Case of the Creeps: A Truly Creepy Podcast - podcast cover

Case of the Creeps: A Truly Creepy Podcast

Case of the Creepspodcasters.spotify.com
Join your Creepy Hosts, Katie & Mama Jerri twice a month for their take on all things that give us the creeps. From killers, cryptids and unexplained cases, if it's creepy - they're on the CASE. See what we did there?
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Episode 49: Frolic Away in Elephant Bootay | Toy Box Killer pt 1

Grab your buckles and comfort pillows Creeps! We have finally come to the debut of our heaviest case we've covered in our podcast history. David Parker Ray was born and bred in the environment of evil and became a product of it. He is responsible for the murder of anywhere from 40-60 women during his 40 years of active killing. But if that wasn't enough, he also made history with his...Toy Box and House of Horrors where he would kidnap women and keep them as his personal torture slaves. On this ...

Dec 15, 20231 hr 6 min

Episode 48: The Math Ain't Mathin' | Harold Shipman pt. 2

Its the conclusion of Dr Death Creeps! Harold Shipman was one of the most prolific serial killers, who was active for over 20 years, and made sure he was covering his tracks in his most professional manner. That was, until he got cocky and was the product of his own demise. The ladies buttoned this up with the details of his empire crumbling and pay tribute to just some* of the 200+ victims of this Dr and his deadly diagnosis, leaving us all with a clean bill of health, and creeps.

Dec 01, 20231 hr 6 min

Episode 47: Someone Call OSHA | Wizard of Oz *UNEDIT BONUS*

Oh boy! Y'all better watch out, because the Chaos train is coming in hot with a whole load of tangents and cackles. Welcome to the Bonus episode! The girls got together and decided to step out of the wheel house on this one and did a light coverage on The Wizard of Oz and the maddening events that took place during filming. To make it even better....its unedited. Grab your makeup brushes and fire extinguishers....maybe even some febreze; Because this one painted on the fire that stunk....you'll ...

Nov 11, 202346 min

Episode 46 : Here Comes Primmy | Harold Shipman pt. 1

The girls are BACK, and starting off the new way of things with a deadly DOSE of creeps for you listeners. On this episode Katie and Jerri dug deep into the life of Harold Shipman. On the outside, he was the well know and loved family practitioner - while on the inside had an unhealthy goal to make his patients perish by his hands. On part one, the girls broke down his childhood and a lot of the red flags that led to our Dr Death being born, leaving us all with a replenishing dose, of the creeps...

Oct 29, 202357 min

Here's What's Happening - Friday the 13th

Well hey Creepy Crawlers. We've been quiet for a few and it's time you know why. There have been some major updates happening over here for the platform both behind the scenes and for you listeners. On this episode, we're bringing everything up for you all and then closing out the episode with some fun facts for our spooky holiday, Friday the 13th, that may even have you counting how many letters you have in your name. When one case closes, another opens and with that - we all have a new case, o...

Oct 13, 202324 min

Episode 45: Mothman Is A Gentle Lover | Mothman

BEWARE OF THE BRIDGE!!!! And 9/11, but mostly the bridge. Strap in Creeps! Katie and Nate are diving into the cryptozoological marvel of West Virginia, the Mothman. With glowing red eyes, giant wings and a DUMP TRUCK of an ass, this fluffy winged man left absolutely no crumbs on his terror in the 1960s. So get ready creeps as our hosts get into the nitty gritty of it with the usual witch cackles from Katie and absurdity spewing from Nate; this episode is sure to leave us all with a lurking case,...

Aug 23, 202351 min

Episode 44: Please Don't Cancel Us | Aleister Crowley FINAL PART

Can we all give a collective scream in Sherpa that ITS FINALLY HERE?!?! AAHAAHAHHHAAHAH! The Final part and wrap up of the elusive and magically abusive Crowley is finally here for your listening pleasure, Creeps. On this one, our hosts are just absolutely DONE with this man and the tales of woe his life beheld. We got the details on the closing and final act of Cooky Crowley and the shenanigans this man got into before inevitably passing away from his bad habits catching up with him. PLUS as us...

