and they show up late, they're supposed to basically...

just stand there in the corner and be visible for everybody. So there are breaking rules all the time. Because it is hard. It is challenging. And I think that the more we try to see a human face to these mugs, the more we realize that the thing that they're asking of themselves, this lifestyle, is very difficult. And so we don't have to pick up those things.

things as ways to live like a monk. You don't have to wake up at midnight and pray if you don't want to. That's not what's in this book, but we do need to recognize that. It was a difficult life for them. And they had the same human failings that we do, especially when it comes to meeting these challenges. And writing has always been a central part to what some monks at least did. So did you feel any kind of...

symmetry with that as you were writing this or did you feel this was a very different kind of thing that you were doing for a very different purpose? Well, we had different purposes for sure in that I come at it from a...

secular point of view, and they're obviously coming at it from a point of view of faith, like great amounts of faith, and everything they are doing is related back to that. But we are doing the same thing, monks and me, in that we are trying to share the things that we have learned.

with a future audience or a greater audience so that they can learn from this and maybe live in a better way or live in a way that is more satisfying to them. So a monk might be writing something in the hopes that the people who are reading that are going to become more. spiritual are going to have a firmer footing on the path to salvation. And my hope is that people will read my book and find little ways that we can really relate to monks.

These are ways that maybe we can change our lives in small ways to make our lives healthier or make ourselves happier. So we have two distinct purposes, but we are trying to share knowledge with people in order to help them out.

Yeah, you have monks that are not only recording things that have been written before, so they'll be making copies of books that exist and hoping that more people will read these books, but they'll also be doing things like chronicling as a way to reach out to the community. not only in their day, but in posterity for posterity as well. So they are showing you what happened in their lives and then they will put...

an overlay of faith on top of that and say, you can see how God works through these actions that happened in our lives. So yeah, we have totally different purposes, but we are both trying to do good in the world, I think, by the way that we are writing and copying. Yeah, I think any medieval historian has to be grateful for all those monk chroniclers who were recording all of this information for us whilst also reading it.

understanding that in their heads, everything had to have this moral tale to it, had to be a demonstration of God at work. Either God is unhappy. So this has happened. or God is now appeased, so everything's gone back to being great. The amount of times a freak weather event accompanies something terrible that happens in a year and all that kind of thing, there is always a moral tale to it. But without them, we wouldn't know so much of what went on.

Yeah, exactly. And you can read between the lines. So you do have an example from Bury St. Edmunds. There is an example I put in the book where Jocelyn of Rakelund says there was a fire at Bury St. Edmunds and it really damaged the shrine. And the abbot says it's because we all complain too much about the food.

But I think it was God's way of making the shrine more visible or putting it in a different spot. So it does have moral overtones to these stories. And it's funny how they actually diverge, right? So the abbot has a different spin on what. God's thinking sounds a bit more like a parent's view as well doesn't it you know there's a moral tale in here to make you behave that's right

Yeah. God's not happy that you're all complaining to me. So shut up and get with your job and God will be happy. Yeah, exactly. And it's funny that, you know, you have Jocelyn sort of on the slide saying, I don't think that's what's going on. And this book you mentioned a little bit earlier.

The Power of Monastic Mindfulness

does have an element of a kind of self-help guide looking at things that I think we might call mindfulness do you think that's a reasonable assessment of the way the book addresses being a monk yes so again We have different purposes to our writing, but it is very much a book that's meant to teach us how to live like monks. So what can we learn from monastic lifestyle? I'm not trying to convince anyone to be a monk. I wouldn't be the best person for that job.

talk about small ways that we can make ourselves healthy and one of those ways is to be mindful of what we are doing so there's mindfulness is something that is thrown around a lot these days, but it's basically just being aware of what you're doing. So whether that's you're being aware of the food you're putting in your mouth, you're being aware of how much exercise that you're getting, you're being aware of the thoughts and the information that you're taking in.

every day just being aware of these things so a monk being mindful is one that is thinking of every situation and how this is tied back to God. So we are looking at the food on the table and we're thinking about how God has provided this for us. Isn't it amazing how he's made these plants and animals? So mindfulness for a monk is always coming back to God and his place in the world.

and his place in their own lives. Mindfulness today, in a secular way of thinking, is just thinking about being aware of this present moment because we're usually... So distracted, right? There's always notifications or things going on in the background. So it's a way of reconnecting to who you are at this moment, what you're experiencing at this moment and kind of quieting everything down and really helping you to focus on the things that are important.

