Swamp Notes: Trump’s transatlantic divorce - podcast episode cover

Swamp Notes: Trump’s transatlantic divorce

Mar 08, 202512 min
--:--
--:--
Listen in podcast apps:

Summary

This episode of Swamp Notes discusses the growing rift between the U.S. and Europe under Trump's policies, focusing on defense, trade, and overall transatlantic relations. Gideon Rachman analyzes the implications of reduced U.S. support for Ukraine and Europe's increasing efforts towards self-sufficiency, including Germany's significant defense spending boost and potential economic shifts. The conversation explores whether Europe can emerge stronger from this 'divorce' and the potential long-term consequences for global alliances.

Episode description

European leaders met twice this week to discuss a plan to protect Ukraine — without US leadership. The rift between Brussels and Washington has grown as US president Donald Trump paused military aid to Ukraine and stopped intelligence sharing. As Germany and the EU discuss a new set of defence stimulus plans, special guest Gideon Rachman, the FT’s chief foreign policy commentator, is on to discuss possible outcomes. 


Mentioned in this podcast:

Rachman Review podcast

Trump is sowing the seeds of an anti-American alliance

Sign up for the FT’s Swamp Notes newsletter here


Swamp Notes is produced by Katya Kumkova. Topher Forhecz is the FT’s executive producer. The FT’s global head of audio is Cheryl Brumley. Special thanks to Pierre Nicholson. 


Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

We're Equinor, an energy company searching for better. Currently we supply 27% of the UK's gas, 15% of its oil, and we're playing our part in the UK's energy transition. Our wind farms power 750,000 homes. And we expect that to grow to over 7 million. Last year, we invested 20% of our global gross spend in renewables and lower carbon solutions. We plan to increase that to 50% by 2030. We're an energy company searching for better.

European leaders rushed this week to come up with a new defence plan to protect Ukraine without US leadership. The split reverses decades of transatlantic cooperation, and interestingly, some markets are loving it. U.S. stocks, not so much. This is Swamp Notes, the weekly podcast from the FT News Briefing, where we talk about all the things happening in U.S. politics. I'm Mark Filippino. And this week we're asking, what are the costs of Trump's transatlantic divorce?

Here with me to discuss is a special guest. He's the FT's chief foreign affairs commentator and the host of the Rockman Review podcast, Gideon Rockman. Hey, Gideon. Hi. So I want to set the scene. for this thing I've just called the transatlantic divorce. The news of the past week has been largely defense related, but there are also the tariffs U.S. President Donald Trump threatened Europe with. He said that the European Union was made to, quote, screw the United States.

A little while ago, Vice President J.D. Vance has criticized Europe for walking away from its values. What does this tell us about where things are headed between these two powers? Yeah, I mean, I think it's pretty profound. Of course, Trump's super unpredictable and, you know, he may say very nice things about Europe next week. But the working assumption, I think, in Europe now is that...

the transatlantic relationship is in deep trouble and that Europe really is on its own now on security, that NATO is still alive in theory. But I don't think anybody really believes that America... can always be relied upon to come to Europe's aid when it's in trouble, militarily. Trump's more or less said that on a few occasions. And the implications of that, Europeans have to do a lot more for their own defence.

And there are even sort of more serious implications. And there's one way of thinking of it, which is, okay, America is no longer a reliable ally and we have to defend ourselves. And the Europeans are doing quite a lot to try and do that. But then there's... an even darker view, which is that in some respects, America is now an adversary. It's not just not a reliable ally. Drawn from things like Trump's evident warmness towards Putin, his aggression towards Zelensky.

The fear that Trump is going to do a deal with Russia over the heads of the Europeans. The Vance speech in Munich, which you alluded to. Vance said he was speaking up for free speech in Europe, but in Europe, it felt like he was speaking up for the European... our right who are regarded as a threat to democracy. And therefore, as a German politician said to me immediately after that speech, that was an attack on European democracy.

Yeah, and that distrust and adversarial nature really came through this week. Trump said he was going to stop military aid to Ukraine and also stopped intelligence sharing. How big of a deal is that? Very big deal. I mean, I was in Kiev, you know, about 10 days ago. And to be fair, the Ukrainians could see the direction of travel and were already very concerned that they were going to do that. And so...

It does have serious military implications for Ukraine because one of the reasons they've been able to hold the Russians off, even though they have inferior forces in terms of manpower, is because they had... very good intelligence provided to them by the Americans, largely.

And the other reason was that they had a lot of American equipment, in particular artillery shells. But also the other thing they're very worried about not having now is air defenses, because Russia's strategy has been to basically pummel Ukraine.

Ukrainian infrastructure to try to destroy Ukrainians' energy resources and also to put their cities under threat with Patriot missiles supplied by the United States. They were able to kind of, if not totally negate that threat, to blunt it to some extent. The question is, can the Europeans fill the gap? We don't quite know, but probably not completely. One thing that America really does provide uniquely is air defences, patriots. The intelligence thing is a bit murkier.

The French were another step in the gap, maybe a bit. But yeah, it's dangerous for Ukraine. What about the German aspect of this? I mean, this week we saw Germany take a... pretty unprecedented move, basically decided to approve hundreds of billions of euros to go toward defense spending. There's talk of a Europe-wide stimulus package, like these are...

big fiscal moves that Europe has not seen in a very, very long time. What does it mean for the bloc? It means a lot. I mean, I think that, you know, Germany is the largest economy and the largest industrial base. their reluctance to spend and their kind of semi-pacifist attitude to the world, a result of the Second World War, meant that they were a kind of big drag on European defense efforts.

Now they've really done 180, and that's huge in its implications because they're much less indebted than, say, the French. The French already have a public debt which is worth... 100% of GDP. The British are also at that level. Germans are only at about 60% because they've been relatively frugal. So they have the capacity to borrow.

