Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts, radio news. You're listening to Bloomberg Business Week with Carol Masser and Tim Stenovek on Bloomberg Radio.
We truly, truly respect all that is going on and is important to investors, and we're going to stay on it, including watching all of the day's IPOs. At the same time, the team here at Bloomberg Business Week Daily has been thinking a lot about some of the stories that impact investors' longer term impact all of the Bloomberg audience, and that have often been in the headlines, but often get buried and lost in the never ending flow of headlines, social
media posts, and DC press events. And so today we wanted to take a look at the CDC. We're talking about the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which was the subject recently of a Bloomberg Business Week deep dive. It was entitled America will Get Sick as CDC's total overhaul takes shape, and Tim that reporting by Bloomberg's Jessica Nicks and Madison Muller.
Jessica Nicks joins us now here in the studio. Also joining us today doctor Richard E. Besser, President and CEO of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, former acting director of the CDC and the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry in early two thousand and nine, I was during the early months of the first Obama administration. He joins us from New Jersey, doctor Bestar, I do want to
start with you and just big picture. I think many Americans would agree, regardless of their political affiliation, regardless of how they feel about what's happening at the CDC and AHHS right now, that Americans are unhealthy in general, that Americans are sick, that the American health system has not been working for years. Why hasn't it? What hasn't been working?
Yeah, you know, I think that's the right diagnosis.
And the big question is what are the drivers of that and their many you know, starting at the healthcare level. You know, healthcare is a small component of people's overall health, but we it is important. And we're the only wealthy nation in which your ability to access health care is so dependent on where you happen to have a job.
There are millions of people in our country who work more than one job per day who don't have access to high quality comprehensive affordable health care, and without that, they will tend to show up in emergency rooms, They'll show up.
Late for care and be sicker.
We also are seeing with the latest legislation out of Washington that tens of millions of people in addition, are going to lose their health care access, so that will move us in their own direction. Some of the biggest drivers of health I have to do with income and whether someone has the income to be able to afford healthy, nutritious food, whether they have the income and the leisure time to be able to get physical activity. These are
critical components of health in America. But we are seeing that in America the rates of chronic disease are extremely high and we need to do more to address that. So I think that there probably is a lot of agreement around what the problem is. There is less agreement in terms of what the drivers of that are or what the solution should be.
All Right, so let's get to and I want to bring in Bloomberg News health reporter Jessica Nicks, who wrote the story with Madison Muller and Jessica, in your reporting, you know that there is a small but vocal contingent that's long been demanding changes at the CDC, and then with an ally in RFK junior the AHHS Secretary, finally getting these critics kind of getting what they want. But scientists are really worried because they feel like they've been sidelined. What is everyone so worried about.
Well, we've seen that in the past few months since RFK came in to take over the Department of Health and Human Services, a complete dismantle at the CDC for what we've seen in the past. There was a lot of criticisms of the CDC during the COVID pandemic in terms of guidance around what schools should be doing, social distancing masking. It really divided a lot of the public.
Since RFK has come in, we've seen mass layoffs in terms of divisions that study chronic disease, gun violence, injury prevention. We've also seen the dismantle of a vaccine panel called the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, whos supposed to meet next week and hand picked members from RFK have now come into that panel and dismantled vaccine policy as we know it. In August, we also saw a shooting at
the CDC. Where the CDC was the attack from a gunman who fired nearly five hundred rounds at the buildings. Weeks after that, the CDC director was fired weeks into her tenure over vaccine policy. So there's so much confusion and chaos at the CDC that the actual work is not as able to get done because everyone's gone.
So doctor Bester, let's bring you in. I mean, the worries justified.
Do we need you know?
I guess I want to take a step back because I think it's fair to say that sometimes we of institutions that have been in place for a long time and there are aspects that get a little stale or that maybe could be improved, and so it's good to take a look at things. But I'm just wondering your view, as a former acting director of the CDC, what needs to maybe be fixed at the CDC, What is maybe wrong about the current approach, and what is right maybe about the current approach.
Yeah, I mean it is so important to look critically at our institutions and ask the question, how can they perform better?
Where have they not performed well? And how do you address that? It's critical. I worked at the CDC for thirteen years under Republican and democratic administrations. I ran emergency preparedness for four years during the Bush administration, which is why I was made acting director at the start of the Obama administration to be able to respond to public health crises. What we're seeing here is the destruction of the world world's leading public health agency. The CDC doesn't
just provide public health expertise for the United States. It had been looked at as a beacon for public health around around the world.
That's no longer the case.
The administration came in and haphazardly fired of tens of thousands of federal health workers, so many people at the CDC For an administration that is concerned about chronic disease. They eliminated the Office on Smoking in Health, and smoking is the leading preventable cause of chronic disease. There hasn't been any coherent approach to this. At the start of the Obama administration, there were efforts to look across the agency,
where was it lacking, where could it do better. Before the start of the COVID pandemic, the public's take on the CDC was very high and had very high approval ratings.
But we saw with the COVID pandemic see makes some mistakes, but we also saw the intentional politicization of public health by an administration that saw the opportunity for a political gain, and so across the nation we saw hundreds of talented public health professionals be vilified, people leave their jobs, some forced out, some not able to take the stress or the blatant threats to their health and safety.
And now, with this.
Administration, at a time where we need to rebuild trust, we have as our Secretary of Health one of the nation's leading anti vaccine advocates and someone who has demonstrated no respect for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Doctor Besser, you mentioned that the CDC is this beacon of global public health. We saw what they did during the COVID pandemic. But what does this mean for future pandemics that might pop up if we have a dismantled CDC, not just for the US, but also for the world.
Okay, my heart just stopped beating, because we are going to get another global pandemic arm a doctor Pessor.
