Support for this show comes from Smartsheet. Have you ever wondered about all the little steps it takes to launch a rocket ship or maybe get a race car around a track or perform a life-changing surgery? These are feats of human ingenuity and they're executed by many people taking many steps that lead up to one big goal, making the impossible possible.
If you're organizing a team, scaling a business, or sending a roper across the solar system, Smartsheet is the work management platform that helps all those details turn into one big leap. Smartsheet, the place where work flows. Learn more at smartsheet.com. Join 167,000 companies like Paul Smith, Castor, MixTiles, who choose Klaviyo for better customer relationships and faster growth. Grow with Klaviyo B2C CRM at klaviyo.com forward slash UK.
This is Channels with Peter Kofka, and we're live from the Vox Media podcast stage at South by Southwest, presented by Smartsheet. I'm here with the Twitch CEO, Dan Clancy. Welcome, Dan. And I'll use my radio voice. Thank you, Peter. It's great being here. It's really super. Do you have people walking around applauding you all day long? No, no. And it's bright, so I can't see who's there. How much do you pay them? Well, it is expensive, you know. All right.
I was going to ask who's a Twitch user in this room, but I know some of them work for you. Who doesn't work for Dan and uses Twitch? No, most don't work. There's only two people who work for me here. All right, we're going to start really slow, Dan. I have an idea who a Twitch user is and who a Twitch creator is, but maybe I'm wrong. So you tell me, who is sort of the archetype?
What's the demographic of a Twitch user and a Twitch creator? I know you're going to tell me it encompasses everyone. Yeah, yeah, yeah. What's your core user, your core creator? Well, it's interesting. I mean, Twitch, of course, started with gaming.
Okay, and in fact when it you know broke off from Justin TV to which originally Justin TV was a general live streaming platform with the idea of i'll just videotape my life yes they were they were a little ahead of their time they were they were it was like oh this would be cool it got some traction but it was still niche and then when they broke off
For gaming, suddenly Twitch took off. Interestingly, when they started Twitch, they forbid you from spending more than like 15 or 30 minutes not gaming. And if you didn't game you would be you know you'd violate our rules just so we're super clear for anyone who hasn't dove into twitch
When you say gaming, it's literally watching people play video games while they interact with the audience. Yes, and let me get to that. I think the biggest thing, in fact, I always start from thinking of the viewers and why are they doing this. And so I'm not a gamer.
which is one thing that helps me in my role because actually sometimes when I'm talking to someone who doesn't know Twitch, I'm talking to myself five years ago. Okay. And the, why do you want someone to play the video game is like the most common question. Of course, nobody asks the question, why do you watch?
someone play football especially when they have never played football in their life right at least these people game regularly I think it's actually kind of the same thing that in fact the same reason we have fascination with sports is people are looking for community. Like, you know, you're a Bears fan, I'm a Bears fan. And that's why we have that fascination. But when I'm watching the Vikings at home, I'm not in a community, I'm just...
You're watching the Vikings. I'm cursing them. But that emotional connection you have with the Vikings is in part because you feel part of the... everyone who likes the Vikings it's not like because you're so into the nuances of football you get into it right and on Twitch what it was is people would well
The video game, somebody playing a video game, who liked video games, but really what it was, was the streamer and the fact that they were letting him into their living room and they would build a connection with the streamer and then with the other people watching.
Okay. And so the way I often describe it is you just want to hang out for a while and you turn on Twitch and you see this person that's entertaining. Does it make more sense if we just call it talk radio, but with video? Ah, here's the difference. If you go back in time with talk radio, people would be calling in questions. But they weren't interacting with each other, what I'll call horizontal interaction. And so it's like talk radio, but now all those people that are sitting and listening.
can be chatting with each other and talking back and forth, so you feel a connection to the other people watching. So you've explained the basic concept of Twitch, which is great. I asked you who the average Twitch user is, and my perception is the creator is a young person. performing for an even younger group of people.
I wouldn't say an even younger group. The interesting thing is it's really aged up where, you know, if you go back in time, it probably was a bit younger, but there's a ton of 25 to 35 or even 40 year olds now. Do you have an average age you want to give me? I don't have one off the top of my head, but it's. in the probably upper twenties or something like that. It's not.
You know, it's not like super young. So the idea that this is the same thing as watching people do professional sports or talk radio, I get that intellectually when I go to watch Twitch or I'm not a Twitch user, but when I see something.
I'm just baffled by it. I get what's happening. There's a person playing a game and sometimes doing something else. They are talking while they're doing it. Their audience is interacting with them. There's this stream of commentary that goes too fast for anyone to... understand what's happening the the streamer is then interacting with that commentary it kind of feels like if i watched it for too long i would get an aneurysm is there am i just too old to
sort of process what's going on is this something where you just sort of need certain fast twitch reflexes to understand i think what it is is when you do it you're watching on the biggest channels because those are ones you've heard of right and on a big channel it is the fact that Chat flies by.
The magic of Twitch is on the channels of like, you know, there'll be somewhere between 200 and 1 or 2,000 or 3,000 people watching, 4,000. And chat doesn't fly by as fast then. Then you can really see chat. You recognize names. and the other thing is you're closer to being on a message board it's it's yes and also you're dropping in once okay part of it is you come again again and again and the analogy i often use now i'm playing to my own generation
is back to the TV show Cheers. I'm familiar. Where everyone knows your name and you show up in a chat room that you go regularly and everybody screams out your name if you haven't been there for a while and says, Norm, where you been? Yep. right and you feel like you belong and that they're happy to see you one of your biggest uh streamers hassan peiker someone i'm familiar with i've interviewed him
He's got a caustic edge to him. He was recently suspended on Twitch. He was making a point about health care. He was sort of extending a metaphor that involved killing Rick Scott, the U.S. senator. He wasn't calling on people to kill Rick Scott. But he's making a metaphor. He was suspended. Apparently, he's been suspended multiple times.
First of all, how does that work? How do you get suspended at Twitch? Do you get involved when it's a high profile person? Is this automated? How does that work? And how do you get reinstated? Yeah. So first of all, they're indefinite. I'm not indefinite. For a given period of time, they're not indefinite.