So we have a different purpose to mindfulness, but it is one of the ways that I think we should emulate monks is to be mindful of everything that we are taking in or experiencing through the day. And it was striking how much of a monk's daily routine did focus on what we would call mindfulness. So even that stopping for the canonical hours, you have to stop. Stop everything that you're doing.

and be mindful of what time of day it is, what prayers you should be saying at that point, your relationship with God at that moment. As you say, you sit down for food, maybe say grace before a meal.

It makes you mindful of the fact that you're about to eat this food that has come from somewhere. Someone's provided it for you. You're sitting now having a meal and doing all of this. It's almost like they punctuated the day with deliberate stops to take stock of what they were doing and why they were doing it, which is... what we've lost and what I think mindfulness tries to encourage us to recover.

Yeah, that's exactly right. That's exactly right. Because everything that monks did was ritualized in order to bring their thoughts back to what they're doing. So every time they get up in the morning, they're supposed to cross themselves three times, you know, and then they get dressed, they're supposed to cross.

themselves three times or they go into the church they see a crucifix they genuflect all of these things it's constant touchstones as you say throughout the day to remind them why they're there and what they're doing and so people have tried to bring this back I do mention this in the

book, gratitude is something that monks are practicing all the time. We are thankful for the food and we are thankful we are here that we can say these prayers. Gratitude is something that's actually really healthy for us today. And I mentioned some studies about this in the book. the more we are thankful, the more we are happy. And so some of the ways that people try and bring that mindfulness back to our secular lives now is by...

finding little ways to remind ourselves. Some people will put little rocks in their pocket and every time they reach into their pocket, they'll be reminded, this is a moment I should take for gratitude. And so monks have built this into their days. And if we want to be healthier, we want to be more mindful, it's useful.

to find ways to remind ourselves of these things over the course of the day, whether that's every day I'm going to write three things I'm grateful for in the morning, or every evening I'm going to do this, or I'm going to put a rock in my pocket. All of these things to center us back to. who we are as people, what's important to us as people, whether that's our faith, whether that's personal goals.

We want to have more success in a career. We want to have more success as a family person. All of these things are goals that we have, values that we have. And if we have little touchstones throughout our lives, that's something we can learn from monks that might help keep us centered and might help keep us. more successful and happier too. Hi, I'm Professor Susanna Lipscomb, and in my podcast, Not Just the Tudors, we talk about everything from sex to spying.

wardrobes to witch trials. Not, in other words, just the Tudors, but most definitely also the Tudors. Subscribe from History Hit wherever you get your podcasts. This episode is brought to you by Royal Kingdom, the latest puzzle game from the creators of Royal Match. When I first heard about Royal Kingdom, it seemed too good to be true.

Royal Kingdom is a relaxing yet challenging puzzle game with high quality graphics and beautifully animated cutscenes. You can download Royal Kingdom for free, play without being interrupted by ads, and even... without Wi-Fi too, so it's the ideal companion for holidays and long trips, as well as sneaking in a couple of rounds in the evening.

The levels vary and different types of challenges are woven in to keep it engaging. Completing levels lets you build your kingdom, so I'm already interested. But what do you know, one of the main characters is King Richard, who's battling the Dark King to save his realm. I mean, was this game just made for me? So download Royal Kingdom for free on the App Store or Google Play today.

Hey, what's up? It's Mario Lopez. Back to school is an exciting time, but it can also be overwhelming and kids may feel isolated. A vulnerability that human traffickers can exploit. Human trafficking doesn't always look like what you expect. Everyday moments can become opportunities for someone with bad intentions. Whether you're a parent, teacher, coach, or neighbor, check in. Ask questions. Stay connected.

Blue Campaign is a national awareness initiative that provides resources to help recognize suspected instances of human trafficking. Learn the signs and how to report at dhs.gov slash blue campaign. The time of my life. From building timelines to assigning the right people and even spotting risks across dozens of projects, Monday Sidekick knows your business, thinks ahead, and takes action. One click on the star and consider it done.

And I owe it all to you. Try Monday Sidekick, AI you'll love to use, on Monday.com. History has made this world of ours. I'd like to tell you about my show, Dan Snow's History Hit, that really explains everything that's ever happened. The origin stories of the cities we inhabit, or of what's in our kitchen cupboards. Why we've always been drawn to dictators.

the greatest discoveries, inventions, and mistakes ever made. For curious stories, check out Dan Snow's history hit wherever you get your podcasts.

