This is the Doc Jacques Podcast. I'm Dr. Jacques DeBruyckert and I'm here to talk to you about addiction and all things related to addiction and recovery.
This podcast is hopefully going to be educational and helpful to people who don't understand addiction and maybe have a loved one who is suffering from addiction or is trying to get clean and sober, and also for people who suffer from addiction and maybe just want something to listen to for support, guidance, information, coaching, anything and everything that's related to addiction. I hope you enjoy.
This episode of the Doc Jacques podcast is going to be exploring today's youth and specifically from the perspective of a college professor. She's wanting to know what happened. How did things change so quickly? Dr. Allison Karas, PhD, Spanish applied linguistics professor at a university and her first years of teaching being that she is not that much older than the students that she's teaching, but the great divide that has occurred due to technology.
She's a little apprehensive and confused and upset, frankly, about how today's youth are experiencing life as she describes it in ways to understand the disconnect that the telephone and technology has created and the anxiety and the stress and the depression that seem to be permeating their existence. So join me as we talk to Dr. Karis and understand from her perspective, kind of what she's seeing and what's happened.
It's 2013 and I'm a graduate student who's getting to teach her first class. I can't wait. I'm here ready to share my love of the Spanish language with these beautiful students who I haven't come to meet yet, but I know I'm going to make these great connections and enjoy our time and watch them learn and grow. I get into the classroom and I see that I'm faced with a challenge right away.
I was seeing that there was a lack of a look in my students' eyes when I was trying to teach them and I couldn't quite figure out what was going on. It seemed to be a disconnect. And I was thinking about how I learned and how I studied and I was seeing that they weren't quite processing the same way. And then I realized, maybe it has something to do with the phone.
I started to notice an impatience, a... a rushed sort of sense in my students, even when we had blocked time to chat with each other, maybe a catch up during office hours and just to see what's going on and how to approach doing your homework or how to study for the next test. And so I'm seeing the lack of attention, even during this blocked off dedicated time where we're supposed to say, study this type of reading for the test, you can practice this way.
And the students that might come through are, of course, some are focused and they're writing their list and they're processing the information. They've got it down, ready to go for later to prepare. But then there are some who are in there that are not even focused on this during this dedicated time. I'm seeing that. They're in their own world, even though they're in my office. And we're talking about a strategic plan to up your grade or improve your performance in some way. But where are you?
And so I was getting more and more concerned about the focus, the lack of focus that I'm seeing in the students sitting one-on-one with me in my office to plan for their own success. And then I'm seeing all this or hearing all of these anecdotes, all of these stories, that all I'm thinking as the more I hear is, oh, there's a little depression in there, maybe there's some anxiety. I'm just recognizing this from my own personal experience.
I'm no specialist, no expert in this field of psychology, but I didn't know what else to do but observe, recognize that I know this behavior or I know this story or I know that anecdote. I've lived that. I've lived something similar to that. And so I'm seeing a pickup in this among my students and I'm getting more and more worried about where they're headed without these personal connections. So it's making me really, I can't say it enough. It's making me sad. It's making me worried.
It's making me concerned. And I want them to know that they have a direction, but it's up to them to find it, no matter how cheesy that sounds. So I feel like I'm there to help guide them as their elder, now that the age gap is getting larger. I feel like Matthew McConaughey, right? I stay the same, they stay the same, I get older, whatever it is, like in Dazed and Confused. But it's really...
So they're not seeing, I think, overall that they're using their devices so, so much that they're missing the personal connection and thus freeing up the headspace for this hotbed of stress, anxiety, depression, whatever it may be, that all of this processing, all of the cognitive processing, all of the learning is going on really in this device, in this device. appendage that they're raised with, they're conditioned to use this device, this appendage in a certain way. We were not.
And so I'm seeing a completely different type of processing is my point. It's really, I don't know what to do to work with it yet, but I'm trying to tackle the emotional side of it first.
