Bill cunning into Great America, and of course what's happening in public education is often a disgrace. It's made difficult anyway, but when large numbers of shall I say, undocumented aliens show up in public schools, it could be a
crisis. There have been a few occasions when the Congress has held hearings on the consequences of Biden's border chaos for k through twelve schools, but it's largely a story that doesn't get a lot of media coverage because it doesn't fit the left wing agenda, and therefore you have to look for outside sources to see what's going on. Erica Sansey is one of the officials of Parents Defending Education. I know it's happening here in Cincinnati, also happening around the world.
I can't imagine what it looks like in Houston or Austin. But of course Erica has expertise when it comes to Washington, Washington, DC, and Erica Sanzy welcome again to the Bill Cunningham Show. And Erica, can you tell the American people just in general? Before there was an influx of literally hundreds of thousands of additional students, many poorly educated, into our public school system. Weren't the public schools under stress anyway? Yes, I mean this is
just adding insult to injury. The public schools have been struggling. Even pre pandemic, we had very very low proficiency rates in reading and math. Since the pandemic, we've seen the scores plummet in those areas, and so schools are having a hard time with what they already have on their plates, and so to burden them with an influx of new students, most of whom do not speak the language here, and many of whom have had no formal schooling
in the past. So it's not just that you're bringing in new students to schools, you're bringing in very high need students. And these school districts really just cannot manage this. And I look at some of these stories given up about thousands. In New York City, there's about fifty thousand additional students going to public schools and a population of nearly one million public school kids. You got fifty thousand, that's five percent, but that five percent puts them over
the top. Also in Washington, d C. There's something called language acquiestion division. Explain what English second language. Let's say you're a twelve year old, just show up in a public school in Washington, d C. Or Cincinnati or Chicago, and you have no education. You can barely understand and speak Spanish, which phonetically is easy for some in Central America but difficult for others. So what are the particular needs of any child that shows up deserving
a public education? But let's face it, the school system can't accept them, And so it kind of walks through what occurs when a kid shows up at the front desk says, here, I am educate me. What happens, Well, the school cannot turn students away, so really they've got to figure out how they're going to navigate this. And what we did is we looked at emails that were going back and forth, you know, with between officials in districts, so that we could get a sense of like how hard
of a time they were having. And again, you're not going to get them out of the microphone saying this is impossible. But in their emails, what we see is it's as basic as trying to figure out space. They don't have the physical space, so they're trying to figure out where they're going to put students you see a lot of the you know, very compassionate people feeling concerned that the school that the child is assigned to is very far away
from the shelter that's been provided for them. And then we see a lot of talk about how they don't have the staff, they don't have staff who can communicate with these students, most of whom boot speak Spanish, but certainly not all, and so that's become just another major drain on the system. And the other thing is that English as a second language, or what they call English Language learners, those students usually are students where they know English but
it's not spoken in their home. But to have students coming in who have no English at all, I mean, that's just obviously puts them in a category of a very high need student. And again, meeting the needs of one or two is challenging. Meeting the needs of a massive influx, where suddenly a school district is dealing with one hundred and fifty students in this category
it is just again really really difficult. And this is coming at a time that all of the esser money, so all the COVID release money that school's got that is ending as of September, that money is gone, and so school districts were already trying to write, size and recalibrate their budgets as they need to and as they knew they were going to need to. Unfortunately,
some didn't make good choices about how to spend that money. But to be again burdening them with this influx of students, it's it's a totally unfair burden that the school districts have been asked to carry, and that in the case of the NEA, the largest teachers union, they've come out against the i'd an administration's plan to shut the border down or at least, you know, decrease this number of people coming in that they are so committed to this ideology
of open borders they've now thrown their own members under the bus, saying, we don't care how hard it is for you, this border should stay open. It's always difficult, but can you imagine a ten year old girl showing up from Lithuania or Afghanistan or Nicaragua and have little or no English language skills. They sit in a class and do they test in do they say, okay, you're ten years old. There's supposed to be what in about the
fourth or fifth grade. You're ten years old, but you have no educational foundation or achievement, and then you don't speak the language. Someone shows up at the front desk. Okay, here's your schedule. The first class is down the hallway in room one. Ten go into that classroom and sit there, and they have no ability to understand what's being said, and they have no foundation of the first four to five years, which allows one the building
points to become more academically disciplined. So what happens to the ten year old who can't speak of the English is our Do schools have to assign a mate with them who understands both dialects or both two or three different languages to communicate? How does that work? I mean, in a perfect world, they'd be able to assign someone to them, but those people don't exist. The school district doesn't have the staff for this, and so what ends up happening.