It's sort of a timeout. It's a timeout. It's a timeout. So think of it like that, right? And all it is is try to make sure people stay within the guardrails, right? And so the idea, of course, is, you know, look, if someone goes outside the guardrail to level, give them a little bit of timeout.
So then it's like, okay, I'm going to work hard to stay within the community guidelines. And we have a team that does that. It's not automated. I'll be aware of their decisions for certain high profiles, but it's not my decision because the whole point is to keep some... degree of separation right where they're trying to make what is a consistent decision on the platform it's a it seems like it's an ongoing theme for your big many of your big name folks that they constantly are sort of
constantly but often are pushing the limits getting in trouble getting booted getting reinstated and then there also seems to be sometimes a question of did this did the streamer say something was it one of his fans saying something was it someone off camera saying Does this stuff get contentious within Twitch when you need to figure out who's actually responsible and what they did wrong? It's work, but I wouldn't call it contentious. The way I describe it is on...
On a VOD platform, like a YouTube platform, of course, you can edit something. You can take something down. It's hard to sit there and talk for six hours straight. Right, and that's the other thing I said. It's not an hour-long show. It's six to eight hours. And so to make sure you don't step over the line. And so it is the fact that sometimes people step over the line and you can't just edit it out.
as you would on a VOD platform. So I don't think it's contentious. It's just tricky for both them and for us to make sure it's like, look, we want to keep it within the guidelines. You can't edit it out.
So we have to see when somebody steps over the line and then do something to make sure they're very conscious so they don't step over the line consistently. Even before last fall's election, we were seeing... tech platform sort of rethinking moderation and and sort of the rules they wanted around stuff and they were moving away from moderation in some cases elon x twitter
sort of led the way on that but you're seeing other platforms follow and now there's sort of it seems like there's additional political pressure for platforms media companies lots of people to sort of rethink what rules they have about moderation how's that coming to affect twitch so we're lucky in that we did not we were we were not overly aggressive previously i think sometimes you have especially with misinformation and other things you had this where people
you know move the line and we had always kind of consistently said listen you should be free to you know say what you want it's how you say it you can't be spewing hate you can't be you know threatening violence but you could say i want to take ivermectin to deal with my covet and we did yeah correct if somebody if somebody said that on twitch we did have a policy that if someone is consistently in the sole purpose
to be there. And the sole purpose of the channel is to spread misinformation. But that doesn't really happen on Twitch. We don't have the viral spreading of information. In fact, more often than not, what people say on Twitch is a manifestation of what they hear. through the other platforms. So someone might say, oh, I read a Facebook post the other day that said this. So you've always been sort of looser than some of the other platforms.
And it doesn't seem like the Jim Jordans of the world are going after you and subpoenaing you and asking you to explain why you censored so-and-so and not. Is that because... Again, because it's just literally a different platform, or is it because they don't even know what Twitch is? No, I think it's because we have not been getting into that space. We, in general, have not waded into censoring.
um people people talk about twitter as a town square twitter's not really a town square because it's someone that it just spreads all over the place in a town square either you're in the town square or you're not okay and on a twitch channel
Either you're watching the channel live or you're not. If someone doesn't want to watch the channel, don't watch it. It doesn't algorithmically suddenly appear in their feed and any of that. You show up, you watch a channel. If you don't want someone watching your channel... you can ban them and stop them from watching your channel. So you don't feel like you've had to sort of recalibrate anything sort of since last fall? Correct. I mean, we're always making what I'll call...
micro adjustments, but what you've seen in the market are more macro adjustments and we have not had to make a macro. Are there people who intentionally try to get banned because it generates more attention? I don't think they intentionally, I mean, it affects their livelihood, right? It is fair that they get a little bit of attention, but...
In general, no. I was watching Hasan Piker's YouTube video about his banning, and then I saw a video afterwards. That was the most attention I've ever gotten on YouTube. I had a million views for that video where I was explaining what happened and apologizing, but not really.
apologizing yeah the interesting thing is whenever there's something controversial or something like that on twitch far more people watch it on the youtube video and then they say i can't believe this happened and it's like well
It's been on YouTube. You're not complaining about it being on YouTube and you're watching all this on YouTube. Yeah, I was going to get to this later, but let's talk about it now. So often when I encounter Twitch, it is off platform. It's a YouTube clip. Increasingly, I'm seeing clips on TikTok.
Sometimes they are from the creator's account. Oftentimes they're sort of been hijacked by somebody else. And it seems to me that one that sort of makes sense and that creators are actively saying we want our stuff to.
live lots of other places. We can't just be on Twitch, but it also seems to underscore your competitive challenges which there's a million places to consume video period and also live video right for a long time twitch was literally the only place to watch live streaming all the other platforms have some version of it now so how do you think about the sort of competitive set for live in general and and then and whether or not you want to pull back from that or lean into it
Yeah, I think the mistake that people often make is they look at the medium they use and not the need they're serving in a user. So by that, you're a journalist. You write, okay, or you used to. Now you talk. I still do some writing. Thank you. Businessinsider.com. But people don't confuse someone who writes a blog with a novel. You're using the written word as your medium of communication. So live streaming is your medium of communication, okay? Twitch, I use the phrase community.
community-centered live. Because on Twitch, people pull up a chair and stay for a while. On the other platforms, they have live, but you watch for a little while and then you swipe. And then you swipe because you're programmed not to stay for a little while. Everyone here... is kind of stuck watching this show because they walked into here they're happy to be here and if well if we get boring for a little while
They may walk out, but most people will stay until we get interesting again. Please don't leave. Okay? Because they don't have related talks that they can just click and hyperlink to another talk and hyperlink to another talk. So on all these other platforms, they can actually...
jump from one talk to another talk to another talk. And they encourage that, right? If you're on TikTok, what doesn't want you staying there all day? Not only encourage it when you're watching Avod, they program you to do that. So they program you after you're sitting for a while, something's wrong. I've been in here for 10 minutes. Let me just check another one.
right whereas on twitch it the whole site is designed for live so what i've said is the difference between twitch and all so many of these other platforms is our focus is on building a live community-centered experience and everyone that has used the other platforms. We've had a bunch that YouTube signed big contracts. They went over there. Pretty much every single one that signed a big contract to YouTube, once their contract was over and they weren't being
disproportionately paid, they came back to Twitch and they all consistently said, it's because we missed the community. And that is what's so magical. We'll be right back with Dan Clancy, but first a word from a sponsor. Support for this show comes from Smartsheet. You know that frustrating feeling that comes when you're really in the flow of a work thing and then all of a sudden you hear that little ping from a message and you switch your screen.
