Crime & Cookie Juice - podcast cover

Crime & Cookie Juice

Detective Chris Anderson & Fatima Silva, Esq.www.crimeandcookiejuice.com

Crime & Cookie Juice is not your typical true-crime podcast. From the hosts of Investigation Discovery’s hit show “Reasonable Doubt,” Crime & Cookie Juice offers opposing views on cases from two experts on opposite ends of our criminal justice system. Join Detective Chris Anderson and Criminal Defense Attorney Fatima Silva as they pour a glass and pore over the evidence of headline cases. In every episode, you will get VIP access to the minds of the best- a detective and a defense attorney. Chris and Fatima will pore through cases, talk to experts, and dig deep into the judicial system. This podcast is not for the faint of heart.


Grab your favorite beverage, put on your detective hat, and join the stars of the hit show, Reasonable Doubt, Detective Chris Anderson, and Fatima Silva, Esq. as they keep fighting for justice and keep the mission of Reasonable Doubt alive! If you are obsessed with True Crime, Anderson and Silva take another look at cases that have been forgotten. This powerful duo has a vantage point that little have access to.

Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

The Sweet Taste of Freedom: The Wrongful Conviction of Evaristo Salas

“Evaristo Salas is a free man. At last. A jury convicted Salas in 1995 of shooting Jose Arreola twice in the head on a foggy November night. Salas was 15 at the time of the killing and 16 when he was imprisoned. The case hinged on testimony of a paid police informant who has since recanted his testimony that Salas was bragging around town about the killing; Arreola’s girlfriend at the time, who reportedly told the victim’s mother that she was only able to identify Salas from a photo montage foll...

Oct 19, 20231 hr 20 min

'You Might Go to Prison, Even Though You're Innocent' with Justin Brooks, Director of the California Innocence Project

Surviving prison as an innocent person is a surreal nightmare no one wants to think about. But it can happen to you. Justin Brooks, Director and Co-Founder of the California Innocence Project, has spent his career freeing innocent people from prison. With You Might Go to Prison, Even Though You're Innocent , he offers up-close accounts of the cases he has fought, embedding them within a larger landscape of innocence claims and robust research on what we know about the causes of wrongful convicti...

Mar 29, 20231 hr 12 minEp. 21

Freed After 30 Years in Prison: The Murder of Dana Feitler and the Wrongful Conviction of Lee Harris

After a night out celebrating her acceptance into grad school, Dana Feitler returned home to her apartment complex in Chicago's affluent Gold Coast neighborhood where she was abducted by 3 men. After forcing her to withdraw $400 from ATM, she was lead to an alley and shot and killed. Desperate for leads, police turned to a cop-friendly informant, willing to say anything to help them. That person was Lee Harris. Lee said he was helping police in return for reward money put up by the victim’s fami...

Mar 22, 202351 minEp. 20

The War on Drugs Podcast with Clayton English and Greg Glod

Drug overdoses in the US are at a record high. Heroin has been replaced by the single deadliest drug threat to our nation, Fentanyl. Marijuana has been decriminalized in over 20 states, yet people remain in federal prison serving mandatory sentences for possession and sale of marijuana. In the past fifty years, the ‘war’ on drugs has fueled incarceration, exacerbated addiction and hampered economic progress. Lava for Good's The War on Drugs podcast, co-hosted by comedian Clayton English and Greg...

Mar 15, 202357 minEp. 19

Headline Cases with Chris & Fatima: Kidnapped in Mexico and the Murdaugh Jurors Speak Out

The verdict is in and the jurors are talking! Join Chris and Fatima as they go over headline cases, including how the jurors arrived at a unanimous verdict so quickly in the Murdaugh case and the latest on four Americans kidnapped in Mexico. Join the stars of ID's hit show, Reasonable Doubt, Detective Chris Anderson and Fatima Silva, Esq. for the podcast that fans have been waiting for. Chris and Fatima talk all things true crime, including cases they investigated on Reasonable Doubt. About Chri...

Mar 08, 202351 minEp. 18

The Murdaugh Murders: A Father on Trial

On June 7, 2021, Alex Murdaugh called police from his cell phone at 10:06 pm, saying he had discovered the bodies of his 52-year-old wife Maggie and their 22-year-old son Paul near the dog kennels at the family's hunting lodge in South Carolina. Both had been shot multiple times and with different weapons. Almost two years later, Alex Murdaugh is on trial for the double homicide of his own family. It's a trial rife with drugs, lies, and scandals. Join Chris & Fatima and they discuss their di...