Aug 15, 202359 min

Reddit Reads: Dinner Plate Nipples

When in doubt, pull a reddit reads out! After the plague infected our team to the highest extent - we needed a good laugh. And as always, Reddit NEVER disappoints us. Starting right off the bat with a succubus demon and then ending with a harrowing shadow man story. We got laughs, chills and all sorts of thrills. Sure to leave us all with a stomach aching case, of the creeps.

Aug 01, 202357 min

Episode 43: Ride This Bull Aileeny Weeny | Aileen Wuornos

Sorry for the delay on this one Creeps! But alas, tis time! LETS GET READY FOR MURDER!!!! Finally creeps the episode you've all been waiting for, the dry handy giving, Marlboro red smoking, Milwaukees best drinking hooker of death, Aileen Wuronos! So strap in and get ready for dirty talk, because Katie and poppa bear are joined by a special guest on this one. While she hitchhiked her way through the eastern United States and left her mark on the Sunshine State - its also apparent Aileeny Weeny H...

Jul 26, 20231 hr 7 min

Episode 42: Money Talks, Babies Walk | Aleister Crowley pt. 2

Aahahhhahaahha! Do you guys hear that? It's the cries of sherpas. It's time for part two of Crazy Crowley Creeps. Join Katie and Nate for this part 2 of the wild and extravagantly embellished life of Aleister Crowley. From wizard battles to mountain climbing there's sure to be something for you in this episode. Plus, we have our first installment of our new mini segment with Creepy Miki and her Creepy Corner. There's unhinged laughter, bad name pronunciation and a whole butt load of Magickal mom...

Jul 11, 202359 min

Episode 41: Power Bottom | Aleister Crowley pt. 1

We're Back Creeps! After a small hiatus, we have RETURNED and with a whole new side of the creepy case. In this episode, we dive into a brief overview of "The Beast" himself Aleister Crowley. Going through his wild lifestyle while also diving into fits of absolute unhinged laughter. Prepare yourselves creeps. On this one there's a few facts, and a lot of side tracks. From the creation of his own religion, becoming a published poet, a mountaineer and hosting wizarding wars - Aleister was nothing ...

Jun 30, 202351 min

Episode 40: Gimme Me The Creamy Oysters | St Augustine Recap ONE YEAR ANNIVERSARY

Its been a whole YEAR of shenanigans creepy crawlers! We couldn't have done it without all you weirdos joining us as we continue to grow and learn with this podcast. So, as a THANK YOU we headed over to St Augustine and took over for the weekend. There was food, there was booze, a live that was beyond chaos AND A GHOST TOUR complete with boos and interviews! Thank you guys again for sticking with us and all our creepiness, we have the best followers that even give US a case, of the creeps....

May 30, 202351 min

Episode 39: Give Me The Poopy Walls | Katies Recap From W.V

Thank the Gods, Katie is back from WV! On this episode, Katie is taking us on a wild ride of retelling her accounts from visiting the very much haunted Tran Allegheny Lunatic Asylum in Weston, West Virginia. And if you weren't a believer of ghosts and paranormal before, we garuntee you will be by the end of this road trip. As Katie goes through the daytime paranormal tour she attended, we get to hear some of the very stories and claims of what happened behind the walls of the hospital taken over...

May 17, 20231 hr 2 min

Episode 38: Shark Whack A Mole | Florida Mayhem

Ah, Florida. The state where all bets are off and the news articles never disappoint. Papa Bear and Katie are pulling some of those whacky articles for your listening pleasure on this episode! We got shark whack a mole, space force base invasion and.....kid fight club? Like we said, Florida never disappoints. But we'll let you be the judge on this episode that sure to give you an unhinged case, of the creeps.