Finding Purpose and Modern Relevance

And I think one of the key features of being a monk is this idea that you lose yourself. You don't have this focus on your own identity. And that's perhaps something that we struggle with today and that can be...

bad for our mental health the amount of time we spend on social media worrying about what we think of ourselves what people think of us how we see ourselves do you think that contributes to our struggles and that perhaps we can learn something from monks in that sense of not being so concerned with the self

Well, this is a question that I was really glad you sent to me beforehand because I really, I thought about this one quite a lot. So yes, if you are an actual monk, you're meant to suppress yourself in a lot of ways, give up yourself and really just become a vehicle. So this is the... reason that we have a lot of anonymous chronicles the self is not important enough for you to sign your name to your work you're supposed to just be a vehicle for god

And we today are very concerned with our individuality and trying to figure out who we are as people. At the same time, we're not spending a lot of time. actually doing that figuring out. We know that we want to be individuals. We know that we have some goals perhaps that we want to reach, but we're not spending that time in contemplation and actually thinking that through. What is?

important to me? What do I want? So I think that in our search for our individuality, what perhaps a lot of us are missing is purpose. And that doesn't mean that we are... aimless necessarily, it means we haven't taken the time to figure out what our purpose is. What are we living for?

What is important to us? What do we want to achieve over the course of this life? Which is very short. And that's one thing that monks had already figured out. If you're in the monastery, you know what your purpose is. Your purpose is salvation. You're trying to get there as best you can through.

you know all sorts of ways whether that's service whether that's prayer all of these things and for us today I think we struggle with ourselves and perhaps we are not sure what our purpose is and so I think it's worth taking the time to sit down with yourself in the quiet and just

figure out what's important to me what do I want from this life and that might actually help us feel a bit more solid a bit more secure a bit happier and maybe that's something we can learn from monks and how would a monk's daily life have differed from ours was it radically different would we recognize any elements of it were there things that might be familiar to us or was it a completely alien world well

As humans can never be completely alien because we we need all the same things. We need community. We need to eat. We need some time outside. So it is very alien to us in that most of us wouldn't choose to live such a strict. So it's very institutionalized in ways that we don't usually experience unless we are in school or we're maybe in jail. We do have institutionalized ways of being in our work, like we show up at a certain time and we are expected.

to eat at a certain time or whatever. But in terms of every part of the day having a function, we're not really that strict in our lives. So that's something that's not really recognizable to us, I think. We're not really comfortable to us. Definitely. But we do see, again, that human element. So we see times where monks are begrudgingly allowed to speak, even though they've taken a vow of silence. There's like a part during the day where you're allowed to speak.

But you should be speaking about religious stuff, but you can also speak. Or there are things like St. Benedict, the fact that everyone should have a bath every once in a while. It's important, but not too many. And then you should have your bloodlet so that... you're healthier. And when you have your bloodlet, you should have a little bit of time to talk with your friends and just kind of take the day off so that you can come back and have a more productive life as a monk.

Taking time off is important too. So we do recognize these human things. There's certain things that monks experience that we experience. So again, wanting to go outside, wanting to eat, wanting to have a bit of time off to talk with your friends. All of these things we recognize, but I think most of us don't.

want to live such a rigid structured life as they did i'm struck by the idea there that there was a recognition of the need for It wasn't quite a work-life balance, I guess, but there's an element of that in that, you know, if you have to have your bloodlet or whatever else goes on, take the day off, take some time because you'll recover and you'll come back.

more ready to do work and do better work because you've had that time off. So we struggle with the work-life balance today. And it sounds like Monk's had an idea of how to address that at least.

Mental Health and Monastic Support

Yes. And so you mentioned mental health earlier, and mugs recognize that this life is so difficult that sometimes you will get depressed. And they had a specific name for this depression that comes from being a mug, and they called it ACID. And that if... A mug experienced this. They were meant to take some time off to go sit in the infirmary, spend some time with friends and just chill out a little bit so that they can come back to it because they knew that if you went flat out.

doing your best to be a monk, like overachieving, you are going to burn out. And this could cause all sorts of problems. So there's examples that I do have in the book where monks, they burn themselves out and they were advised not to do this, but they did it anyway. And they might have health problems.

or they might attempt suicide. So they recognize the fact that you can't go full out as a monk. It's just not possible. And sometimes there are some examples I have in the book too, where even St. Benedict says, as monks, We're not really supposed to be drinking wine or beer, but since I can't convince anyone of that...

These days, well, fine, have it, just have it in moderation. So there's always a recognition of human frailty in this, that they recognize that this is difficult, you're going to struggle, and that's okay. You can tell someone, you should tell someone, and then... And we will help you to get through this so that you can achieve your goal to be the best monk you possibly can be. And that's to recognize the fact that it is hard and you are going to struggle.