So that must've been kind of interesting for you to be teaching with students who were not that much younger than you.
No, that was another interesting encounter because none of us knew how to greet the other, in a sense. It was like every day, hi, hola, senora, professora, usted, hola. And I would just say, you can call me Allison. Me llamo Allison. Peers. It's fine. It's almost like peers, right? Yes, it really, it really, there was a... no sense of authority in the room.
So did that affect the way that you experienced them?
I have to say that it did, of course, but I also would like to point out that I didn't use authority as a tactic. I used my warmth and my way of trying to connect with them. And that in turn showed leadership.
But she said that they were difficult to connect with because... you saw this look in their eyes that were, was kind of disconnected.
Not processing. So my concern there was I was offering the information. I was offering, Giving breadcrumbs, leading them down these paths to the answers on their own deductive reasoning, all of this. I can figure it out. As you're
trying to teach them.
As I'm trying to teach them. That's how I teach. That's how I teach is giving clues and hoping that you pick up and piece things together for yourself and then feel more confident and motivated to learn more. Do it again. Do it again. Do it again.
Did you find that they had that what's the point attitude?
That's it. That's it. So how do you work with that?
What's the point?
What's the point?
Why am I doing
this? This is a requirement.
And these are students who are taking this class because it's a requirement for their degree program, but language is not their degree.
That's right.
So they really weren't motivated necessarily to be there other than they had to check the box.
That's right. Some, of course, had some personal interest in the language. Maybe some family members spoke Spanish or maybe they just had a knack for languages. Absolutely. But the majority No, it was heartbreaking to see that they didn't want to be there sharing, meeting me in the middle of wanting to share this passion I have
for the language. Is that the emotional disconnect that you were seeing? Did it feel like a barrier between you and the student?
Absolutely. I'd call it more like a veil. It was softer than a barrier. Yeah. I'd call it a veil. Yeah. Because it was still as if I could connect. There were chances and opportunities there. I would think a barrier is more... difficult to break through, but a veil there, there was still, that's why I'm still in the game, right? It's a veil.
Did they, did they, did you see them experience that with each other? Did they seem like when you were in school, did you see, did you feel that way with your fellow students? back in 2008?
So my senior year of college was 2008. In December 2007, I got the first iPhone, I'm privileged enough to say. And I was, of course, the most popular person on the floor in the senior dorm because everybody wanted to come play with this TV phone thing that they could watch videos on. And anyway, it was incredible and fun. And I was recording videos with my friends and it was so neat. We just had them on my phone and people would come watch them on my phone.
Maybe I was starting to email videos out and pictures. But what I'm seeing is a difference in my upbringing coming through high school with the flip phone to text or call mom when I'm ready to go home after lacrosse practice to, yeah, showing off the new iPhone that's this groundbreaking technology that's just hit. all the way to just learning the different features that will help me in my daily life or social life.
But what I'm seeing in terms of the students, what I started to notice almost right away was there seems to be a different type of processing going on. And might that be because they were raised on this stuff, on this technology, on these apps, on these distractions, on this disconnection?
So buried in their phones, their head is buried in the phones for so long that they're getting tidbits of information. They're not actually getting... There's a wealth of knowledge available on a phone and you can gather that information and you can find very robust information, but they don't seem to do that, do they?
No. And so the very interesting observation I've made in the last few years is the disconnect in logic from... I don't know what that concept is to, well, why don't you look it up? I don't see my students, I don't see it dawning on them that they should look something up that's unknown and that they're interested in. So
they're not seeing you as an authority figure.
I'm not sure. I'm not sure. I think what I'm seeing is, well, actually I should say, let's back up. It's not the authority anymore because I don't let them use phones in the classroom. So we need to back up on my, and talk about my methodologies and my practices. But overall, if I say something to them, when they ask a question in the classroom that they can easily look up, I might say, go ahead and look it up later.