And you open a new application. And you check the message. And you check the link in the message. And that opened a new application. And yeah, your flow is gone now. You are definitely not alone here. On average. toggling between tasks and applications adds up to about 9% of time spent working each year. That is five whole work weeks. That's what Harvard Business Review calls the toggling tax.
And it increases stress hormones, decreases focus, and makes it impossible to tap into a state of flow. That is where Smartsheet comes in. Smartsheet is the work management software where workflows, where you and your team can plan, track, and deliver their best work. without toggling back and forth imagine what you could do with those extra five work weeks if all your work happened all in one place smartsheet the place where work flows
Visit smartsheet.com slash vox today to learn more. It's been reported that one in four people experience sensory sensitivities. making everyday experiences like a trip to the dentist especially difficult. In fact, 26% of sensory-sensitive individuals avoid dental visits entirely. In Sensory Overload, a new documentary produced as part of Sensodyne's sensory inclusion initiative, we follow individuals navigating a world not built for them.
where bright lights, loud sounds, and unexpected touches can turn routine moments into overwhelming challenges. Burnett Grant, for example, has spent their life masking discomfort in workplaces that don't accommodate neurodivergence. I've only had two full-time jobs where I felt safe, they share. This is why they're advocating for change.
Through deeply personal stories like Burnett's, sensory overload highlights the urgent need for spaces, dental offices, and beyond that embrace sensory inclusion. because true inclusion requires action with environments where everyone feels safe. Watch Sensory Overload now streaming on Hulu. And we're back.
There was that period in the pandemic where a lot of people discovered Twitch and or a lot of people spent a lot more time on Twitch for all the same reasons people spend a lot of time on other digital services. during the pandemic. And then there was this rush from YouTube, Microsoft, Facebook. We want to basically build our own Twitch. We're offering huge contracts to some of the biggest Twitch streamers, paid them giant, giant deals.
and they basically have all sort of retreated from that business they've all said they've all realized they're still doing live yeah they realize it's it's not something where it makes money to lose money on this their hope was i'll lose money on this creator but i'll all these users will come. And when that creator left Twitch, there was another creator ready to step up and become
the next big thing on Twitch. Kai Sinat, who's the biggest streamer on Twitch now, you know, sort of other folks leave and that Kai Sinat or Jinxy or these other folks, they fill that void. Okay. And so, yeah, they said, no, this doesn't work.
we're not really you know pulling from twitch so why do we want to keep losing money on these deals so from the outside i look i look at your competitor competitors popping up deep pockets and then walking away and you can either say well that just proves that twitch is the best version of this platform they can never compete or you go
maybe they decided this is just business is not worth it for them and they can get a better return doing something else that that ones would be more alarming for I wouldn't this is what I'd say I mean It's absolutely the case that the VOD business like TikTok and YouTube is a great business. That's because... you watch that when you have five minutes between here five minutes there and you add up the five minutes you get stuff so it's a great business i mean it's bigger than our business okay
Their thought was, oh, well, this will be on top of our business. And they still all have live. It's not like they pulled back from live. They just realized, oh, we're not going to sign these big contracts. And they were paying these people much more than what. they were organic tens of millions so they haven't pulled back from live they've pulled back from signing money losing deals and then when you pull back from that artificial injection of capital twitch because it focuses on live
They go, no, I'd rather be on Twitch in that case. You put out this, you do an annual letter this year. You said we're going to make it much easier for more people, more creators to make money. We're going to sort of lower the thresholds you need.
stream for a certain number of hours have a certain number of concurrent users whatever whatever it is we're going to make it easier to make money from for more people for twitch um youtube 2018 or so sort of went the opposite direction and they said it's gonna be much harder to monetize on YouTube I think part of that was they wanted to get some content sort of off off their platform or not be giving the money but also
I think they thought, and it seems like it was true, that they would actually make more money if fewer people were participating. But the pie would increase overall. How are you thinking about sort of going the other way? So YouTube is a different business. YouTube is predominantly an ad business. Okay. So they're kind of choosing how they distribute, ultimately how much ad.
they get is how many ads they can sell and they're figuring out how to distribute to that ad money so I think part of what they were deciding was they want to distribute the ad money that they're getting a little higher up the chain okay in terms of the creators for us
About two-thirds of our money comes direct from our viewers in terms of what we call subscriptions. It's different than a YouTube subscription. We can talk about that. Patronage, gifting, things like that. Someone's saying, I like what you're doing. Here's some money. Yes. Okay. So...
Smaller creators are not competing with bigger creators for the limited number of ads. And so what it does is you have someone who says, I want to... play around with this idea of live we want to make it so that when they get an audience more quickly can they start getting support from that audience the patronage the emotes everything that comes we want to make it that it becomes much quicker for you to just
it's working right away twitch has been around for a while amazon has owned it for more than a decade why make that decision this year what does that tell us about twitch i don't think it tells you anything about right now sometimes these things we could have done three years ago but we're doing other stuff and we just didn't like say you know oh let's do it now early on one of the reasons we needed to do it was fraud is always something we have to watch out for and when you
let people make money quick more quickly then it opens doors for fraudsters we've gotten better and better at what's a what's a fraudulent live streamer look like They're moving money around without a big audience a lot of times. They create fraudulent viewers and fraudulent other things, right? The whole thing, it's not somebody building a community. It's just somebody figuring out a way to exploit our platform, which can happen. And we've gotten really good at detecting people.