May 09, 202342 min

Episode 37: Ham and Eggs | Albert Fish

He's not beauty, definitely not grace...but he loves poopy in the face. He's The Floppy Fish himself, Albert Fish. On this episode our creepy hosts summarize the utterly horrifying deeds this man committed along with his very questionable pleasure outlets. *TRIGGER WARNING* this man is very vile creeps, and we want our audience to be fully prepared prior to listening to this episode - this man willingly shoved things into his own orifices, he consumed human feces, but he also raped, tortured, mu...

May 02, 202354 min

Reddit Reads: What Not To Do With A Skinwalker

Creeps and creepettes we promise we're gonna be back to our regularly scheduled unhinged true crime episodes..... Right after the Reddit reads that poppa bear and Katie have for you. From a haunting church to a crawler account about their own skin walker encounter this episode is sure to leave us all with a freaked case, of the creeps.

Apr 18, 202333 min

Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 6

Cue the Johnny Cash music cuz we're going to Jackson, Creeps! Papa Bear snatched the reins from Katie and theyre riding off into the sunset towards Colorado in this episode breakdown of The Last of Us. But be warned, there are a few foes along the way, in the form of Katie becoming their own soundboard, the cupboard lady ghost making a pant sh*tting appearance and lets not forget the constant roller coaster of heartache and sheltered life coming forward in the form of Katies lack of movie watchi...

Apr 11, 202356 min

Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 5

We got one word for this episode - unhinged. It's a breakdown episode! And right off the bat, Katie and Papa Bear are already holding onto their sh*t as Katie's ghost goes bananas with the lights and completely scares the life out of them. From that point on, its all downhill as they dissect Episode 5 of The Last of Us. As Joel and Ellie are making their way through Kansas City, they're greeted with some unwanted guests that turn into allies and we finally meet the man behind the name....Henry. ...

Apr 04, 20231 hr 4 min

Episode 22: Headbutt a Hooker | The Abduction of Colleen Stan

Can we all agree that Colleen Stan is one of the baddest b*tches to walk this earth!? This epsiode is dedicated to her, and the intense true story of the kidnapping and enslavement of Colleen. Not only that, but her captor, Cameron Hooker, took to a whole new dark side even Darth Vader would be proud of and kept Colleen in a box under his bed during her enslavment too. The elaborate schemes he pulled off to brainwash Colleen, and the intense torture she went through would make any sane person tr...

Apr 04, 20231 hr 20 min

Episode 23: Not on My Porch | Black Eyed Children

Turn off the lights and definitely lock your doors creeps! You never know when you may just get the unsuspecting knock of a child with pits of darkness for eyes needing to come inside your home or your car. On this episode, Katie and Nate are at it again, but with a different vibe for the episode - reading claims from Reddit of those who have encountered Black Eyes Kids. And let me tell ya....Katie scares the soul out of herself with just the thought of these little demon kids. So grab your flas...

Apr 04, 20231 hr 20 min

Episode 24: Geins Goods | Ed Gein

The tech battle is over and Katie prevailed! With a new computer and all the giddyness to get back into it, the Head Creeps are back at it again with this skin peeling* episode on none other than the Butcher himself, Ed Gein. Ed was an interesting case, but what made it even more interesting - Papa Bear led and Katie had no idea what she signed up for. With the undying need and want to please his psychotic mom, Ed truly knew no bounds of life itself after her passing and would later exhibit no s...

Apr 04, 20231 hr 2 min

Episode 36: The Supah Fly Snookah | The Unsolved Case of Molly Bish

Its a Crawler requested episode this week creeps! And on this one, Katie & Papa bear waste no time jumping right in to the tragic unsolved case of Molly Bish. Molly was only 16 years old and on her 8th day of her summer job as a lifeguard when she was abducted minutes after her mother dropped her off for the day. To this day,. suspects have been identified, but no arrests have been made. With little to no evidence and the largest search ever conducted in Massachusetts state history, Mollys c...