The look in their eyes then upon receiving that suggestion is, oh, I would have never thought of that. That's what I mean. So it's those snippets, those chunks, but then where's the connection and a through line of logic? That's what I'm not seeing. I see sentence fragments in their language. Spoken language or written? Spoken and written, mostly written.
And I see this... this overall lack of engagement with whether it be material me each other the engagement and the interest it's again it's it's breaking my heart to see overall and it makes me celebrate those that i come across who are i i see them with their feet on the ground i see that they are seers. They're knowers. They are aware of their surroundings. They can relate to others easily. They have it down. They understand the world, it seems, and how to function within.
There are others who seemingly and sadly don't know how to navigate at all. And a way to navigate or in order to navigate, you need to connect.
I saw you getting really emotional there for a minute when I was describing the effect of this on students. Yeah.
Why is that? They mean a lot to me.
Yeah.
This group of people means a lot to me, students. I think that I, at least in my personal life, I'd always like to be a student myself of something, right? And I want to also share what I've learned with others. And when my passion falls on deaf ears for whatever reason, it hurts.
Well, I'm guessing that you probably see the lack of learning going on because of that disconnect. And that's where that goes.
I'd agree. It's nothing personal. It's not against me. It's not against, it's a bigger issue.
It's what has happened to them.
Yes. It's not their fault.
You said device and appendage. Those are terms you used to describe the phone, I'm assuming.
I did. Yes, I was.
And the phone is now, as you've kind of portrayed it, part of them use the term appendage.
That's how I see it.
So it's an appendage. So it's an emotional outlet and input for them.
they feel connected to the phone and that's where they get that feeling of feeling better right one of the things that we talk about in addiction is and and in trauma recovery is the ability to feel felt two people are talking and connecting and the point of that as a lot of my addict clients will try to figure out is like what's the point of going to meetings what's the point of working with a sponsor what's the point of you know spending time with other people because addiction's best friend
is isolation. And so you wanna feel felt. You can't feel felt from a device. It's a device.
When you're telling it what to tell you.
So somebody sitting there having a panic attack or being upset, they go to the phone because that's an addictive behavior. It's a distraction, but it's something that they are repetitively connecting to, thinking that it's gonna make them feel better. And it does temporarily, just like any other chemical of choice or behavior of choice, but then it becomes pointless the more they do it because they're not getting that feeling of satisfaction from it.
response to stress or whatever that stimulus is. I
am stressed. I am anxious. I am depressed. So if I use my phone, it can pull me away from my feelings.
And that's implicitly charged. That's an implicit reaction to me. That's so deeply conditioned that they are not explicitly making that decision to get out the phone. It'll fix it. I'll feel better. No, it's so deeply ingrained.
You know what we call that?
What?
Addiction.
There it is. That's what it is.
with the heroin or the cocaine water and the food and they put them in a cage and they leave them there and the rats would start consuming the water that was laced with cocaine and they'd be given food and they would keep doing it and they would stop eating and so they would keep drinking the the water laced with the drug until they eventually died he looked at that research and said there's something wrong here the thing that's wrong is that rats are they're communal there.
Now you've put them in a sterile cage with nothing to do by themselves. They have nothing else except for that drug of choice that they become addicted to. And then they die from using it. So he tried a different research. He put the rats in by themselves, but he put in every rat toy that he could think of balls and tubes and wheels. And he put down lots of like the, the Cedar bedding and he had food and he had regular water. And he had the drug-laced water.
And then he would also put them in an interaction environment where they could interact with other rats as well. Surprisingly, they didn't use the drug-laced water. They would eat. They would drink. They would get on the wheel. They would play with the little toys. They would interact with each other. And occasionally, they might drink from the drug-laced water. But they didn't die. And they didn't use that water. What's missing? Right.