that are finding ways to do that, lots of technology. So we now feel like we have the ability to let people monetize right away and we can control. those threats because we have lots of ability to do that now pause for a second uh dan and i are going to talk for a while uh another 15 20 minutes and then if you guys have questions we're going to allow you to ask questions i think there's microphones somewhere around here so think about great questions and we'll come back
because you'll ask better questions than I will. There was a period, I don't know, seven-ish years ago where... Twitch was on the radar of media companies. I remember the NBA was saying they thought that the way that they would be producing broadcasts in the future would be sort of a Twitch-like broadcast. They had demos, so it was a basketball game going on with all the sort of Twitch.
stuff on the side it doesn't look like that ever took off is that the media company saying actually we're not really ready for a twitch like experience is that the audience saying we're not ready for that is how does twitch feel about that it's I think it's people misunderstanding what is so special about Twitch. So let's take music. Okay, which actually there's a ton of musicians on Twitch.
okay but sometimes you had this idea of oh i know we'll put music on twitch we're going to film the concert okay and so you take one concert and you film it okay the Creator isn't interacting with the community online, okay? It's not distinctly different than what you can watch in a VOD, right? And it happens once, so the people are not building community amongst themselves.
The musicians that use Twitch, they often use Twitch with more to engage with their audience and community and doing whatever they do in their free time. the poster child example is t-pain who's a big musician who streams on twitch all the time i'll like chat with him and hang out with him on twitch and he games on twitch he does his sound recording on twitch he like once i would i you know, I was streaming and I kind of knocked on his door and we started streaming together and he just said,
oh last night i finished my new music video i'm putting out let me premiere it right here and you know there was his new music video and he just played it and so the point is it's not about taking traditional music media and sticking it with chat next to it. That doesn't create community. That is just traditional premium media with people chatting alongside, which they already do on Twitter.
you know, the NBA's of the world misunderstanding Twitch or was that Twitch trying to sort of move beyond gaming and and figure out other ways this could work and then realizing it didn't work? No, I think so. Moving beyond gaming works, I think. how much of it was Twitch versus the NBAs and everyone, I think what often happens when you have two things, your first instinct is, well, let's just do this but here, okay? And that wasn't...
What was magical? Okay. Let's make Fortnite, but then add it in a different adjective. Well, so I'll use a concrete example. You know, let's take sports. OK, the thing that's been working a lot in particular in Europe and Latin America is you now have a lot of folks that build communities around teams that then have actually sports talk radio talking about it, which isn't just.
having the sports it's all of the shoulder content and then there's a group called it's called Kings League and it's a soccer league and they basically created it all for live interactive viewing on Twitch. And what they do is they have a set of players that get drafted. They're not the best of the best, but they're good players. And then they add in two or three named players that are retired. And then they've spiced up the game some. And then each team is owned by a creator.
It's been a huge success because they get the audience and the people watching involved. They're actually watching a basically minor league soccer game. You're basically watching a minor league soccer game, but it's designed for kind of interactive entertainment when they do their draft.
OK, they like they draft players and then you're able to steal players and you have money. They almost like gamified it. So you don't think that would work if you just said, look, let's take the biggest teams in the world, Liverpool or Man United or whoever, and let's overlay. There is a community. There's huge communities around these things. You don't think that would work? I think what would work is you have somebody who is, if you take one of the big, it's not one community on Liverpool.
It's probably 15 communities. It's 20 communities. It's 30 communities, right? You know, or if you take... Let's take U.S. sports, because in the U.S., you know, in other words, you certainly can have a group of avid fill-in-the-banks, you know, Saints fans or Bears fans or Eagles fans or something like that. But you need to capture that. And it's probably not just one community.
There are lots of sports bars in Philadelphia that are watching the Eagles, and each of those bars are a little different. So it's not one, it's multiple communities of personalities that then... gather people around to watch so as you know in part because you worked at youtube but also because you know what's going on in the world when you go to basically any other platform there's an algorithmic
discovery where the platform is giving you stuff that it thinks you want to watch and or that it wants you to watch. It doesn't really exist on Twitch. How do I find the thing that I want on Twitch and why don't you more aggressively? push stuff towards me so interestingly we do have all those algorithms too sure okay and when you go we have those algorithms now on the mobile app we have a feed the difference is this okay
When you're watching, when you have a 45-second clip that they pushed you, if you don't like it, swipe away. You don't like it, swipe away. Because the unit of consumption is small, okay? Finding a channel you like on Twitch. I liken it to finding a friend. It takes a while to figure out you like someone as a friend. And the analogy I use is, suppose you have two people who don't know each other.
And then you say, you two should get together sometime. But you don't do anything with them. The odds that they get together, that's like a homepage. Someone walks out of this room and says, oh, I heard about Hassan Piker or Kai Sinat. I'm going to watch them. Right. So they may go and watch, but they're probably going to need to get exposed to him on YouTube and these other short form video. Most of our viewers have...
build affinity for someone. They get exposed to them on other platforms. So is that how people are finding their favorite Twitch people is outside of Twitch? They often, that one of the things, do you know how you said competition with short form? Short form isn't our competition. One of our big...
focuses this year is making it easier for our creators to find the cool stuff happening you know and get it on every platform and so just like you will get you know little snippets on Instagram right of some conversation And then that's how you drive them to the whole podcast. Here, you get little snippets of this creator. You see it in your feed on YouTube or TikTok or Instagram. And then it's like, oh, let me check out. And then you want to go hang out there for a while.
i make podcasts i talk and i write um and increasingly it's very hard to get the big platforms to send people to my podcast to my websites where they can read my words and we've all sort of realized belatedly oh we really can't depend on the platforms to send traffic to help us acquire users it might work in some cases but we can't rely on it
that seems like a vulnerability for you guys too. Actually, we're almost like the opposite. Once you get an audience on Twitch, you keep it because they're there for you. The difference is on... Let's just take Spotify, right? Their affinity is with Spotify, and then your content happens to appear in their feed, but they're going to Spotify. When they come to Twitch, They're coming for the creators. Someone who goes to Twitch regularly will watch four to eight creators in a week.
because they're the creators they like. So then you can retain them better because we're not moving them to other people. So you're not worried about a scenario where Elon Musk decides that he wants to... have his own live streams and it's going to make it either harder for the kaisenats to be on his platform or more likely harder for him to send traffic and users not worried at all
not worried at all because obviously he's going to want the kai sanats to be posting short stuff and the kai sanats are going to say i want to be i mean kai's a perfect example where tons of folks were trying to get him come over here and he's like no like i want
i'm going to build my community kai is the star you know tick tock is the star on tick tock right kai is the star on twitch the creators are the star okay and when people are coming it's because they form a bond with that creator and they come back for that creator.
