Brian Wilson: Love and Mercy, Murder, Theft, and Manipulation - podcast episode cover

Brian Wilson: Love and Mercy, Murder, Theft, and Manipulation

Sep 02, 202543 minSeason 24Ep. 248
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

Brian Wilson was the quiet one. The genius in the bathrobe. The ghost at the piano bench. He wrote Pet Sounds, rewrote pop music history, and was nearly destroyed for it. This is the story of how mercy, murder, theft, and family fractured the mind behind the Beach Boys—and how Brian Wilson reclaimed his music, his story, and his soul.

For a full list of contributors, visit ⁠⁠⁠disgracelandpod.com⁠⁠⁠

To listen to Disgraceland ad free and get access to a monthly exclusive episode, weekly bonus content and more, become a Disgraceland All Access member at ⁠⁠⁠disgracelandpod.com/membership⁠⁠⁠.

Sign up for our newsletter and get the inside dirt on events, merch and other awesomeness - ⁠⁠⁠GET THE NEWSLETTER⁠⁠⁠

Follow Jake and DISGRACELAND:

⁠⁠⁠Instagram⁠⁠⁠

⁠⁠⁠YouTube⁠⁠⁠

⁠⁠⁠X⁠⁠⁠ (formerly Twitter) 

⁠⁠⁠Facebook Fan Group⁠⁠⁠

⁠⁠⁠TikTok

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

Speaker 1

Disgraceland is a production of Double Elvis. This is a story about the quiet One, the genius, and the bathrobe, the savant, the ghost. And it's a story about murder, about theft, about manipulation. It's a story about the cost of music and the way a sound can save a person and the way it can drown them too. It's about the beach Boys, yes, but it's also about the wave that never stops pulling. And this is a story about love and mercy and about family and the violent

cracks that split these things apart. It's about the man who made pet sounds, and it's about the people who nearly destroyed him for it, people who medicated him, isolated him, rewrote his contracts, manipulated his mind, and stole his future. It's about a murder that marked his descent, a theft that changed his legacy, and a manipulation so complete it turned a fragile artist into a legal hostage. It's a story about beach Boy Brian Wilson, a man who made

great music. Unlike that loop I played for you at the top of the show that wasn't great music. That was a preset loop from my melotron called pick in Cass forever. I played you that loop because I can't afford the rights to Monday Monday by the Mamas and the Papas. And why would I play you that specific slice of your mother's Laurel Canyon Cheese. Could I afford it?

Because that was the number one song in America on May sixteenth, nineteen sixty six, And that was the day Brian Wilson's Beach Boys released Pet Sounds and changed the course of pop music forever. On this episode Murder, Theft, Manipulation, Love and Mercy and the Broken Beauty of Brian Wilson, I'm Jake Brennan, and this this disgraceland and the surfboard hit Brian Wilson's head so hard that it brought on total blackness. But when he opened his eyes under the wave,

the salt brought a sharp sting. The pins and needles that bit at his hands and feet brought fear, and a voice in his head not his own, told him it was going to be all right. He was young, not much older than ten, but he was physically strong. Soon he'd be a high school athlete. He'd survive this scary incident off the beach a couple miles from his family home in Hawthorne, California, but he'd never serve again. The hits kept on coming back in the Hawthorn home

throughout Brian's childhood. Hits to the head, close fist, hits to the face, to the stomach so hard his knees buckled, and down he went. Above him, he heard his father's voice screaming at him. Whatever Brian had done, Murray Wilson believed it justified the beating his sons, especially his oldest son. Brian needed to be tough if Brian was going to survive in this world, if he was going to make something of himself like Murray had, and Brian Wilson was tough.