The markets trust them. And also it looks like they're going to put their weight behind European debt, which again, the Germans have been a big break on. That has implications actually well beyond defense. It's really one of the big... next steps in european integration which people have been arguing about for 20 plus years the difficulty is timing i mean i think over time germany backed by the rest of europe can become a considerable military force but they've

let their military really run down, certainly in the post-Cold War era. And you can't sort of bring it into... existence overnight so it's possibly a 10-year project to really fill all the capabilities that america currently covers for them and the question is does europe have 10 years gideon what does this mean

From an economics perspective, because the markets this week, we saw a very large bond sell-off, potentially indicating that investors are excited about the economic growth that will come with defense spending. What did you make of that?

yeah i mean i think that um one of the interesting things that's been happening is the reversal of expectations you know i was at the world economic forum in davos in january and everyone was saying oh god you know the actions all in america no investor in their right mind would invest in europe uh look at the american stock market it's going to boom under trump whatever you think of him and you know On the contrary, the American markets are struggling and European markets are booming.

I guess, you know, it just tells us again that obviously if markets were that predictable, we'd all be very rich. The point is you can't tell how these things are going to play out. But what I think they're currently reacting to is the sense that... um defense spending will provide a kind of keynesian stimulus to the german economy which has been struggling uh struggling partly because there are

losing market share in China for machine tools, for the automobile industry. And people thought, you know, what's the way out of this? And in fact, a French industrialist joked to me, A year ago, well, it's very clear, as he said, they can't sell their cars, they'll make tanks instead. And he didn't say it with any great relish. You know, the French and others in Europe still have a kind of lingering suspicion of German.

armament but i think that's what's happening right now you can see the share price of rheinmetall which is uh you know the main german armaments manufacturer really soaring so gideon a lot of what we've been talking about is Europe becoming self-sufficient and laying the groundwork to be independent of the U.S. in many ways. Is it possible that Europe walks away with this better than it was before Trump?

Well, that's the hope. I don't know. I mean, I think that, you know, there is a sort of determination in Europe now to try and make this work. And I think... Over the long run, possibly. But, you know, Europe does have all sorts of vulnerabilities, as Trump doesn't hesitate to point out. The Europeans enjoy a trade surplus with the United States. So in theory, if there's a trade war...

this side of the Atlantic is more vulnerable. You know, France, Britain are very indebted countries, Italy, so on. They don't have a reserve currency to back that up. They also have... welfare programs that are hugely expensive and becoming more expensive. And they can talk a good game about spending more on defence, but how they fund it, you know, to some extent, issuing common European debt is a new source. The other possible source is confiscating these.

200 to 300 billion in Russian assets, maybe handing them over to Ukraine or maybe using them for European defense or a bit of both. So there are some ways, but I think one of the things that European... politicians are beginning to worry about is let's say we cut welfare to fund defense does that then fuel the rise of the political extremes that we're trying to stop so europe does have real weaknesses and i think trump can play on those but i think that

One of the things, and mood shifts very quickly, but the sense of a Trump's America that holds all the cards is diminishing a little bit because... Trump's policy approach seems so chaotic, exemplified by tariffs on Canada one day, then off the next day, then on again the next week, and then off again. And we suddenly realize these guys don't know what they're doing.

And maybe that actually gives Europe an advantage. I think another thing people are beginning to talk about is if there is a threat to the rule of law in America. might Europe be able to say, yeah, you know, we're slow moving and you know all our problems. but actually you'll still get a fair shake in the European courts. The regulators are not necessarily going to be in the pocket of a very powerful businessman who's, you know, next door to the...

president. So there may be something there for Europeans as well, depending on how badly things go in America. Gideon, what are you watching next? What about this transatlantic divorce are you curious about?

Well, I mean, I think the big thing, immediate thing is Ukraine. Does Trump strike a deal with Putin? Can the Europeans get their seat at the table? And does this whole process... exacerbate the rift between the two sides of the Atlantic, or might actually we end up in a place where both the US and Europe can kind of live with it, in which case...

maybe in a couple of months' time will say, well, that was just sort of Trump theatrics, and it was all pretty brutal and distasteful. But in the end, Europe and America found common ground, and Trump didn't basically kind of... switch sides and join up with the Russians. The more dangerous outcome is that actually what we're seeing is just a prelude to a real transatlantic rift over Ukraine.

I'm a bit of a worst-case scenario person. I think this transatlantic rift is real and probably quite historic until such time as America definitively turns away from Trumpism, by which time who knows where we'll be. Gideon, I want to thank you for a great conversation. My pleasure. Gideon Rockman is the FT's Chief Foreign Affairs Commentator and the host of the Rockman Review Podcast. We'll post a link to that in the show notes.

This was Swamp Notes, the US politics show from the FT News Briefing. If you want to sign up for the Swamp Notes newsletter, we've also got a link to that in the show notes. Our show is mixed by Sam Giavinko and produced by Katya Kumkova. We had help this week from Andrew Georgiatis and Misha Franco-Duvall. Special thanks, as always, to Pierre Nicholson. I'm your host, Mark Filippino. Our executive producer is Topher Forges, and Cheryl Brumley is the FT's Global Head of Audio.

Original music by Hannes Brown. Check back next week for more U.S. political analysis from the Financial Times. Here's the truth about AI. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into. ServiceNow puts AI to work for people across your business, removing friction and frustration for your employees.

Supercharging productivity for your developers, providing intelligent tools for your service agents to make customers happier. All built into a single platform you can use right now. That's why the world works with ServiceNow. Visit servicenow.com slash UK slash AI for people.

This transcript was generated by Metacast using AI and may contain inaccuracies. Learn more about transcripts.