So what you're talking about is this kind of learned response of isolation from the use of a cell phone where they live in this virtual world from the time they're a child. I mean, we've all seen kids walking around in stores in the shopping cart glued to that cell phone or the little kiddie iPad thing because mom wants to shop. And so then a mom is not talking to them. Mom is not interacting with them.
Mom shouldn't have brought them to the store because They just forced their child to be checked out. So that kind of a learned response. And that's the generation that you're talking about, that you're teaching. That's what they did. So this appendage truly is an appendage. It doesn't seem to help. Is that what you're saying?
That is what I'm saying. It's a tool, but it's got a capacity to be used in so many different ways. that we're all it's become normalized. So it's not because it has the capacity, but I'm saying it is a tool that has a capacity is a computer, it is a brain for all intents and purposes. That's where a lot of the cognitive processing is going. So there's not a whole lot going on upstairs is what, you know, I don't mean to sound insulting, condescending once again.
And then you are introducing the idea to me, at least of using this, this device, this appendage as a knee jerk reaction. This is where I go for my comfort. This is where I go to. That's addiction. That's addiction. It could
be heroin. It could be pot. It could be alcohol. It could be food,
food, anything,
anything.
And so it's like you're saying it's a learned reaction, but I'm getting lost in where we're going.
Well, the parents of these children who grow up to be adults are at a loss because they don't know what to do with the kids who are disconnected by the time they get to high school. I experienced that in my practice. A mom or a dad will come in and want help with their 16, 17 year old, sometimes 18 year old before they go to college. because they are emotionally distant. They're not connected. They isolate all the time. And the parents are very concerned.
And they come to me and they say, can you help my child? And they can't enforce any rules because they never have had any rules. And so usage of devices or whatever, they've given that up a long time ago. They've given up that control a long time ago. And so now their parenting is limited to we don't know what to do. And this is our last chance before our son or daughter goes to college and fix them.
And I don't know what I can offer them other than just to say, well, they're connected to their phones and disconnected from reality. Most of the time, those are also the kids that are heavily engaged in smoking pot and drinking. that the parents know about. A lot of times they're actually, they've been dropping acid, they do cocaine.
There's some heroin usage, but kids tend to be a little bit more concerned about heroin because they hear so much about the addictive qualities of it and they've had friends who have been addicted or died. So they tend to shy away more from heroin in those cases, but pot and the psychedelic drugs and alcohol. Parents know about the pot and the drinking, but they don't know about the other drugs, cocaine and heroin.
So the feeling of disconnect and anxiety and depression that you're describing a lot of times comes up with additional things to that. And the phone is a great way to get those things. That's how they get it. So it really becomes a trap. They're addicted to the phone. They're addicted to other things usually. And here's another concept for you. Most of my clients, actually 99.9% of them, I've had one or two that claimed this is not the case, but they all have trauma in their childhoods.
Some really severe, some not so severe, but trauma, the five forms of abuse usually. And they come in and they talk about the abuse, but it's never really addressed or treated. So they're trying to escape that feeling of uncomfortable. And so the only way they can do that is to isolate because they don't want to talk about it. They don't want to have to re-experience it. So they start using a drug of choice, whether it's the phone or drugs or alcohol, whatever.
That behavior then becomes abusive, right? So now they're self-abusing on top of whatever else they've had with their trauma. So it becomes this unbelievable peak It just keeps growing and growing of views. So by the time you get them in the classroom, now what are they experiencing? They're in full bloom. And this is the first time they've been away from home a lot of times, right?
Yes.
So you're seeing them at that point.
So I'm seeing a student who won't put his phone away no matter what I ask.
Mm-hmm.
and increasingly demand of him. And I eventually call him into my office like a teacher in whatever grade to discipline this student who is an adult who should know how to comport, how to act in a college classroom. That's what I expect. And he sits down in my office to have this no cell phones in the classroom discussion. And he takes his phone out and is staring at it while I begin speaking to him.
That's the rat drinking the drug-laced water in the sterile cage. Like, he has tuned you out.