Brian Wilson, the songwriter, producer, composer, singer and beach boy, passed away in twenty twenty five at the age of eighty two, and much has been said and written about him. When it comes to twentieth century musicians, Brian Wilson stands among a small group of giants Paul McCartney, Miles Davis, George Gershwin in The list pretty much ends there. In the first paragraph of Brian Wilson's Wikipedia entry, and in the first paragraph of his New York Times obituary, you'll

see the word genius, which is entirely justified. But Brian Wilson was, of course, much more than that. He was, as the Times oh Bit points out, damaged. He was mentally ill. He abused drugs, the kind of drugs that exacerbated his mental illness. He was also partially deaf and creatively, he was as controlling as he was collaborative, as focused

as he was untethered. He was a son, a brother, a cousin, a friend, a husband, an ex husband, a husband again, a father, a dad, both loving and unintentionally unloving. He was also a forever child who, like a kid, found it difficult to rein in his impulses, and that childlike quality persisted throughout his life, and it was, in

my opinion, part of what contributed to his genius. That ability to see around creative corners other musical geniuses hadn't yet approached, and other so called professionals were too grown up to even notice. That childlike quality helped Brian Wilson create America's band, The Beach Boys with his family, his two little brothers and his cousin Mike, as well as a couple of kids from the neighborhood, all under the guidance of his domineering father and loving mother. The Beach

Boys gave the world. I'll repeat that, The Beach Boys gave the world a glimpse at what the best of America could be. Son, surf, young love, fast cars and

all the rest. And then Brian Wilson reached deep down inside of himself and largely of his own creative volition, gave the music world the greatest pop record of all time up to that point, Pet Sounds, and later on in life, it was also that same childlike quality that somehow, perhaps ironically, helped Brian re emerge from his madness as not only a survivor, but to regain his position in pop music as a unique voice capable of penning one of the most poignant and inspiring pop songs that I've

ever heard, Love and Mercy, and then becoming the literal embodiment of what that song offered to the world. To do all that, however, Brian Wilson had to endure three devastating crimes murder, theft, and manipulation Ian Wilson's life. To put it mildly was an incredible life, and this is an incredibly brief look at his story. Chapter one love. Families are built on love, and families, as we all know, are messy. By now, we've learned that there are different

ways of building a family. Families in the past, back in the nineteen forties and nineteen fifties, weren't that different. I have two young kids, and I was a kid back in the eighties and the nineties. So I try to raise my kids with some of the same gen X, independence and grit that I grew up with, but it's

very difficult. The world is a different place. During summers, when I was my eleven year old son's age, I left the house in the morning on my mom was BMX, mostly without a plan, maybe came home for launch if I wasn't scarfing down food at my friend's house, and

otherwise didn't return until the street lights came on. Nowadays, my son leaves the house to walk the dog for twenty minutes with an Apple watch on his wrist, which I can track on my phone, and he walks to the edge of the neighborhood and back again on time.

Thank god, because if he doesn't, my mind starts imagining kidnapping and child trafficking rings, and worse, God forbid he should go into a friend's house without checking with me first, and visiting a friend's home means my wife and I will be googling his friend's parents like amateur detectives to make sure they're not lunatics. Like I said, it's a different world and my kid's a different kid. But back in the fifties it was a little closer to what

it was like when I was a kid. In the eighties, families had more of an open door policy in their neighborhoods,

and kids came and went with less oversight. That was America, and that was the America in which Brian Wilson formed The Beach Boys with his little brother Dennis and his youngest brother Karl, and their cousin from the neighborhood, Mike Love, and their buddy from school, Al Jardine, And when the band took off and learned part due to the Wilson Boys Dad Murray helping steer them toward a recording contract while they were still in their teens, and when the

band started to tour, Al quit the group to get his college degree it was a sensible thing to do, with rock and roll not being anybody's idea of a stable career choice. And when Al quit, Carl's buddy from across the street, David Marx took his place, and there

were new auditions. It was that simple. After the band took off, after they'd spent nineteen sixty four jockeying with the Beatles at the top of the charts with incredible singles like I Get Around, Fun, Fun, Fun, a year in which the Beach Boys would release four full length albums, when all the pressure caught up with Brian Wilson and brought for the first time his mental illness to the forefront of the band after he suffered a massive anxiety

attack on an airplane flight, Brian simply decided that he wouldn't tour anymore, and he was quickly replaced by a friend, a burgeoning singer songwriter named Glenn Campbell. And when Glenn's own solo career took off, requiring him to leave the Beach Boys, the Wilsons and their cousin Mike turned to their buddy Bruce Johnston to replace Glenn as Brian's replacement on the road. Shortly after David Marks quit, but that was no sweat. By then Al Jardine was ready to rejoin.