Prior to this interview, I was asking people who actually spend time on Twitch, and one thing I would hear repeatedly is it was sort of vibes-based, but it feels like Twitch's cultural moment has come and gone, that it's... regardless of what the actual numbers are, it seems like...
it seems like the live phenomenon is happening on other platforms more often. I know you're going to tell me that's not the case, but explain why people are misunderstanding that if that's the case. Yeah, I mean, first of all, I'll go back to in terms of, oh, it's seen.
It seems like the live phenomenon is hanging on other platforms. If that's the case, then all these Twitch streamers that left Twitch for YouTube wouldn't have come back. There was a period where I remember I said, you know what the one thing that top 10 live streamers all have on YouTube?
they all started on Twitch. Okay, and then got a deal and went over and then those 10 all came back. Right, but you don't want to be the farm leagues for YouTube. But they all come back. In other words, it's one thing if they go because that's where they want to stay. There was an artificial incentive. right and then they all came back okay it is the case that live as a medium of interaction is growing which is good for us our problem has never been we don't have enough of the market
Our problem is we want the market to be bigger. We want more people to understand the magic of live. I often say this, the best thing for Twitch is TikTok investing heavily in live. A couple years ago, you became, when did you become CEO? How long ago? Two-ish years ago. Two-ish years ago, you came on, then you had cuts, and you said, we're not making money. That's why we have to make the cuts. Again, Amazon bought Twitch for a billion dollars in 2014.
it's kind of shocking to hear that between amazon's resources and twitch's cultural cache that it couldn't be making that it wasn't making money a couple years ago is it making money now so i don't talk about where we're at now okay but it's not when you say it's shocking not that shocking uber didn't make money till i think last year yes but they were in a different business right and youtube but youtube was making money
Not right away. Oh, no. I was at YouTube 2010 to 2012. And at that point, we understood it. And I like... It was somewhere in the middle when YouTube finally decided to focus on that because before that they were investing. So for a long time, YouTube was not profitable. Okay. So I don't think it's that strange. However, I think the key difference is, and I don't think this is unique to Twitch. I think this is.
This is an issue in the tech space. In the tech space, there was this mindset of build your organization for where you're gonna be in three or four years. okay and i used to be at google they came out of google in part because google was lucky enough to have a money machine in the back of the house almost from the get-go from the get-go so youtube made google made money
like from the very beginning. And it was all... And not just money, like enormous. And it was all funded by this. So everyone else then is like, oh, grow, grow, grow. And you get a big team, get a big team. And to be honest, part of what happened to Twitch, they kind of fell into that at Amazon. on the twitch team when they first got there they were very scrappy and then people would come and say no no no that's not the game here
You have to argue for more resources. You have to argue for more resources, okay? And having been in big tech, that is the game. How do you argue for more resources as opposed to how do you figure out what is the number you need to like serve your...
audience in your community and so we're just like many other folks in tech we were just not running the business as well as we could have i'm going to open this up to the audience in a minute but i do want to ask you about your background we've mentioned it briefly you were at youtube Other parts of Google you started out at NASA. Can I say you were literally a rocket scientist? Oh, you can say it close I Was an AI guy. Yeah, you were next door. You said you're not a gamer Mm-hmm
don't really look like you're a core Twitch user. I look old. I'm just saying, I'm just saying we both don't look like the core Twitch user or creator. How did you end up running Twitch? I know that you were the COO and moved up, but how did you get to Twitch? So I had left next door and I was just taking some time, kids and whatnot. And it was interesting because Emmett reached out and Emmett was the CEO at the time, reached out and interviewed me and then he offered me the job and I said no.
Because? Because I said, you know, I'm not a gamer. And at that point, I thought Twitch was, oh, it's a gaming platform. That was what was in my mind. Okay. And I thought, oh, it's a gaming platform. Okay. Then like four months later, he came back and said, Dan, we really think you're the right person. And the timing was a little better. Again, I've been enjoying time with the kids and whatnot. So I said, yes. And the main reason.
was i hadn't had this revelation about twitch it was more i realized um the things that i've always enjoyed is working with people i like working with so i would always tell me myself a story about how i'm changing the world when i was at um google i did google book search and we're scanning all the world's books and i would weave
poetically about what a difference i was making in the world um at nasa would talk about search for life at youtube democratization i always had these great stories really i enjoyed it when i was working with people i liked And so I said, I like this team. Let me go work there. And what I realized when I got there finally was, oh, Twitch isn't about gaming at all. Twitch is about community. And of course, at Nextdoor is doing community.
And it's also about performance. And one thing you didn't mention, I was a theater major undergrad along with computer science. I did not mention your theater major, my apologies. And I realized there's this whole world I could have lived that was more about performance.
And what I realized is Twitch is this, somehow the universe found a way to weave this other half of my brain together with my tech and community, because what it brings together is my tech and business and all that with my community, with... kind of you know twitch is really interactive performance art live and so it's sort of this perfect synergy that i kind of lucked into we'll be right back with dan clancy but first a word from a sponsor
Support for this show comes from Smartsheet. Okay, be honest. How many times today did a DM or email send you on some wild goose chase when you should have been focusing on being productive? No matter how many times you were distracted today, You don't have to be embarrassed. It's okay. We all do it. But just because we all do it doesn't mean we have to all do it. Smartsheet knows how easy it is to get distracted.