Oh, I'm gone.
Right.
I know I'm gone. You're in the room. Yeah, I'm not there.
Yeah. I know. That's addiction at its extreme.
Yeah. And it just... It's one of those things that if your knee-jerk reaction is to go judgmental, then it's like, dude, the irony is so beautiful right there. You're called in to the office not to use your phone in class, and there you are using the phone precisely. So the compassionate side of me has to say, all right, it's not your fault, man. You just don't know.
You just... I know this seems like it's a nuisance for you to come in and waste your time during these office hours that I've made you attend to talk about why I have on my syllabus, no phones in the classroom, but maybe there's a gem in there to lead you to a connection. Maybe in these five minutes that you're here with me, you can sit with me and talk and let the conversation meander and have a social connection. Maybe that can happen.
Mm-hmm.
We'll see you next time. In addiction work and recovery, we have a million different sayings. And one of them is, drinking is not the problem, the problem is the problem. And so we're sitting here talking about things that you're experiencing from the perspective of being an authority figure as a professor.
You're
called a professor, right?
I am.
Okay. So it's the problem of... Mm-hmm. They have fallen into the trap of using a faulty coping mechanism. I need to give them a healthier coping mechanism, which in clinical treatment, really effective clinical treatment would be the connection between person to person. And you're talking about person to device. And so it must be very difficult for you to just stand there and watch this happen.
which I imagine is why you're getting so emotional about it when you're sitting here talking about it.
I agree with you because I am not getting the connection that I'm seeking. There's no meaning in my teaching if it's not received.
Well, you've had this awareness of this problem since 2013, so that's seven years. Right?
That's
right. And so there's been this growing awareness of this issue, of this disconnect. What'd you say? The dead look in their eyes, the vacant look, the disconnected.
Yeah, there's just a void. It's a disconnect, a lack of a look in their eyes.
Right. Response. Yeah. Right?
Connection.
So what's the answer?
What a question. I don't know. And I am absolutely willing to admit that. I want to learn how to work with this person, this type of person that seems to be different than myself in a big way. And I just want to find a way to connect.
And it's hard to do because you can't.
I cannot in my job capacity. That is, that's not part of this job description. I am there to impart information and to, you know, promote your learning of the Spanish language or talk about linguistics for a little while, have some fun discussing. And that is fun to discuss. But then if I see someone suffering, that's beyond my reach. That's not my job. And I don't want to see that, though. I don't want to be working with someone who is in that state, meaning I want to be able to help them.
And that's beyond the scope of my control as a professor. I would be probably reprimanded for crossing the line and trying to help.
Because that's a clinician's job.
Indeed.
Like me.
Indeed.
Indeed.
So you don't have the answer.
I don't.
Because your application, your practical application of living.
I'm in it.
Not theoretical or psychological application.
Right.
Because that is the actual truth is that you don't know the answer and you couldn't know the answer. You're just trying to help them live their lives, but you're seeing the wreckage of what they've grown up with, which is kind of the attitude of what's the point? And if you're trying to connect with somebody whose thinking is what's the point, it becomes very problematic because they're not reachable. They're not emotionally available. They're not making themselves emotionally available.
In my office, when somebody comes in and sits down, it's usually gotten very bad. That's why they're there. When I'm talking to them and trying to get them to tell me what is the problem, they don't know either. I get that answer a lot. So what's the problem? I don't know. Many times they've been to two or three or four different therapists and they never brought up the fact that they were molested. They never brought up the fact that mom was, was borderline and abusive.
They never brought up the fact that dad had affairs on mom and then left, but then came back. And if they did mention it, the therapist a lot of times will just kind of note that and then they move on and want to talk about the relationship they have with their mother recently because they had a fight. And so the answer to the problem is to not deal with the coping mechanism itself because that's how they've learned how to respond to the stress and anger or depression.