It sounds complicated, but it wasn't. The Beach Boys. Their revolving personnel door reminds me of a neighborhood pickup game of football. Oh, Stax has to go home early for dinner, but the game's not over. No sweat. Just go knock on Mike's door and get them to come out and replace Stacks. Wait a minute, Barney has to leave too. Grabs Seth from over on the other side of the park, and let's keep playing. There were no egos, no her feelings,

just boys being boys, just beach boys. And the brothers Wilson and their cousin Mike loved the music they were making with the Beach Boys, and they loved the music they'd grown up on, the Four Freshmen, the Everly Brothers, the Ronettes, the Ventures Link Ray, and they loved channeling that music into a vision of America that they were almost solely responsible for exporting across the world. But despite the subject matter of so many of their songs, the

Beach Boys did not love to surf. With the exception of Dennis Wilson, the Beach Boys, they spent little time at the beach. We covered this in our previous two Beach Boys episodes, which you can revisit if you like. But the point here is that the Beach Boys from their earliest days were less of a band and more of an idea, an idea of what America could be, and that came from their love of what their lives

and family had been up to that point. The same love drove the bands one for all and all for one approach to making music at home, in the studio and on the road. It didn't really matter who was in the Beach Boys at the time, as long as the train kept on chugging. The band, Mike, Dennis, Carl Al and Bruce toured incessantly to sell the songs that

Brian stayed home to write. Eventually, Brian would begin recording on his own with an incredible group of LA Studio musicians known as the Wrecking Crew, who worked with superstars arranging from Frank Sinatra to Elvis Presley. The idea was that the boys in the band, upon returning to LA would help Brian finish the songs by laying down their patented, tight knit vocal harmonies by nineteen sixty six. The result was, to Paul McCartney anyway, undeniable. Pet Sounds, the Beach Boys

nineteen sixty six album, was a masterpiece. Brian created a technicolor version of what his hero, the producer Phil Spector, had established before her. Pet Sounds took Phil's layered wall of sound technique and raced it towards the Summer of Love in a way that no one at the time

thought was possible. Few Paul McCartney aside even understood it, and even some of the Beach Boys themselves were skeptical, notably Mike Love, who lobbied for a return to what had always worked for the group, songs about sun girls and fast cars. But over the years Mike Love has become known as the Pet Sounds boogeyman. But that's not quite fair. Pet Sounds was a commercial flop. Hardly anyone got it at the time. Be honest, when you first heard Pet Sounds, did you love it? Did you really?

I didn't. I didn't pay attention to it. I didn't pay attention to whatever Pet Sounds single I heard first as a kid. But I did pay attention to Barbara Ann and help me. Ronda, like I said, was a little kid after all, not sophisticated enough to understand the genius of Pet Sounds. And that's pretty much what the world was like, with few exceptions in nineteen sixty six, not sophisticated enough to understand Brian Wilson's genius. Just yet. He was breaking the mold with Pet Sounds. There was

no comparison, no roadmap. I don't blame Mike Love whatever his ignorance or lack of understanding was for Pet Sounds. The dude wrote the lyrics to Good Vibration, so he gets a pass. But Brian Wilson's genius wouldn't let him off the hook. Fragile as he was increasingly running off the rails with LSD and marijuana and alcohol, all of

which were echoing the literal voices in his head. With dread, Brian was unable to complete the Beach Boys' next record, Smile, and from there he was in and out of the band for a string of records Smiley, Smile, Wild Honey and Friends. And in this period of the Beach Boys had some incredible moments like the aforementioned Good Vibration single and Heroes and Villains from Smiley Smile, the title track from Wild Honey, and Little Bird from Friends among them.

But these moments were mostly about a group trying to find their place and a culture that had left them where it thought the Beach Boys belonged in the past. By nineteen sixty nine, Brian Wilson was back underwater figuratively, yes, but sinking nonetheless. Smacked down by endless waves of addiction, self doubt and growing mental illness, he was down under

the surface, his chest filled with dread. He couldn't breathe never mind create, and by the end of the decade, the love that Brian Wilson had used to fuel the Beach Boy's rise, the love for his family, for his brothers, for rock and roll, for an idealized version of the America.