Yeah, the question is when not in but one of the challenges it's not just the CDC being decimated the elimination of USAID, the Agency for International Development. The CDC works very closely with USAID personnel around the globe to make sure that health departments are ready, public health professionals are ready to be able to detect and respond to signals very quickly to ensure that other countries can control disease, but it also helps ensure that new diseases don't come
to our shores. Dropping out of the World Health Organization, which is designed to be the body to help share information around the globe help ensure that problems are contained where they arise. That is leading leaving us as a nation less secure, more defenseless. The cut of billions of dollars to the CDC means a cut of billions of dollars to state in local health departments.
Because most of the money to the CDC has passed on.
That means that in our communities they're not going to be as well prepared, not just for the next pandemic or major infectious disease crisis, but for making sure the restaurant you go to for dinner is serving you food that doesn't make you sick, and when your kids go to the swimming pool, they can swim in that water without getting harmed. These are some of the things that the CDC has done that they're not able to do with what's taken place under this administration.
So, doctor, when, in your view, do we start to see the effects if we haven't already of these cuts that you've been talking about, Well, we are.
Seeing them, and you're reporting that. Such a nice job lifting that up.
Where a health department in Texas calls the cd for the CDC for assistance and there's nowhere there, there's no one there to help. We heard early on in Milwaukee where they're dealing with lead and their water supply. They called the CDC, but the group that worked on lead poisoning had been like, oh, these are things that will affect people at the community level. It will continue to grow, but in general, public health is invisible.
When it's working properly. It's only when it's not working properly and then get stressed. So whenever there's a crisis in a community and.
Public health can't respond, then you will see it and then hopefully people in their communities will say this doesn't work for us. We need the CDC to be supported. We need our state and local public health departments to be supported.
Doctor Besser, Why are we so divided when it comes to There are those of us who are like, yeah, I trust the government, I trust the CDC and what they say, and then there are those that don't. Is it just politically motivated or is it people who don't feel like they get good health care and so they're like, the system is just not working.
Yeah, it's a great question, and I think that there are a number of factors. Before COVID pandemic, the approval rating by both parties was very, very strong.
With the COVID pandemic, there were mistakes that CDC made, but I led the CDC at the start of the H one N one swine flu pandemic, and during that period we saw extremely high approval ratings. And the reason for that was there was intentionally efforts to not politicize the response. People from both parties came together and said, we're going to do what it takes to keep people in our communities safe. What we recommend now may change as we learn more information. That's a good thing. With
the COVID pandemic. Whenever there was a change in guidance. It was jumped on as a sign that the agency didn't know what they were doing. And CDC wasn't allowed to talk directly to the public after the first two months in the pandemic, and that is a setup for disaster because you need active communication to build trust and maintain trust, and once you've lost trust, it's extremely hard to.
Get it back, doctor Besser. We've also seen this dismantle of the Vaccine Committee at the CDC, which decides which insurance people are going to be able to have to be able to get their vaccines. So what does that mean to watch this dismantle of the vaccine policy as well.
Yeah, So, I'm a general pediatrician and I practiced pediatrics for more than thirty years, and I know that nothing I did as a pediatrician had more proven value than helping my patients make sure that they were vaccinated completely and on time. And that took spending a lot of time with parents answering their really good questions so that they were comfortable making the right decision for their children.
And I always said, if you have a question, if you want some honest information, go to the CDC website. They'll give you all the information. We can't do that anymore, and that is a major problem. We're seeing other organizations step up. The Academy of Pediatrics represents pediatricians. I'm a member of that group. They have guidance. We're seeing states
come up with guidance. But the idea that we can't look to the CDC because this advisory group has become so politicized, so staffed with people who who have strong anti vaccine agendas, will put us at great risk. And what I'm hearing about the committee meeting for next week is that they will raise great concerns about safety in the COVID vaccine, safety concerns that have not been verified scientifically.
And this again will lead people to be confused and will lead some people to make a decision that I think is not good for the health of their families.
All right, And as we know, confusion uncertainty never good, doesn't matter what area of the world or our lives that we're talking about. Doctor Besser, thank you so much, Doctor Richard Besser, President CEO of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, former Acting Director of the CDC, joining us from New Jersey on this Friday. Hey, Jessica before you go. Incredible story. Highly recommend everybody check it out on the Bloomberg I'm
reading and you do quote doctor Besser. He said it here and he said, in a very short time, we've seen an incredible destruction of the agency that leaves people here and around the world at increasing risk. And of course he was talking about the CDC. Your kind of thoughts After having a further discussion with doctor Besser and where we are in terms of healthcare in America.
It's going to be really interesting to watch what happens to public health across the US right now. We're seeing a bit of a piecemeal policy around vaccine policy in the US too. States are kind of adopting their own guidelines or working together about how can we start making sure that COVID vaccines are still offered at pharmacies now
as well. So we're seeing a state by state approach to public health now, which is difficult without the CDC, because the CDC does provide that nationwide view of what's happening to the nation's healthcare right.
And it sounds like different states have different moneies and that will kind of determine some of the healthcare.
Well, not just that, I think insurance companies have an interesting position here because if the CDC doesn't necessarily recommend something, but states do, then what is an insurance company going to cover And to what extent does that actually push somebody to get or not get a certain medicine.
That's a great question, and I think we're going to be seeing that play out, especially starting next year when the next plans start. As of this year, insurance companies are still going to cover vaccines, but health experts have been telling us in our reporting that the cost of a vaccine is probably less than the cost of the illness that you're going to get later on and then your hospital bill and everything else.
So they are a whole idea of preventive medicine right, exactly right, and folks have been preaching that for such a long time. Thank you so much you're reporting and also joining us here. Bloomberg News Health reporter Jessica Nick