Come On Down - podcast cover

Come On Down

John Baker and Jonathan Motneywww.comeondownshow.com

For nearly 70 years, television game shows have captivated American audiences. In this comedic podcast, friends John Baker and Jonathan Motney delve into a different game show each episode, exploring the formats, highlights, controversies, and more.

Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Queen For a Day

There’s a lot you can say about this post-World War 2 game show, and it’s likely that not a lot of it would be good. We take a look back and analyze this show through a 2021 lens, and fondly remember those days of yore when parading out women to share their sob stories, and then voting (by applause) on who is the most pathetic, was still socially acceptable.

Jul 13, 20211 hrEp. 46

Concentration

What's better than a game show based on a puzzle game you played as a kid? A game show based on TWO puzzle games you played as a kid. We take you from Concentration's start in the 50s through Alex Trebek's run in the 90s.

Jun 29, 20211 hr 3 minEp. 45

Would I Lie To You?

It’s the one question where the answer is almost always yes. Of course I would. This British panel show helps us find out which celebrities are the best liars, and which are the best at sniffing them out. Join us as we put on our transatlantic voices to listen to people with funny accents tell amusing lies and stories in order to earn points that ultimately mean nothing.

Jun 22, 20211 hr 9 minEp. 44

America Says

This week, we discuss the game show that’s kind of like Simon Says, but the power of the world’s mightiest government compels you to do their bidding at the threat of military force. Veteran mockumentary actor John Michael Higgins hosts this laugh-a-minute tour through American colonization, imperialism, and genocide. Either that, or it’s a Game Show Network knockoff of Family Feud.

Jun 15, 20211 hr 1 minEp. 43

You Bet Your Life

If you only wanted to watch a game show if it wasn't really a game show, this might be the game show for you. Groucho Marx grew a real mustache to host this post-war NBC hit (World War II being the aforementioned war). This week, we learn all about it, smoke some cigars, and ask what's wrong with reality TV.

Jun 08, 20211 hr 9 minEp. 42

Sale of the Century

If you love a great deal, this is the game show for you. Get a stereo system for $5, a family vacation for $15, and get bamboozled into coming back to defend your title the next day and almost certainly walking away with nothing. This week, we dive into Sale of the Century, break down how it works, its Ameri-Austral-ican origins, and do some really bad accents.

Jun 01, 20211 hr 4 minEp. 41

The Dating Game

Do you like dating people, but hate having to make an informed decision about who to date? This show might be for you! We head back to the Swinging Sixties to learn about the game, hunt down a serial killer, and figure out if you were a raccoon, what would be your favorite piece of trash and why.

May 25, 20211 hr 6 minEp. 40

Cash Cab

Tune into the ONLY podcast that takes place entirely inside an apartment. This week, we delve into our first game show from the Discovery Channel: Cash Cab. Learn about host Ben Bailey, try your hand at the red light challenge, and help us figure out why this show is on Bravo now.

May 11, 20211 hr 5 minEp. 39

Hollywood Squares

This week, a couple of squares take you through Hollywood Squares: the only game show where you play tic-tac-toe on Joan Rivers’ face. We talk about their Brady Bunch opening credits-looking set, the hosts, the center squares, testicular cancer, and so much more.

May 04, 20211 hr 7 minEp. 38

Guts

This week, we answer the question: Do you have it? Join John "The Piranha" Baker and Jonathan "Maniac" Motney as we take you through the story of Nickelodeon Guts, try to bring home a glowing piece of the Crag, and go to Mo for the scores.

Apr 27, 20211 hr 7 minEp. 37

Password

Celebrities, one word clues, love connections: Password had it all. Well, mostly just those three things. This week, we talk through this word association game's debut in the 60s, it's Plus-sized and Super versions (you know, like tampons), and more.

Apr 20, 20211 hr 11 minEp. 36

Chain Reaction

When disco went out, Chain Reaction came in. This early 80s game show is like a game you’d find in the puzzles section of the Sunday Times. We break down all six degrees of this game, talk through its history and hosts, and try to alternate words for an hourlong podcast.

Apr 13, 20211 hr 5 minEp. 35

Press Your Luck

This week, we go for big bucks and no whammies as we break down Press Your Luck. Learn about the history of the show, a little bit of scandal, and its recent revival.

Apr 06, 20211 hr 5 minEp. 34

Nick Arcade

Long before Ready Player One, Nick Arcade put kids in the game. This episode, we talk about the Nickelodeon game show that combined trivia, video game skills, and a bunch of weatherman-adjacent skills.

Mar 30, 20211 hr 3 minEp. 33

Cherries Wild

Imagine a game show that’s actually just a really long commercial. Now imagine the guy most famous for getting intimate with a pie hosting that game show. Congratulations, you’re a Pepsi executive. This week, we discuss the Jason Biggs-hosted Cherries Wild, dive back into American Pie, and more.