He was lucky enough to grow up in his love of Phil Spector, for the Four Freshmen, the everleas Gershwin, his love of harmony so tight they made Lennon and McCartney burn with jealousy of melodies nobody, but he was able to hear of sounds and arrangements that made Box Ghost smile. All that love, by nineteen sixty nine was being drowned out. It was no match for the drugs

in alcohol and the growing mental illness. By the end of the decade, a darkness like the dead of the ocean had consumed Brian Wilson, just as it had the rest of sixties culture, and for America, all that love

had curdled into something worse than hate. Chapter two murder by nineteen sixty nine, with the culture turning its collective back on the decidedly unhipped Beach Boys, with Brian Wilson increasingly isolated and unavailable creatively to the point of being admitted into a psychiatric hospital in nineteen sixty nine to address his growing mental illness, specifically the voices in his head that he was hearing alongside all those great harmonies

that were driving a mad The Beach Boys needed songs, songs that would resonate with a record buying public that the band now felt disconnected from. Dennis Wilson had an idea. His little guru friend, the one who had all the young girls following him around, the girls that Dennis and his friend Terry Melcher were sleeping with. That little dude, Charlie. He had songs. Now Terry didn't hear it, but Dennis

did so Dennis brought Charles Manson into the studio. The knife flashed out of Charlie's pocket in an instant, and Charlie waved it all around the room crazy, like a shithouse rat. He aimed it at the vocal booth and then wheeled it towards Dennis, right next to him in

the control room, and pressed it to his throat. The blade was warm on his neck and the fear was cold in his veins, and Dennis froze and felt that now familiar Charlie chill ride his spine if I hear one more fucking note from you, I swear man respect the prism fuckers. He then put the knife away. Everyone acted as if this was somehow cool. Dennis included. Things in the studio were not going well for Brian Wilson's brother Dennis with Charles Manson, but Dennis wasn't so easily dissuaded.

In the summer of nineteen sixty eight, he went back and forth between wanting to do right by Charlie to getting Charlie and the girls out of his life. Nis to the throat aside, no pussy was worth one hundred grand in a rotting package. He brought Charlie and the girls into the studio to try to get something down himself.

It was nothing short of a nightmare. The recording session devolved into an orgy, the results of which were captured on tape and to this day have never been heard, and aside from occupying a rather large swath of music history's collective imagination, they are buried somewhere deep in the

Beach Boys vault. They ceased to Exist, which was the title of the Charles Manson song Ceased to Exist that Dennis Wilson decided to purchase off of his wild eyed guru friend in one last desperate attempt to propel the grifter prophet out of his life of hippie squalor and

into music industry stardom. Cease to Exist, a simple folk blues number that Manson penned about well who the fuck really Knows, was purchased by Dennis Wilson for one hundred thousand dollars in a BSA motorcycle that Charlie coveted for use at Spawn Ranch. Dennis brought the track into record with the Beach Boys, passing it off as an original

song that he'd written. Once they had the track in the studio, Dennis, unusually engaged in the process, got down to arranging and producing the track with his brothers Brian and Carl and the rest of the group. They modified the feel from a traditional blues to something more pop, more of a psychedelic ballad that only the Beach Boys, in their tremendous harmony singing, along with Brian's arrangement prowess,

could pull off. They altered Charlie's lyrics cease to Exist became cease to Resist, and a bridge was added to avoid the monotony of Manson's original. Finally, the title was changed from the bleak Ceased to Exist to the hippie Zeitgei's sounding never Learn Not to Love, and the results were pretty stellar. The track is, in a couple of words, fucking awesome. It was featured as a B side to the December nineteen sixty eight Beach Boys single Bluebirds Over

the Mountain. It was later featured on the Beach Boys album twenty twenty. The A side charted and the B side was met with positive reviews, but Charles Manson was not impressed. In fact, Charles Manson was pretty pissed off. Pissed off at Brian Wilson's brother Dennis, and Dennis who Charlie believes screwed him over, screwed him over by messing with his song, and screwed him over by not working hard enough to get his friend, producer Terry Melcher, to

help Charlie launch his career. As one version of the story goes, this is why Manson directed his followers to the house Dennis and Bryan's friend Terry Melcher once lived in and where director Roman Polanski and his pregnant wife, the actress Sharon Tate now lived the house that was in nineteen sixty nine. All over the news on Brian Wilson's television set, We.