They know how easily opening a new window to start a work task can turn into a series of rabbit holes, work-related and otherwise. And that's exactly why Smartsheet designed a seamless all-in-one platform that allows you to flow between tasks. Smartsheet customers know that Smartsheet is a distraction-free zone. Smartsheet is the place where work flows. Learn more at smartsheet.com slash vox.
And we're back. I have more questions, but I want to open it up to the audience. Do people have questions for Dan? Don't be shy. I think there is a microphone. Yes. Thank you. We can't see very well. Can you hear me? Hi, I'm Jane from a marketing agency in Dublin in Ireland. I was just wondering what advice you have for brands that are moving maybe from those more traditional spaces for live communications.
into Twitch? What is the big message for them? It's a great question. I feel like she's a plant, but she's not. I'm going to talk for one brief second about brands and what they're trying to achieve. Ultimately, in brand marketing, what you're trying to... build is emotional attachment to your brand so that when you see it you react and you feel good about the brand okay
Often you advertise and do things to try and get transference. You do it on the Oscars or a sporting event or whatever because someone's feeling good and they see your commercial so that emotional connection transfers. As I said, Twitch is all about emotional connection to the creator. Okay, and so what you're trying to do is find a way to create that transference Okay, and you have a lot more emotional the viewers of the twitch audience
are a lot more emotionally connected. The way I describe it is if there's a streamer you watch on Twitch and they don't stream for a week, you know it. If someone stops creating content on YouTube for a week, you have no idea. because there's always some other player there. So my high level thing is, and we do a lot of this, is trying to get brands to understand how to create some authentic engagement with the creators.
I also encourage a lot of brands to think about what content do they have that they might put somewhere, but then they want the creators engaging with it. Because the foundation is you want to see that connection where someone has an emotional connection to this creator and then your brand is kind of appearing in some way there. And then that...
turns into that emotional connection. If I'm a high profile Twitch star, can I do a direct brand deal myself and you guys don't participate in that? Absolutely. Absolutely. So, you know, all of our... you know all of our even big and even the interesting thing is we have a lot of torso creators that you know make a significant amount and
it's it's interesting when i tell the story of some of the torso creators which i'll do for a second because for a lot of people they just don't realize they think gaming okay but now like kai does game but most of his stuff is more lifestyle but you know i'll use just examples off the top of my head of these people that are funding their life there's a pizza princess g who runs a pizza shop and she almost looks like a disney princess
And what she does is run a pizza shop every day and chats with her community. There's a husband and wife that were science teachers at a university, and they then started streaming. talking about science there's a paleontologist and there's ads that are happening while they're doing this yep yep there's a paleontologist who goes on dinosaur digs and this is how he funds his life he used to be a university professor
And there are like 20 other examples that I could give you of these folks that are just doing like all sorts of things. But they build a community and they find these people, they find a connection there. And so some of what we do isn't just about... the big creators it's about how because that emotional connection is strongest often on those torso creators right and you just want to get 5 10 15 20 of them and that can be very effective
Yes. Hi, my name is Patrick O'Keefe and I'm the chief integrated marketing officer at Elf Beauty. We are a brand that's super active. Which uses Twitch. We do. Every week we stream with our amazing, she's a makeup art global makeup. artist my question is more so around how can brands start to monetize on the channel here would be my suggestion
There are various different ways like where Elf could start monetizing. And we're actually going to be doing some things so that you can capture buyers right at that point. okay but we probably as opposed to just on your channel because you only get a certain amount of viewership on your channel part of your whole point is everyone else engaging so one thing we're looking at is how to help brands
to get direct monetization on the platform. But to be honest, I think the biggest thing is building that emotional connection. And so you have to be careful about getting a few dollars here. When you can get a lot more dollars by you build that connection so that they're like emotionally buying Elf everywhere else. So I think a lot of what y'all are doing actually is the right type of thing.
Does live commerce, which we keep hearing about, it's going to be the next big thing, it's big in Asia, it seems like maybe it's catching on, but I'm not really sure it's catching on in the U.S. Is that interesting to you? Here's the thing that we've learned.
you know played around with that because everyone said oh it's big in Asia it's gonna be big here it's big in Asia it's gonna be big here and I've dug into this many times also while I was interesting even before I was at twitch at Google it turns out one reason it's big in Asia is they don't have as much trust in online retail as you do in America. And the people that are selling there are actually retailers.
and that you trust them to make sure the good gets to their house, okay, that it delivers and all that. And in the US, you don't have that problem. Everyone trusts buying things online. And so in general, people in the US are getting like affiliate fees. Whereas in general in Asia, they're getting retail margins.
because they actually are retailers. So I don't think it's going to be as big, you know, obviously YouTube, I mean, TikTok is investing a lot in shopping. Okay. And I think part of that is they're trying to make sure that that creators can find a way to make money directly from their platform, because most TikTok creators make their money from
you know, endorsements and stuff like that. Right. They're not, TikTok's not sharing meaningful revenue with them. TikTok doesn't, the revenue share for TikTok is zero, 100% for their normal stuff. But I don't think it, and they're obviously spending a ton on shopping. but I don't think it's going to be the same as Asian because of the way the margins work. I do think there are ways of getting it more situational, but it's not going to be like Asian. Gotcha. Question here.
Hey there. I'm Michael. I'm just a person. I'm a person too. What's the whole world? We're both here. When I look at larger companies... especially these types of platforms i have my meandering question i think it's really hard for many of these uh companies i i like from avoiding this like growth at all odds like i look at like etsy and it's really sad and the companies that have kind of remained focused on their i guess core values are tend to be outside of
the belly of the beast of amazon or big venture i think about like itch.io small gaming platform but it's just a guy um in the end so he doesn't have to make decisions that other people's want how do you protect the kind of the the heart of the company from not doing uh time on site or other you know yeah yeah how do you how do you keep so so first of all let me i want to say this that um
One of the things that happens sometimes, you know, growth itself creates problems because more people are enjoying this. And it's always nicer to have this cool little thing that just you in this small group like.