Mar 23, 20211 hr 3 minEp. 32

Pyramid

It’s both a game show and the strongest shape. The show that started out as The $10,000 Pyramid (and had bumped up to $100,000) gave us a whole lot of Dick Clark, bad guesses, and even worse clues. This week we dive into The Pyramid in all its forms, its schemes, and even NFTs (what are they???).

Mar 16, 20211 hr 10 minEp. 31

Deal or No Deal

The great thing about this game show is that you've got a choice. Deal or No Deal put Howie Mandel's shiny dome back on the map, and this week, we dive into the game show, its stylish metal briefcases, Howie's other fine work, and more.

Mar 09, 20211 hr 13 minEp. 30

Let’s Make a Deal

Since the dawn of time, man has been on the hunt for a good deal. And thanks to Monty Hall, there’s no better place to dress in a ridiculous costume and make some deals than on Let’s Make a Deal. In this episode, we get into all the deals, the zonks, the Monty Hall Problem, the Wayne Brady Solution, and more.

Mar 02, 20211 hr 8 minEp. 29

Who Wants to be a Millionaire?

The answer to that question is everybody except billionaires. This week, we give you the final answer on this turn-of-the-century cultural phenomenon and discuss Millionaire's history, controversies, and more.

Feb 23, 20211 hr 14 minEp. 28

Hellevator

If you love portmanteaus, then this is the game show for you. After their success with horror movie hits like Paranormal Activity, The Purge, and the thousand subsequent movies in those franchises, Blumhouse Productions took a dive into the game show world with this haunted house/escape room style GSN original. Listen in to learn about the show, the Twisted Twins who hosted it, and more.

Feb 16, 20211 hr 6 minEp. 27

Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader?

It’s the question on absolutely nobody’s minds, but it needs to be asked anyway. If your name is Jeff Foxworthy, you might be a game show host for a game where contestants attempt to answer supposedly elementary-level trivia questions. This week, we ask the real question: is this whole premise kinda b.s.?

Feb 09, 20211 hr 6 minEp. 26

Shop ‘Til You Drop

Ahhhh, capitalism. Sometimes it’s so so fun, you just have to make game shows celebrating it. In the most early 90s game show imaginable, contestants run through a fake shopping mall exchanging gifts, guessing prices, and more. Learn all about it, take a walk with us down mall memory lane, and make sure you listen ‘til you dristen.

Feb 02, 20211 hr 5 minEp. 25

The Chase

This week, we cut to The Chase. And we only talked about this game show to make that joke right there. Hear about the origins of the game, getting double-Catfished, and more, as we discuss this newly-revived British import.

Jan 26, 20211 hr 8 minEp. 24

Room Raiders

This week, we put on our puka shells and head back to the early 2000s to discuss Room Raiders, the MTV dating show where the winner was the contestant whose mom was the best at cleaning their room. Listen in and learn all about the only dating show where you break the ice by getting kidnapped.

Jan 19, 20211 hr 3 minEp. 23

Name That Tune

We found a game show that includes its entire rulebook in the show’s title. From the 50s to today, people have been naming that tune. Learn all about the show, why Motney has seran-wrap on his ceiling and play along as we try to name that… song.

Jan 12, 20211 hr 6 minEp. 22

Taskmaster

Who can build the tallest structure in 60 seconds? Who can build a bridge from pasta noodles that supports the most weight? Who can get the most podcast subscribers in 4 months? The answer to all those questions is: not us. So let’s dive into the British game show Taskmaster to and see what other challenges lie ahead.

Jan 05, 20211 hr 3 minEp. 21

2020 Year in Review

2020 was an absolutely wild year in the game show podcast world. For example, we started this podcast. Out in the real world, things were also wild, and other people started podcasts, too. Let’s look back at the best and worst game shows from the year that was.

Dec 29, 20201 hrEp. 20

Family Feud

Survey says... the holidays are all about family. This Christmas, between battling with in-laws, listen to us break down the history of Family Feud. Show me a double entendre!

Dec 22, 20201 hr 14 minEp. 19

I’ve Got A Secret

Unsurprisingly, this is a game show all about secrets: from the wild ones to the mundane. And trust us, there's a lot of mundane. Travel with us back to the 1950s, where smoking was cool, integration was not, and I've Got A Secret was all the rage.

Dec 15, 202059 minEp. 18

Legends of the Hidden Temple

This week we make our way across the moat, travel down the steps of knowledge, and battle past temple guards to get our hands on some little trinket a talking rock told us about. Hear all about the 90s Nickelodeon classic Legends of the Hidden Temple.

Dec 08, 20201 hr 13 minEp. 17
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android