Speaker 2

Have a weird homicide. Later last night, another bizarre murder in Los Angeles, the second in two days.

Speaker 3

Roland Polanski, the film director and husband of Sharon Tate, Paul Newsman to a hotel in Hollywood today, and there he made a long emotional statement total a good deal of what had been on his mind since his pregnant wife and four others were killed at their home on August eighth. Twenty one year old Susan Atkins is involved in still another murder case.

Speaker 2

She appeared in the Santa Monica City courtroom this morning to enter a plea in a trial stemming from the July thirty first murder of thirty four year old Gary Tinman. Los Angeles police have placed miss Atkins on his saty gluts at the scene of the Tate murder, taking into account the published report in the Los Angeles Times, the story that Susan Atkins told about what allegedly happened that night after the murder at the Tate house. We drove

from Clo Drive at the base of Benedict Canyon. Up here we found some trousers and some shirts appeared to be turtleneck shirts or something.

Speaker 3

Dark in color.

Speaker 2

Did they appear to have any stains on them?

Speaker 3

This is where they lived, among the stables, barns, and tony buildings of an old rundown movie location twenty.

Speaker 2

Miles from Los Angeles.

Speaker 3

They called themselves the Family.

Speaker 2

Five members are now in jail on.

Speaker 3

Other churches in the Desert John of Independence. The family's leader, Charles Manson, is jailed here. It is expected that he will be charged on the Tate murders.

Speaker 1

Weird say it was Dennis Wilson, who brought the Manson family into the Beach Boys family, and the guilt he felt for his involvement, no matter how unintentional, in the Manson murders, would drive Dennis harder into drugs and alcohol and further away from his brothers in the creative center of the band. Brian Wilson and the rest of the Beach Boys did what they could to distance themselves from what was about to become known as Helter Skelter, the

Crime of the Century. But in nineteen sixty nine, the bottomless blackwater that Charles Manson left in his wake flooded the band, nearly drowning Brian, and the worst thing to come that year hadn't even happened yet. We'll be right back after this. We're We're where, Chapter three, Theft. It was November in nineteen sixty nine and Brian Wilson was alone with his father Murray, in the house he grew up in. But his and his father's voices were not

the only voices Brian was hearing. Brian heard his father shouting above all the rest, and Brian exploded in anger, fear, and disappointment. Trying to quiet the sounds that were consuming him. Brian grabbed plates, glasses, silverware, whatever he could get his hands on. They're rocking again with his father. His father's voice only grew louder, and Brian cried out in response, a cry of anguish, of deep pain, so deep, so painful,

so dark. He didn't recognize it. It only made his father raise his voice more, and Brian pinned himself to the kitchen wall and exploded in tears, a grown man twenty seven years old, crying for his father to stop yelling. But the pain kept coming. It rose up from his feet, passed his ankles, above his knees. He was waiting in it now, and the only thing stronger than the rising anguish was the power of his father's voice screaming at Brian. And the pain rose up into his chest and filled

his lungs, and Brian began hyperventilating. His father explained that there was no other way. Brian was no good, he was washed up. He'd never write hit songs again. The public had moved on from the Beach Boys, from Brian Wilson. He wasn't back, for God's sake. He wasn't Phil Specter either.

He wasn't even Lawrence Welk. Brian would be lucky to get a job fetching coffee for Burt Bacharack at the rate he was going and the pain was up to his neck now, and Brian still pinned against the wall, arched his head up, chin first to stay above it, but it was no use. He was drowning right there in his father's kitchen. His father's voice rang out, still louder now in some sick harmony with the voices inside

Brian's head. Chuck Berry's, just who the fuck did Brian think he was trying to cash in on his walking roll, letting his little brother rip off all those riffs and Paul McCartney's Brian pet sounds as good, but it was no Peppers it was, And what happened to smile?