The way I always look, I think that's great, but I think live streaming and community experience is very impactful on people's lives. And so it's a good thing that more people are doing it because you're having a bigger impact. Now, as soon as you get bigger, you do have to... be very clear of where you came from that's one reason why i repeatedly say the creators of the foundation of twitch and it's live community-based streaming that it's not trying to be someone we're not okay
I will say one thing that happens is whenever you have to make some difficult decision, often our brain goes and explains that because they're big now or because they're owned by Amazon. Because that's the explanation that our brain gives us. And a lot of times, it may not be the reason.
Okay. It's just, you don't come up with that reason when the small company does something you don't like, you don't blame it on now they're getting big. So I do think it's something we have to be very clear about and very conscious about where did we come from and what is the foundation of Twitch?
And that's why I continually say we are a live community-centered streaming platform. The foundation of Twitch are our creators. That's where the emotional bond is. And then we just have to keep that as our North Star.
It's an inherent tension though, right? Like you are owned by a giant company. They spend a lot of money on you. They want you to make money. And you want the creators to help you do that, right? And so you do have, you've got different incentives you give them and you want them to spend.
six to eight hours streaming to have this much audience. How do you balance that with the tension with the fact that these are real people uh this is difficult work even though it's just sitting and talking it's a real strain for them how do you how do you balance sort of your just basic growth and profit imperatives with the fact that these are real people who are
both depending on you and working their ass off for you. Well, first of all, you mentioned one thing about depending on me and, you know, I spend a lot of time with creators for those who, you know, I, I might, when I became CEO, I started streaming myself and I still stream regularly where I. do stuff just to experience, and then I spend time with streamers. And one thing that I think a lot about is how much they depend upon us, because they need Twitch to be here 20 years from now.
You take someone like Coke Carnage, who was one of our biggest streamers back in the 2010s, and he's still a big streamer. He's got three kids, and this is his career. For any reason, and it's not like he can go to another platform and do what he does on Twitch. There are other live streaming platforms. It's not the same. We focus on live streaming. You know, his kids are still young.
He's planning on doing this for another 30 years. It's not like if something happens to us, he can't put it in his resume.
Oh, I'll now be an IT professional. He was an IT guy. And so we have an obligation to our creators to make sure we're here 10, 20, 30, 40 years from now. And I... take that very seriously now the interesting thing is um we're a platform that allows them to do what they feel is right for them and the good news is as like all ugc platforms All UGC platforms are built upon this idea that we're all creators.
It used to be, oh, the movie makers, but I'm not a creator. Everyone in this room is a creator. Everyone in this room has the ability to creatively express themselves. But most people are consuming, right? Most people are consuming, but interestingly, everyone can create. And as with any platform that depends upon the creative expression, there's always an excess supply of people who want to use it.
actors musicians artists every single one there are more people who want to be an actor that can be an actor there are more people who want to be a live streamer that can more people who want to be a youtuber so as a UGC platform the good news is There are a lot of people that want to use our platform. So then that makes you make a choice for yourself. Maybe you were streaming six to eight hours a day, four or five days when you were...
24 and then you're 30 and you have a kid and other things. And so now you want to do it two to three hours a day. Great. That works great for us. You're not going to demonetize them, say you had a deal, but you needed to be working for six hours? No, not at all. This was one of the problems. There was a period where we...
We gave these contracts with minimum guarantee and all that. And YouTube luckily actually for their core product stayed away from that, right? We have a rev share deal. You stream less, you get a rev share, you decide.
we get our rev share you get your rev share you figure out how that works in your life to make that choice and so no we're not going to put them pressure at all it's like youtube and we have a lot of streamers that end up the the thing that works so well about twitch is you can sustain an audience maybe you're not like the big you know at the top of the billboard
But you have a very loyal audience that still shows up. And the interesting thing, people used to think that, oh, well, it's going to age out. People don't age out of watching Twitch. Just like people don't often don't age out of their, you know, now when you ask about the age, there are a lot of 30 somethings that spend a lot of time watching Twitch. Let's hear it for the loyal audiences. We've got a few questions over here and then we'll let you get out.
Hi hi, I'm just I'm just a normal person um I
I kind of grew up on Twitch and I grew up on watching a lot of like really independent women, either gaming wise, talking about dropping knowledge, a lot of that kind of stuff. I feel like recently in the past few years and even on Hazan, piker has talked about where you know as much as you talk about the creators and supporting creators no matter what you're creating there is like this very big wave of unfortunately people who are very like explicit explicit kind
and they're not really getting much pushback from Twitch and like a lot of like content creators who like have been in it for a while have gotten like demonetized like are kicked off of Twitch like Hasan Piker. Or like sweet Anita who got banned off of Twitch because she has Tourette's and she accidentally said a slur because someone said it in the chat.
She has Tourette's so she can't control what she says sometimes because it happens. So like a lot of like those content creators who... do the right stuff and then they have that kind of pushback and they have to like redeem themselves for it but then you have a wave of people who do have very explicit content and it's very hard for like the women creators on twitch to really
be able to push back on those chatters who were pushing that onto them to do that same content. So how do you see Twitch dealing with the new wave of things and how to protect the... I guess the old content creators who are really just there trying to do what they want to do and not be pushed in the corner of like well there's this new wave of like this explicit content coming out to Twitch of people
Doing that kind of stuff. How do you... So you've touched on a bunch of... different issues let me quickly mention just so like sweet Anita who's someone I did a stream with interestingly I didn't know she had Tourette's when I was doing the stream with her and then we talked about it and that was something that those things will happen where somebody doesn't understand something and she she was
reinstated when that happened so you know that's the nature of this sometimes somebody does something and you reinstate them and you know it's interesting you talk about a new wave i mean this is this is a challenge in the online world And one thing that we're very clear on, because the interesting thing is different women will express themselves in different ways in choosing and engaging with their audience and their community.
And the big thing is you want to make sure they don't feel like they need to do that. And one thing, knowing a lot of women streamers that do not do anything like that, a lot of them are in Austin. I think actually they're doing, you know. They're doing great. And we have a lot of policies to make it so that if you're getting pressure or anything like that, then you can control your community. So it's something we have to stay very conscious of. And this is the nature of the online world.