I think that might be a surprise to a lot of people. It probably is to me because you tend to think of monks living this slavishly devoted life and being... whipped and whatever when they misbehaved and everything was about a punishment for the slightest sign of frailty. But it sounds like frailty... bit of mindfulness, some care for your mental health and your physical well-being was actually built into the routine of being a monk. There was a recognition that they were just human.

Hey, what's up? It's Mario Lopez. Back to school is an exciting time, but it can also be overwhelming and kids may feel isolated. A vulnerability that human traffickers can exploit. Human trafficking doesn't always look like what you expect. Everyday moments can become opportunities for someone with bad intentions. Whether you're a parent, teacher, coach, or neighbor, check in. Ask questions. Stay connected.

Blue Campaign is a national awareness initiative that provides resources to help recognize suspected instances of human trafficking. Learn the signs and how to report at dhs.gov slash blue campaign. Monday Sidekick, the AI agent that knows you and your business, thinks ahead and takes action. Ask at anything, seriously. Monday Sidekick, AI you'll love to use. Start a free trial today on monday.com.

Mm hmm. And even the punishments that you say there were punishments. That is true. But there were recognitions to like if you screwed up. You should just confess. And if you are the one to confess, you're going to have a more lenient punishment. If you try to hide it and someone else outs you a chapter.

then you're going to be in more trouble. So again, the recognition, you're going to screw up. And if you do that, try to make reparation as best you can. And then just try again tomorrow. But there's all sorts of little sort of...

clauses in monastic texts that say something like, if you can't do that, try doing this. And even St. Benedict says, everyone eats according to their ability. So you shouldn't be given something that's too hard for you. And that's because they don't want people... quitting it is a very important vocation to them all and they want

to support each other. That's why they built a monastery in the first place instead of everyone just being a hermit out in the wilderness. They wanted to do this together so that they could help each other. So yeah, there is a certain amount of leniency and also the fact that we know from you know,

admonitions that they're getting from the Pope or from heads of orders saying, stop bringing pets into the monastery. We know that people are, they're not always following the rules and sometimes their abbots are turning a blind eye to that. So there is a lot of flexibility.

change and how people are being monks it's meant to be very strict but then people are trying to make it a way of life that they can live with that's going to be something that's tolerable even within the rules as much as possible

And it sounds like pets are probably one of the oldest human frailties, aren't they? I was just thinking then that sounds like the medieval equivalent of spending all your time at work watching cat memes on the internet. We can't help it. We can't help it. Well, there's a whole poem about... A monk and his white cat. I think it's an Irish poem. And it's even been turned into a kid's book.

Even that was an example and an excuse for contemplation. Like the cat does his work and I do my work and we both are serving God in our own ways. So yeah, pets are something that we're not supposed to be there, but we're there anyway. And that speaks to the fact that you do need to be flexible in some ways and pick your battles i think as an abbot so that everyone can be successful overall in the end i get more and more convinced that being an abbot was just like being a parent

Bridging Ancient Wisdom and Modern Life

I think so. Well, they call him father, right? Yeah, that's true, actually. Yeah, very good point. Was there anything in particular that you felt like you would take away from writing this book and maybe implement in your own daily life? Well, this book is very personal in ways that I maybe didn't expect as I was writing it. But this book has a lot of the wisdom that...

I've learned over the years. So I do like to read books about psychology and sociology and like to learn about the human element. People have listened to my podcast or paid attention to my work before.

They hear me always talking about like humanity and the human element. So this is something that interests me in general. And so I've brought that psychology and... ideas of wellness and studies that we've done since then into this book so many of the things that I talk about in terms of ways that we can live healthier lives are things that I do practice myself so I mean I'm not great at

eating healthily because I just don't enjoy cooking. But I do live my life in a relatively minimalist way. So I don't collect a lot of possessions, which is kind of monastic in some ways. And I do practice meditation and things like that. So it reminded me of a lot of the things that I have learned are valuable from doing research in my spare time.

what spare time, when I'm reading things that are not history, I might be reading about ways to be happier. And so if you look at the bibliography of the book, you'll see lots of things in there about the psychology of wellness, the psychology of happiness.