Speaker 3

Brian?

Speaker 1

We made the white album? What have you done? And of course Phil Specters, so you never should have come for the wall. Sound kid, you shoot with the king and you better not miss. But his father's voice eventually drown out all the other scene. I had to do it, Brian, you finished. That's why don't you see that? Don't you see that? I got as much for us for you as anyone could more. Because Brian Wilson's father, Maury, had

just sold Brian Wilson's songs. And before we get into the mechanics of this crime, I have to explain what this means for a songwriter. I've done so in past episodes, but it bears repeating. Aside from their children, a songwriter, songs are literally the most important things in their lives. For Brian Wilson in nineteen sixty nine, his soul was wrapped up in his songs I get around Surfing USA. God only knows good vibrations. Those songs were his identity.

Being the composer of Beach Boys tunes was who Brian Wilson was. And for Brian Wilson, it wasn't just his history tied up in all those enormously popular songs. It was his family history which made his connection to his tunes even stronger. And his father, his father, had just sold them to someone else, making matters worse. It's arguable, almost certain, actually, that his father did so illegally, thus stealing from Brian, his son the things that mattered most

to him in this world. Back in nineteen sixty four, leading up to this theft, Brian and his brothers and cousin Mike fired Murray from his role as their manager, largely because Murray Wilson had become a major pay and the ass for the band, inserting himself into the creative process on top of being a world class dick to

his kids and to his nephew. The deal is that Murray would get to continue his involvement with the band, a band, let's be fair that he did help launch toward their initial success, but a band that by nineteen sixty four definitely did not need him in any creative capacity or even in any real business capacity anymore. So Murray was allowed to stay involved and handle the Beach

Boys publishing. That was it. There's another way of saying that Murray was now tasked with managing the band's songs and finding ancillary ways for the Beach Boys music to

make money. But one of the first things Murray did in his role as publisher of the Beach Boys songs was make sure that Brian and only Brian was registered as the songwriter, thus cutting out his nephew Mike Love from his share of the songwriting royalties and making sure that all of the songwriting revenue flowed into the Wilson

household alone. Murray then pressured his son Brian to reassign the publishing share of his royalties, essentially fifty percent of the revenue to him Murray, in exchange for Murray handling the administration of the songs. According to Murray, Brian agreed. Also, according to Murray, Brian later agreed to give up his own control of his songwriting share, which is something that

Brian absolutely never did. These so called negotiations around the Beach Boys publishing happened while Brian's drug use in the nineteen sixties was at its peak and his mental illness was rearing its head and spinning him out of control. For much of nineteen sixty nine, Brian Wilson didn't even get out of bed, and when he did, he spent his time playing piano in an indoor sandbox, or at least imagining what it would be like to play piano

in an indoor sandbox. He wouldn't actually have the indoor sandbox installed for a couple more years, but the point is that Brian was spiraling in nineteen sixty nine. He was in no condition to negotiate with his domineering father for control of his song catalog, and his father, of all people, knew this, but that didn't stop that sneaky Murray Wilson from selling the Beach Boys song catalog for seven hundred thousand dollars in November of nineteen sixty nine,

and this development absolutely wrecked his son. The rationale that the Beach Boys were washed up and had to sell their catalog in nineteen sixty nine in order to get anything for their songs while they still had some juice is beyond shortsighted. The catalog is estimated to be worth two hundred million today and the Beach Boys still don't

own it. In nineteen eighty nine, Brian sued to reclaim the copyrights and some royalties, and he was forced to settle out of court for an undisclosed amount, and in nineteen ninety four, Mike Love had to sue Brian for the credit his uncle, Brian's father screwed him out of and Mike won. But again, the songs are still not theirs these days. They're owned and controlled by Universal Music, the biggest music company on the planet. So when you see a Beach Boy song and a Chili's commercial don't

blame Brian and Mike, blame Murray. Fifty plus years ago, when Maury sprung this news on Brian, it devastated him, and it only drove him harder into drugs and alcohol, deeper into paranoia and drowning beneath the sounds of the voices in his head. Brian Wilson needed serious help, a doctor, twenty four hour medical care. Instead, what he was about to get was falsely imprisoned. Chapter four, Manipulation. It was the mid eighties. Brian Wilson was sitting at his piano.