I think women creators have to deal with this in the online world, and I'm very conscious of the challenges that women experience. Do you think that's more challenging on a platform that's gaming-centric? I think if you go in the past... I think that was more of a challenge. It's not more acute on Twitch than on other platforms. I think this challenge that women can be harassed and, you know.
you know, people coming after them and giving them a hard time. I think unfortunately... Definitely exists everywhere. It exists everywhere. I don't think it's actually more pronounced. I do think with live, right, it's a little more... you know it's it's a little more in their face and that's one reason why we have a lot of tools that allow people to decide who can watch them
Right. Because that way, if someone, if you don't want this person watching him, you can stop them from watching you. And now, even if you ban them, they can't even watch you. Two more questions quickly. i'll be very quick hi i'm chelsea i'm a creator on twitch and one of those women streamers i refer to in austin thank you appreciate what y'all do for safety but i wanted to ask because it's a vested interest for me what is twitch's success metric for this year
since you discussed opening the market and making it bigger for us. Yeah, this is what I'd say, as opposed to the success metric, and Chelsea, I know well, brings up this interesting... uh what i'll call point that i'll turn into this tension that we have we of course we have metrics about trying to grow we want to make it easier for creators to make more money um from the audiences they have
As you know, we do a lot on collaboration and other things. The thing that I always, it's always a challenge as a leader is in a big company, so often you're focused on metrics around growth. Get bigger, get bigger, get bigger.
so often that causes you to lose focus on the magic that is happening every day for people that are showing up right so if you're one percent smaller that means 99 of what was happening yesterday is still happening okay and so i guess what i'd say is one of the things that i and it's a good example is you take a creator that happens for every single one of our creators they get caught up in growing
But then it's so easy to forget about those people that are showing up every day, provide the foundation. And so for me, I always try to be careful of not getting obsessed with a growth metric. because all sorts of stuff we want to do.
But in the end, we have this responsibility of serving those community members and those creators that show up every day and fund their lives. But you can't tell Andy Jassy. I'm not so obsessed with growth metrics, Andy. Of course. We have all sorts of metrics that we have with Andy.
in terms of that. But as we talk about me talking to the creators and that sort of thing, part of this is anyone who's created, they realize there's this challenge because we are programmed to get caught up in numbers. I'm a streamer. I don't make any of my money from Twitch. I donate all the money from Twitch. Obviously, I don't make a lot, but I'll still stream. And afterwards, I go and open my email that tells me what my average concurrent viewers were, which is a metric. And I'm small.
Mine's like 200 or something like that. And I feel better if it's 250 or 300 than if it's 200. Even though I run to it, but emotionally I'm like, oh. Okay, and we are programmed to kind of look at numbers and of course all sorts of apps Program you to get obsessed with numbers and often in a way that is psychologically harmful So I guess one of the things that I say is twitch is about community
Don't get too obsessed with just looking at a number where you feel good if it's up a little bit and you feel bad if it's down a little bit when you are ignoring all the magic. That sounds like very good advice that's impossible to take. We will leave it to this person for the last question. Hi, Aaron from Hungary, a creative technologist.
Totally different topic. You got these ultra long form contents with full of information, time coded user commands. It seems like a goldmine for machine learning. Do you have anything in mind regarding this? ready to take it monetized it started sold it for you for example open to research or something like this
Is Twitch going to be an AI engine? Yeah, so it's actually, I'm going to use this to talk about the whole question of AI because I think, isn't there something in the contract that we have to talk about AI otherwise? We'll both be kicked out. Also, you literally have worked at AI. We'll be watched out. So I'll use this. Yes, there's lots of text.
So I think that what's really interesting is so much about AI now is focused on what I'll call the facts and the higher level reasoning. But the thing that makes us uniquely human is, of course, the emotional connection.
that we establish with each other and I do think it's very interesting the ability for a streamer or creator to extend that emotional connection by using AI either when they're not there or by making it a little more intimate and personal okay so you know suppose let's assume ai now
Some of y'all may have questions that you can't ask, but let's assume AI was good enough that afterwards you could pop up your phone and ask that question that you're a little embarrassed to come up and ask. But I wouldn't have minded asking Dan this question. And then the AI can give you your question and you your question and you your question.
And I think this is more going to a part of AI that is the biggest challenge, which is this idea of emotional connection and having conversation, not just about facts and information, though. But is the data that is generated by Twitch, is that useful for an LLM? So there's so much. Is it useful for an LLM? Sure, it's useful for an LLM. But now I think what everyone... Is Amazon using that for their stuff?
Like right now, Amazon doesn't talk about what it's used, but let's just say it's not a big deal, right? You know, we see... We used to think that there was these, oh, you've got this unique data. And then every day there's a new foundation model come up that's the new hip thing that didn't have this data that no one had. DeepSeat didn't have, oh, this data that no one had.
is now out there. There's tons of data out there. Yes, it's interesting. I find it much more interesting to think about how streamers and creators will use AI as a sort of extension of themselves.
Okay. We're going to leave it there. We talked about AI, so we fulfilled our contractual obligation. Check that off. Thanks to you guys for showing up. If you are not channel subscribers, please subscribe. I think there'll be a QR code if you can't figure out how to subscribe to a podcast, but I bet you can. Thank you for coming. Dan, thank you for your time. Thanks for having me.
Thank you to Smartsheet for supporting this episode. Whether your team is scheduling complex surgeries, getting a race car to the finish line, or sending rovers to distant planets, they need a single place to allow their work to flow. And that place is Smartsheet. No matter what seemingly impossible task you're working on, Smartsheet is the work management platform built to make it all possible.
Whether your work happens in the operation room, on the racetrack, or out on the very edges of our galaxy, Smartsheet is the place where the improbable becomes possible. Ready to learn more? Visit smartsheet.com slash vox. Smartsheet, the place where work flows. Meet Klaviyo, the only CRM built for B2C. Join 167,000 companies like Paul Smith, Castor, MixTiles, who choose Klaviyo for better customer relationships and faster growth. Grow with Klaviyo B2C CRM at klaviyo.com forward slash UK.