Mar 01, 202348 minEp. 17

'Man, You Are Crazy': Destigmatizing PTSD in Law Enforcement with Former Police Officer Kevin Donaldson

It is estimated that, on average, approximately 15% of officers in the U.S. experience PTSD symptoms. More police officers and firefighters die by suicide than in the line of duty. They are front-row witnesses to horrific atrocities including, suicides, motor vehicle accidents that result in trauma and/or death, child abuse or neglect, overdoses, and acts of domestic violence. Exposure to these traumatic daily events impairs their well-being and affects their ability to perform duties to the pub...

Feb 22, 20231 hr 7 minEp. 16

Vanished in the Snow: The Disappearance of Jonelle Matthews with Former CNN reporter Ashley Fantz

December 1984, the town of Greeley, Colorado, is getting into the Christmas spirit. At a school holiday concert, 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews sings alongside her classmates. Later that night, she’s dropped off to an empty house. By the time her family returns, Jonelle has vanished. For more than 3 1/2 decades, Jonelle’s disappearance was a mystery. Was she taken? Did she runaway? Was she still alive? Then, in 2019, Jonelle’s remains were discovered near the foothills of the Rocky Mountains, only...

Feb 15, 20231 hr 8 minEp. 15

The Disappearance of Ana Walshe with Professor of Forensic Psychology, Dr. Katherine Ramsland

On January 4, 2023, real estate executive and mother of three, Ana Walshe, was reported missing by her employer and, separately, by her husband, Brian Walshe. She was last seen early on January 1, having had dinner with Brian and a friend of his on New Year's Eve. After an initial arrest on January 8 for misleading investigators, Brian was charged on January 18 with murder and disinterring a body without authority, to which he pleaded not guilty; prosecutors allege that he beat her to death and ...

Feb 08, 20231 hr 20 minSeason 1Ep. 14

Be Justice: 'How to Human' with Carlos Whittaker

"Justice is standing up for someone who cannot stand up for themselves, even if you may not agree with everything that they are. One thing that you can connect over is they are human and so are you." - 'How to Human' by Carlos Whittaker In this uplifting and encouraging episode of Crime & Cookie Juice, author and self-professed "hope dealer", Carlos Whittaker, talks his latest book, 'How to Human' and explains three ways to share life beyond what distracts, divides, and disconnects us. This ...

Feb 01, 20231 hr 8 minEp. 13

Innocent Behind Bars: 'Bone Valley' Podcast with Host and Pulitzer Prize Winning Author, Gilbert King

​​In 1987, 18-year-old Michelle Schofield was found dead in a phosphate pit in Florida. Two years later, her husband Leo was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. Fifteen years later, previously unidentified fingerprints matched Jeremy Scott--a violent teenager who lived nearby. Jeremy has since confessed to Michelle’s murder. Yet Leo Schofield remains behind bars. In his groundbreaking podcast, Bone Valley, host Gilbert King uncovers startling new evidence that Jeremy is responsible for a ...

Jan 28, 20231 hr 28 minEp. 12

It's Cookie Juice Time with the Nation's First Black Female Whiskey Blender, Eboni Major

The demographics for whiskey drinkers are changing quickly and Eboni Major is proud to be a part of that evolution. As one of the first Black women whiskey blenders in the U.S., Eboni is paving the way for the future generations of women of color in the whiskey industry. Bulleit's former master blender (and Birmingham native) just dropped her own bourbon with Dread River Distillery Co. and Detective Chris Anderson is excited to talk all about this delicious bourbon. Follow Eboni Major on IG @maj...

Jan 18, 202343 minEp. 11

The Latest on the Idaho Murders Featuring Veteran FBI Special Agent, Bobby Chacon, and DNA Expert, Arthur Young

A suspect has been arrested in the University of Idaho student murders. Bryan Kohberger faces murder charges in the stabbing deaths of Ethan Chapin, 20, Xana Kernodle, 20, Kaylee Goncalves, 21, and Madison Mogen, 21, on Nov. 13. Join Detective Chris Anderson and Criminal Defense Attorney Fatima Silva as they analyze the latest evidence in the case. This episode features veteran FBI Special Agent, Bobby Chacon, and DNA Expert, Arthur Young. About Bobby Chacon: Bobby spent 27 years with the FBI. H...

Jan 11, 202350 minEp. 10

New Year: Fresh Perspectives. Tips for True-Crime Junkies Featuring Life Coach Emel Mutlu

Did you know that the average American consumes about 34 gigabytes of data and information each day — an increase of about 350 percent over nearly three decades? It's no wonder why many of us are feeling anxious and overwhelmed these days. A New Year is a great opportunity to practice more stillness and reflection, but how can we do that when there are distractions all around us? This special episode is our holiday gift to our listeners. We want you to take care of yourself, especially when dige...