The Beach Boys were no longer a part of his life. They were on the road, or in the studio, or somewhere somewhere far from Brian's thoughts. The voices in his head were all he could concentrate on at the moment, which was a problem because Brian had to concentrate on the song he was trying to get down. The longer he went on without writing anything of importance, the more upset as Doctor would get, and Brian didn't want to upset Eugene Landy. Doctor Landy wanted hits. Doctor Landy wanted genius.

Doctor Landy wanted to be the one who brought the genius Brian Wilson back to the top with a hit record, A hit record that he doctor Eugene Landy, would co write and produce. It was possible, the Good Doctor reasoned, after all, he himself was a genius, even more so than Brian Wilson. Brian had brains, sure, but they were all over the place, and it was only through the strength of his genius that Brian Wilson was even still alive,

never mind recording music again. By the mid nineteen seventies, Brian Wilson was a barefoot recluse in a bathroom, chain smoking in bed for months on end, surviving on cocaine and cheeseburgers, and racked by fear, while his brothers and bandmates carried on without him, they themselves too burned out to stage an intervention, but still too caring not to.

It was decided that doctor Eugene Landy, a showbiz shrink with a Messiah complex, should be hired, and so he was, and in nineteen seventy five, the Good Doctor went to work dragging Brian out of his bedroom exile and back into show business. Miraculously, his efforts worked. Brian lost weight cleaned up a little and rejoined the Beach Boys on stage, and so Landy was dismissed and Brian was better, and

then he wasn't. When Brian crashed out again in nineteen eighty two, doctor Landy was rehired and this time given tighter can control. A year later, when Brian's brother Dennis drown doctor Landy put his control to the test to help manage Brian's grief, and Brian was in such bad shape by then that doctor Landy was granted legal guardianship, working under a mandate to do whatever it took however he deemed necessary to help save what was left of

the broken beach Boy. Once Landy had full control, he medicated Brian into imprisonment. He dosed him into submission with meds, cut him off from his family, and went as far as rewriting Brian's will to include himself. This is on top of paying himself thirty five thousand dollars a month and attempting to insert ownership of Brian's songwriting, publishing, and eventually to collaborating with Brian on his new album, which doctor Eugene Landy wanted to call Brain's Ingenius. Brian being

the brains and him Gene being the genius. Get it dipshit, and Brian was too sedated to fight back. He sat at the piano and pecked out noises while the doctor screamed that he was doing it all wrong. Doctor Landy was on the precipice of taking everything, not just Brian's possessions, but his physical and mental capacity, and now not just

his songwriting but his creative process. Brian was powerless at the piano, a broken down musical genius, heavily drugged against his will, his mouth agape, drooling, being screamed at by a quack doctor telling him Brian Wilson how to write songs. It's a scene so absurd that it's hard to believe, but it happened. And that's right around when Doctor Landy's own unraveling began. He pushed to be credited as co writer an executive producer for his efforts in shaping Brian's

solo record. He nearly made it happen. He did succeed in getting his girlfriend listed as a lyricist on multiple tracks, but those efforts raised suspicion, and other people around Brian started asking questions when they did. Landy shut them out, and this raised their suspicions further. Brian's new girlfriend at

the time, Melinda Ledbetter, wouldn't back down. She worked with Brian's daughters, Carneye and Wendy Wilson, and together they built a legal case to free Brian from doctor Eugene Landy's unethical treatment and guardianship. Ultimately, Landy would not be criminally prosecuted, but a Los Angeles Superior Court judge ruled that he'd violated professional boundaries and ethical standards, and he was legally barred from contacting Brian Wilson again. As a result, California's