And so all of these things are things that I've learned over time. So it is a very personal book in that you do have a lot of my practices in it. So I guess it's kind of validating in that way where it's like, oh, these are actually good ways to live. But these are things that, you know, I've learned over time.

and have been borne out by psychologists, which I think is super interesting. Were you surprised by how modern-sounding some of those approaches were, given that we think of monks living this... primitive life back in the dark ages I shouldn't say dark ages should I but I'm going to say dark ages it seems to me surprising how much of what they did and what they thought about and how they behaved are things that we

are just realising now are actually good things. We need to work on our work-life balance. We need to work on

our mental health and our mindfulness and all of those kinds of things. And monks seem to have some of that down. I mean, it was at the expense of some of their freedoms and their ability to be themselves and be an individual. But do we need to maybe find a balance between those things? Were you surprised how close to the concerns that we have today they lived or how well they had dealt with some of those things that we struggle with today?

I'm always interested in the ways that we are similar to people from the past. So it's always nice and surprising and also not surprising when you see that. We are so similar, right? People haven't changed all that much over hundreds of years. But I think that what maybe gets in our way of... Continuing to practice this wisdom, right? I look at Christian monks in Western Europe and Middle Ages, but these are practices that are...

part of Buddhism or, you know, they're part of Tibetan monasticism or they're part of people's practices who are Stoics, perhaps. And I think that what perhaps gets in our way of bringing these things together is the idea that we think that... They're separate. Like we talk about them in terms of separation. Like these are Christian monks and therefore what they're doing is irrelevant to us. And I think when we put up those walls, it's harder to see how.

we have this common ground of the things that we need a community time outside good food all of these things and I think when we think of it as being a separate entity that maybe has the rules, we only look at the rules, then maybe we miss out on the fact that there's common humanity and things that we need as people. Because the things that we need as people are very consistent over time throughout history. So I think that...

Hopefully this book bridges that gap by just explaining how they had these rules in place. They are... informed by their culture, they're informed by their religious goals, but they're also things that are common to us as human beings. Hopefully I've been able to bridge that gap. And I think that the more we kind of zoom out.

of culture, well, recognizing the importance of culture. The more we zoom out from culture, the more we can see commonalities and then maybe bring those commonalities to the way we look at culture kind of zooming back in. So I don't know if that answers your question, but... That's how I think about it anyway. It's a good answer, though, and lots to think about. And so when and where can people get their hands on this book?

How to Find the Book

So this book comes out and I'm pretty sure it's worldwide on November 23rd. It was supposed to come out in October. but it was sitting on a boat for a couple months as so many things were. So it is late, but it is coming to you. So November 23rd, you should be able to get this in hardcover and ebook, and you should be able to get it.

So Waterstones, Barnes and Nobles, Indigo in Canada, of course, Amazon. And then I'm also actively recording an audiobook version of this. And I will let people know when that comes out. So November 23rd is the day. I'm super excited about it. And then I will let people know. when the audiobook version is ready, and hopefully that will be ready before Christmas. And where else can people find you if they want to catch up with what you're doing?

I'm doing stuff everywhere all the time. So a central place is my website, which is danielsebolski.com. But you can also find me all over different social media at 5minmedievalist, which is 5-Minute Medievalist, which is how I started.

this whole crazy career so you can find me across social media there and you can listen to the podcast my podcast I was thinking the other day Matt that it's great we're not radio so we're not in direct competition they can listen to you they can listen to me my podcast is just the medieval podcast absolutely and everyone should listen to as much medieval goodness as they can do so oh for sure no problem here with you plugging your podcast it's a team effort i think it's a team effort absolutely

Thank you so much for joining us today, Danielle. It's been really fascinating, I think, to explore an area of medieval life that we perhaps haven't fully understood all of the aspects of and to consider what we might be able to learn from that particular life for our modern day world. You can join Kat Jarman on Tuesday for another brand new episode of Gone Medieval. And don't forget to tell all of your friends and family that you've gone medieval.

While you're here, there's an episode of The Ancients, also from History Hit, which I thought you might enjoy. The Rise of the Praetorian Guard is Tristan's chat with Lindsay Powell, in which they look at this most iconic of ancient bodyguards. Anyway, I'd better let you go. I've been Matt Lewis, and we've just gone medieval with History Hits.

Make money predicting football. Now you can. Now in Texas with Calci. Calci is the only platform that lets you legally trade on real world events in all 50 states from football to Bitcoin, the Oscars, and even politics. If it matters, you can trade on it. Trade on who wins each game, props, spread, and more. Legally, now in Texas. Don't miss your shot. Download the Kalshi app or go to K-A-L-S-H-I dot com. Use code PODCAST and get $10 when you trade $100. This is an investment that carries risk.

This transcript was generated by Metacast using AI and may contain inaccuracies. Learn more about transcripts.
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android