Jan 04, 202349 minEp. 9

Holiday Special with Angel’s Envy Co-Founder Wes Henderson

Happy Holidays from the Crime & Cookie Juice team! In this special holiday episode, Chris & Fatima get to sit down with Wes Henderson, the Co-Founder of Chris’ favorite bourbon: Angel’s Envy. Wes Henderson isn’t just the creator of one of the most groundbreaking bourbons; he is also a Death Investigator/Deputy Coroner, Pilot, former Firefighter, and Dad to six boys. Join us as we dive into all things crime and bourbon. Join the stars of ID's hit show, Reasonable Doubt, Detective Chris An...

Dec 28, 20221 hr 2 minEp. 8

The Psychology of Killers and Violent Offenders Featuring Forensic Psychologist Dana Anderson

A 10 year-old boy in Wisconsin recently shot and killed his own mother over a virtual reality headset. In Idaho, four college students were brutally stabbed to death while they slept. What drives a person to commit such horrendous crimes? How can trauma impact our mental health and lead to violent behavior? Join Detective Chris Anderson, Attorney Fatima Silva and special guest, Forensic Psychologist Dr. Dana Anderson, as they dive into the pathology of killers and violent offenders. About Dr. Da...

Dec 21, 202243 minEp. 7

Lyin' Eyes: Mistaken Eyewitness Identification in Criminal Cases. The CJ Rice Case Featuring Eyewitness Expert Jules Epstein

Eyewitness misidentification is by far the leading cause of wrongful convictions. Nationwide, 75% of wrongful convictions that were overturned by DNA testing involved erroneous identifications from victims or witnesses. In this episode, Detective Chris Anderson and Fatima Silva, Esq. discuss the CJ Rice case in Philadelphia and speak with eyewitness expert, Jules Epstein, on why eyewitness identification is often fallible and unreliable. About Jules Epstein: Jules Epstein is a Professor of Law a...

Dec 14, 202254 minEp. 6

Confessing To A Crime You Didn't Commit? The Chanel Lewis Case Featuring False Confessions Expert Alan Hirsch

Out of 375 exonerations in the USA, about 30% involved false confessions. That means one in 3 people who have been proven innocent by DNA, false confessed. In this episode, Detective Chris Anderson and Defense Attorney Fatima Silva discuss why false confessions are so common. They continue discussion of the murder of New York City jogger, Karina Vetrano, and the validity of the confession of convicted Brooklyn native, Chanel Lewis. False Confessions Expert, Alan Hirsch, explains how to spot a fa...

Dec 07, 202241 minEp. 5

Headline Cases with Chris and Fatima: The University of Idaho Murders and the Deadly Beating of Shanquilla Robinson

Join the stars of ID's hit show, Reasonable Doubt, Detective Chris Anderson and Fatima Silva, Esq. for the podcast that fans have been waiting for. Chris and Fatima talk all things true crime, including cases they investigated on Reasonable Doubt. In this episode, Chris and Fatima discuss cases in the headlines including the slaying of four University of Idaho students and the brutal beating that left 25 year-old Shanquilla Robinson dead while on a vacation in Mexico. About Chris Anderson and Fa...

Nov 30, 202242 minEp. 4

Touch DNA: Helpful or Harmful? The Murder of New York City Jogger Karina Vetrano, Featuring DNA Expert Arthur Young

Join the stars of ID's hit show, Reasonable Doubt, Detective Chris Anderson and Fatima Silva, Esq. for the podcast that fans have been waiting for. Chris and Fatima talk all things true crime, including cases they investigated on Reasonable Doubt. In this episode, Chris and Fatima discuss the murder of New York City jogger, Karina Vetrano, and question the DNA evidence used to convict Brooklyn native, Chanel Lewis, for her murder. Seasoned Forensic Biology Specialist, Arthur Young, explains the ...

Nov 23, 202247 minEp. 3

A Murder Without A Body: The Kristin Smart Disappearance Featuring Crime Scene Investigator Alina Burroughs

Join the stars of ID's hit show, Reasonable Doubt, Detective Chris Anderson and Fatima Silva, Esq. for the podcast that fans have been waiting for. Chris and Fatima talk all things true crime, including cases they investigated on Reasonable Doubt. In this episode, Chris and Fatima discuss the 1996 disappearance of Kristin Smart and the recent trial of her convicted killer, Paul Flores. Seasoned crime scene investigator, Alina Burroughs, weighs in on the physical evidence used to convict Paul Flo...

Nov 16, 202252 minEp. 2

True Crime and Cookie Juice With Detective Chris Anderson and Fatima Silva

Do you know the stars of ID's hit show Reasonable Doubt? Detective Chris Anderson and Fatima Silva have graced Discovery Channel for five years bringing true stories to television. They are doing the true-crime work that others ignore. Anderson and Silva talk all things true crime and pore over the evidence. You will get the behind the scenes access to these two stars while they enjoy their favorite beverage, "Cookie Juice". What is cookie juice? You will find out in this episode! Join the stars...

Nov 11, 202245 minEp. 1
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android