Board of Psychology revoked his license to practice. It was also deemed in court that Brian Wilson had been mentally incapable of making informed legal decisions at the time doctor Eugene Landy inserted himself into Brian's will. Mercifully, those documents were voided and the doctor was completely extricated from Brian Wilson's life. Landy's girlfriend did manage to retain her songwriting credits, and it is suspected that she received some royalties from

Brian's solo album. Eventually, however, her credits were struck down, and it is believed that those shady royalty payments ceased, and one of those songs was one of Brian Wilson's greatest achievements, the song Love and Mercy Chapter five Mercy. After doctor Eugene Landy was banished from his orbit, Brian Wilson began the long, slow crawl back to himself. He married Melinda Ledbetter, the woman who helped save his life, and for a time he found peace in her steadiness.

He reunited with the Beach Boys and Fragments, patched things up with his brother Carl before cancer took him in nineteen ninety eight, and stood beside the surviving bandmates on anniversary tours. But the real triumph came when Brian, backed by gifted musicians called the Wonderments, led by bandleader Darien san Naja, finally finished Smile, the lost master work that

had driven Brian mad and haunted him for decades. In two thousand and four, he brought the album to the stage, alive and whole for the first time, to triumphant standing ovations. And then came more albums, global tours, a biopic, and the long overdue recognition that Brian Wilson wasn't just a fragile genius. He was a survivor, a man whose voice was erased for a long time by the voices in his own head, had finally succeeded in quieting the noise

and found himself for his final act. I believe that Love and Mercy the simple leadoff track from Brian's self titled album, which Doctor Landy tried to spend Gali. That song, to me is Brian Wilson at his core. It's not a particularly robust production. It's a simple melody with simple, beautiful harmonies. It's not trying to be something it's not. It's a man in pain at his piano, singing into a microphone and putting himself aside and trying to ease

the pain of others. In researching this episode, I purposefully avoided learning about how that song was produced. I know that it was part of the era when Brian was being abused by Doctor Landy, but I don't know much else except how the song came out, and what the song sounds like and what it says. And I like my vision of how I imagine Brian made that song better than anything I could read in a book or online.

When listening to interviews with Brian Wilson and reading his autobiography, you get a pretty good look into the man's soul. He was delicate, childlike, funny, generous, aware, filled with life and love and mercy. Brian talks about his struggles with his father and with his doctor, and to a lesser degree, with his cousin Mike, and his bandmates brothers, and in all of that you hear zero spite and somehow very little judgment. You even hear forgiveness. It's quite beautiful, actually.

It's a story that began with love, somehow overcame the true crime hardships of murder, theft and manipulation, and ultimately still somehow ended with mercy, love and mercy. I like to picture Brian Wilson at his piano writing the song Love and Mercy, under the full way of psychotic oppression, and there, at his lowest moment, he's choosing to sing about bringing love and mercy to others. It's what a big brother would do, and it's anything but a disgrace.

I'm Jake Brennan, and this this disgrace land.

Speaker 2

All right.

Speaker 1

I hope you dug this episode. Discoes listen Apple podcast listeners, make sure you get auto downloads turned on so you never miss an episode of Disgraceland. This week's question is which musician is the best example of the torture genius. Is it Brian Wilson? Is it someone else? I want to know who, and I want to know why. Tell me Who's pain shaped something beautiful? Whose story hits you hardest and why it matters? Hit me up voicemail text at six one seven nine oh six sixty six three eight.

Can also find me on Instagram, Facebook, x and at disgracelamdpod at gmail dot com. Leave a review for the show on Apple Podcasts or Spotify wins free merch. This is mythwork, Baby. We uncover the truth, confront the story, and reclaim the music. Brian Wilson did that with pet Sounds with every note, and so do you every time you listen. All right, here comes some credits. Disgraceland was created by Yours Truly and is produced in partnership with

Double Elvis. Credits for this episode can be found on the show notes page at disgracelampod dot com. If you're listening as a Disgraceland All Access member. Thank you for

supporting the show. We really appreciate it, and if not, you can become a member right now by going to disgracelampod dot com slash membership, rate and review the show and follow us on Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, and Facebook at disgracelampod and on YouTube at YouTube dot com slash at disgracelamdpod rock A Rolla, He's the Man.

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android