And I've actually seen this back when I worked in schools. Lots of times kids just have their whole day wasted because they are because they have been enrolled in an institution or facility that cannot meet their needs. Now you can get lucky and you can have. It could be that the school has somebody who who knows the language is great with working with newly arrived migrant students. Like you can see progress, but everything has to align for that to happen,
and that's usually in very small numbers. The problem right now is that places like DC Springfield, Massachusetts, which is tak Kansas, another district in Wisconsin. I mean, these places are not used to having to deal with this number one and they're just completely overwhelmed. And again they're not getting you know, there isn't really much attention being paid to the fact that these schools
are being asked to manage a burden that is unsustainable. I look at some of these stories and that what happens the educational opportunity may I use the term regular kids. If you're a regular fourth grader in Washington d C. Public
schools, I can't imagine the quality of education you might receive. But nonetheless, it doesn't assist to have classes disrupted with large numbers of other fourth graders that are not educationally appropriate, don't know the culture, don't know how to behave, and can't speak the language, and the teachers have to more or less take care of student body that she doesn't speak a dialect out of a f or Central America, and the kid sits there with no hope of learning.
What impact does that have on the kids who've been there for three or four years, they're in the third or fourth grade. Here comes ten kids from Southern Asia Afghanistan that have no idea what you're talking about, don't speak the dialect. So what is it a babysitting service? Well, how does it look? I mean again, it's hard enough to meet all the needs
of all students in the classroom because they're often at very different levels. Right, So teachers already dealing with the fact that they've got students who have very different levels of proficiency. That is a massive challenge. So then when you bring in new challenges and again, these children didn't do anything wrong, right, and they have a right to be enrolled in the school according to the law. Here, the problem is these schools are not set up and equipped
to set them up for success. So what ends up happening is it's almost it's hard for anybody to really get what they need because the needs are so disparate. And this is you know again, I just feel like the schools are already reeling from the pandemic and trying to recover from that, and this just adds another massive challenge that from a compassionate angle of course, right the
school districts wanted you the best they can buy these kids. But the realistic, you know, situation, or the truth about what's going on is like they don't have what they need to be able to do it. And of course the leads on because what you're reporting, Erica Sansei of parents defending education is happening every day in every public school, whether in Minnesota or Maine or California. There's something like two million children have come in the past five years.
The official numbers eight million total. And of the eight million, there's about two million children who are legally entitled to a quality public education dispersed all over the country, and the school districts are not set up happening. Whenever there's an action, there's an opposite and direct reaction to what's going on.
About seventeen or eighteen states now have educational vouchers. We have in Ohio where if you're dissatisfied with your public school, you can take a voucher that's works between eight and twelve thousand dollars to a private school or to a Catholic school
or some other monastery school outside the system and parents. There have been tens of thousands in the state of Ohio that have left the public school system, leaving behind even a worse situation because if you're a parent in Washington, DC, or Wichita, or Chicago or Cincinnati, and you have a voucher available of putting your kid's hands, the voucher goes with the kid and you can get a quality education outside of the Chicago public schools which are in total chaos,
complete destruction. You're going to leave and then what do you leave behind? Yeah, I mean the reality is, in my opinion, every single family, regardless of their income, deserves to have options when it comes to where they're going to educate their children. And to your point, you know there's people who are if you're in a failing system and you have an escape hatch, most of the time you're going to take it. So what's the
solution, Erica? Instead of cursing the darkness, what's the solution of this terrible problem which is producing kids coming out at eighteen years old who have difficulty reading their diploma. They were never failed because it is always socially promoted throughout urban America. You never fail, and you get done, and you basically went through about fourteen years of whatever in the public school system, and you come out and you have no quality education at all. What happens? How
do you solve the problem? Well, the social promotion is not only in urban America, though we've never seen social promotion in suburban America. I think that, honestly, part of it is people have to get brutally honest about what's really going on. I mean, one problem is that nobody wants to
tell the truth about what's really going on. So the first thing is is to and part of that is because there is a lot of intimidation around people wanting to speak freely about these topics, right, So teachers that are really really struggling all with these issues, they're not likely to speak out about this in any sort of public way. The other thing is that is that I mean, again, I was a teacher for a lot of years, and I was a member of the NEA and two states, and I'm telling you,
like, the unions are a massive villain in this. They never talk about student learning, student outcomes. They don't talk about, you know, reading and maths proficiency. They are hyper political organizations now, and so, for example, that's why we don't even see them being supportive in terms of helping with this immigration, this influx of students, because their ideology is such that they want the borders wide open and they don't really care about the impact
that that's having on their own members. No, teachers are leaving in droves, they can't can't take it anymore. And lastly, if after November or the same philosophy remains in charge, and we have the next four to twelve years of open borders, whether it's whether it's Biden or Kamala Harris or Gavin Newsom wherever, it might be, all interchangeable left wing drill bits. If that policy continues the next four to twelve years, what's the state of public
education all over the country after twelve more years of this? I mean, I have this. I have concerns about the state of it now currently. And so if we do not get our arms around this and begin making you know, hard choices, but hard choices that are good for students and families and teachers, we're going to be in trouble. Teachers will leave, counselors will leave, Education will become double and triple and price. Citizens don't want
to vote additional levies to support the schools that aren't functional. You've got to build brand new building. Schools have become also now welcome wagons. They've become language centers, They've become nursing centers and medical centers. They've become psychological service centers. They've become feeding stations. All these things in the past were handled within a family or a community, and families and communities don't exist anymore.