But rather, the answer is to work on the actual problem which is the trauma and the abuse, the neglect, the abandonment, whatever went on. And unfortunately, someone like you, who apparently is very much a feeling person, you're receiving the disconnect. You're receiving and noting and aware of that kind of situation, but you're powerless to do anything about it.
And yet you're subject to dealing with it So the answer is to get the clinical help you need and to work with somebody who actually understands trauma and understands how to treat trauma, not just therapy, but trauma, because that is the problem. And the isolation that comes with those feelings of being trapped, whether it's as extreme as PTSD or just major depressive disorder, moderate or severe, is difficult.
But labeling it is something also people don't want to do because they don't want that label. And it becomes difficult then for someone to seek help because they have to admit that they have a problem of some type. So hopefully they would come into an office like mine before it got that bad But I think with this generation, what I'm seeing with the normalization of pot smoking and what I used to call the 420s, but now there is no like 420 doesn't exist really.
But it's because states have legalized it. And now everybody says, oh, look, see, it's legal. It's not a problem. It's less harmful than alcohol. And from my perspective as a treating clinician, it's actually worse than alcohol. It's way worse.
Why is that?
It subtracts from the person in a way that's different than alcohol, and it has a stigma attached to it. But like in Colorado, the skyrocketing heroin addiction is a good indicator of the gateway drug that we used to call it in the 70s and 80s. It was a gateway drug, is actually an indicator of the problems in California.
Before it was legal for recreational use, I heard a clinician being asked, so how many of your patients that you see that have an addiction to heroin or something else come into your practice with a medical marijuana card? And without even hesitating, he said, 100%. How many of those actually needed, had a medical need for medical marijuana? Zero. And so it's like the idea of using drugs and alcohol has become normalized in a way that I have never experienced.
I'm a child of the 70s and 60s and 70s when everybody was smoking pot and it was dazed and confused in that 70s show kind of environment.
It was a subculture. Yeah.
I
think pot culture was a subculture. It was the mysterious, it was over there and now it's here. It's accessible. It is culture. It's no longer a subculture per se.
No, it was in the basement at somebody's house or it was, it was the midnight movie with Led Zeppelin movie, you know? Now it's somebody driving their car down the street and it's, quote unquote, fine. I'm using my finger quotes. It's fine, but it's not. So the actual answer to the problem of how do we get that generation to re-engage is to help them understand that there is something that maybe they need some help with. And part of it is experience.
You know, when I was growing up, we didn't, my parents were Eisenhower era parents born in the depression. And I, The answer to everything was, well, get off the couch and get a job, dumbass. You know, that 70s show with Red, that was his answer to everything.
And
that's the generation that were my parents. And that was helpful because we understood that we needed to actually do something. But the caring wasn't there, which is why my generation has gone overboard with trying to compensate for that. And now we have very entitled children who don't have responsibilities because we didn't want them to feel bad.
Part two of this podcast right now. It's a whole nother podcast.
So the answer is getting help and understanding you need to get help before it's too late. But you can't force somebody into it. So that's why I'm hoping that somebody who is hearing this will hear something that resonates with them and maybe get that help. Um, wherever they are.
Me too.
Yeah. So I wanted to thank you for spending the time and coming in and talking. Uh, I think it was helpful to kind of get a different perspective.
Thank you for having me. It's so great to be able to share these concerns as well, just because I, um, I see things going this way in some sort of a pattern that's become clearer and clearer since 2013. It's clear to me, it's building, it's gaining speed, it's getting bigger. And I really want to see what we can all do to connect with each other in this environment.
Yeah, that's awesome.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Maybe I'm disillusioned or maybe I'm idealistic. I'm really not sure which, but I haven't given up hope and I'm going to keep trying.
The Doc Jacques Podcast is hosted by me, Dr. Jacques DeBruyckert, a trained, licensed clinical therapist who specializes in addiction treatment. Thank you.