Mar 28, 20231 hr 9 min

Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 4

Cue the boogie music because it’s time for a breakdown episode. Joel and Ellie seem to have already come so far on their journey in the hit new show The Last of Us, and things are just getting started. After losing Tess, the only companion Joel had left, and Ellie losing…well, everyone; they’re left with no one else but each other. Which in essence starts to make/force the pair to create a bond within each other. After restocking up at Bill & Franks home and heading back out our duo hits the...

Mar 21, 202344 min

Episode 35: Pimp Hands Smackin' & Chains a Draggin' | The Bell Witch Haunting

O.M.G it's a GIRLS NIIIIGHT over here at the creepy cave. With Katie & Mama Jerri at the mic and the listener requested episode with our main girl the Bell Witch, this episode is FULL of Witch Mafia shenanigans and spooky moments galore. John Bell Sr was your average Joe (or John) famer during the 1800s, until he and his family became the center of the towns attention with their uninvited guest - The Bell Witch. This witch had a vendetta out against the entire Bell Family and would cause ins...

Mar 14, 202358 min

Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 3

Ouu everyone buckle up, it’s time for us to crack open the breakdown of the super talked about episode 3 of The Last of Us. In this breakdown, Papa Bear and Katie first go off the rails about…. book porn? Which let’s be honest, just sets the tone for you weirdos to listen to the breakdown of episode 3. This is THE episode that caused a huge uproar within the shows fan community that Nick Offerman starred in; and set a huge fire under Papa Bears ass who just wants everyone to realize one thing – ...

Mar 07, 202351 min

Episode 34: Rick Flair This Bitch | Ted Bundy pt. 3

As the title says, lets Rick Flair this Bitch because we are FINALLY to the conclusion of Ted Bundy. Not only that, but its very apparent that our hosts are absolutely slap happy in this re-record of the episode. With Bundy in custody, then out, then back in custody....and then out again.....only to end up in Florida, reeking more havoc in the Florida State University area with the Chi omega murders; and then BACK in custody for the final time, we reach the electric ending of Bundy in more ways ...

Mar 03, 20231 hr 6 min

Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 2

It's a Katie filled episode! With Katie riding solo on this one, she's diving into Episode 2 of the hit new HBO Series, "The Last of Us." **Spoiler Alerts Ahead** We're talking about the trek to meet the Rebel Fireflies, and the shit fest show it took to get there. Plus, we get an intro to the second type of "infected" running around town now too - The Clicker. The name alone is enough for for this episode to give us all a case, of the creeps.

Feb 27, 202339 min

Episode 33: Check The Chin | Ted Bundy pt 2.

Crusin down the street in my V dub, crowbarin the bitches, Killin these girls! That's right creeps the long awaited part 2 on Ted Bundy in our heavy hitters series is finally here! Pappa bear Nate and Katie finally get into what you've all been waiting for, the twisted disgusting nitty griddy details of Bundy's murders that are sure to make you grind your teeth. And guess what you guys get this one fully unedited! So strap in and prepare those holes on the side of your heads. This man was so ext...

Feb 21, 20231 hr 28 min

Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 1

Its a fungal infected nightmare over here Creeps! As Katie & Papa Bear get back to normal life after the chaos of moving, our Head Creeps decided to do just one more pallet cleanser before the mayhem of upcoming cases is unleashed. How you may ask? By starting a new series breaking down the new hit series "The Last of Us" taking the cinematic world by storm currently....or should we say infecting. In this episode we are breaking down the very first episode of this season, and lets just say -...

Feb 20, 202348 min

Reddit Reads: The Spook Skoots

Who's ready for some slappy happy tangent filled nonsense!?! Katie and Pappa bear decided to scrape your tongues and cleanse that pallette this week with some good ol reddit reads in preparation for part 2 of the murders and trial of Ted Bundy. So sit back and relax while Pappa bear and Katie give you some of the best (and worst) stories the people of reddit have to offer up.

Feb 06, 202357 min
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android