And I don't see a way out of this until we stop what's in other words, before you start about drain draining the swamp, stop the inflow. And we can't do that until we stop this happening of literally two million kids have entered America in the past four years, two million dispersed all over the country. And if that accelerates these days, the same public education is done. And I don't know what happens to our great and use to our magnificent
cities. You know, America, for a long time we had magnificent American cities, majestic American cities, and all of them are being destroyed in one way or another because of crime and lawlessness and lack of faith, lack of family. And it's not lack of funding, because Washington DC public school kids get about twenty two thousand dollars a year each from the Congress, and they want more money, and they want more money because of the failure of the
board and border policies. But all right, Erica Sanzi, go ahead, please, Finnishop, I was just going to say, most of that money never makes it to kids, and it never makes it a classroom, so
you know, obviously they're terrible stewards of the money. And the last thing I would say is that if we're going to consider schools to be social service institutions, right, you know, we're going to provide you with all the services that you need, then we need to stop calling them schools, right because schools are not meant to be places that provide every single need for a family. They're meant to be institutions of learning. Now the goal is higher
learning or secondary learning. The goal is to come here and get the basics and then many at the age of eighteen, I love the idea of getting an electrician, getting a plumb. I love that some go on to institutions of hire indoctrination at the Ivy League, and that's even worse. But I can't imagine public education. I don't care what city or state you're in.
If these policies continue, it'll it'll collapse. And the collapse. I think it's collapsed right now because I can't imagine comparing the senior high school or eighth grade proficiency rates now till like fifty years ago, it's not even close. There is none, and they're getting worse, and no one's addressing the real problem, which is out the southern border. It's not money, and it's
as teachers' unions dominate and they fire superintendents all the time. Like in Cincinnati, we had a pretty good one named Ironetta Wright, and she had a vote after about a year and a half trying to change things in Cincinnati, which is a terrible school district. The six unions got together voted a censure, no vote confidence, and the school board fired the superintendent and paid off
about three hundred thousand dollars to get her out the door. And she wanted to make significant changes, and the six unions in Cincinnati did not want it to happen, and we're left and it's awful. The unions do not like people who come in to disrupt the status quo, so it is very common for unions to go after makers, and what we need are change makers.
So that is again why I say again the rank and file members of the unions are not well represented by their leaders, and those organizations are nothing but political organizations. Now, they do not represent their members well at all, and you know, they are a big problem. And that is why you'll see like a place like Florida is really taking off academically. They're you know,
they've they've moved up to the rankings. They think they're now first at least in some categories, whereas other states like where I live, Rhode Island, where a high spending, low performing state, and that is not only because of the power of the union, but is definitely related to that. All right, Erica Sansey, we got to go parents defending education keep working. It's a tough job, but someone has to do it. And Erica,
once again, thank you for coming on the Bill Cunningham Show. Thank you, thank you, Erica, thank you, thanks for having me. Well, let's continue with more your reaction five three, seven, four, nine, seven thousand, Bill Cunningham News Radio seven hundred WW. The Rore Insurance Agency has been meeting and exceeding the insurance needs of tri stators for more
than a quarter of a century. Whether it's life insurance, disability business, or insuring your home, whether here or a second home in Florida, Michigan, Kentucky, Tennessee, or anywhere. Row Insurance is ready to handle all your insurance needs and processing your claims. Twenty four to seven. Put the Roar back on your insurance. Call the Row Insurance Agency today or online roweriins dot com. My wife and I both we ended up mildly sick for a
few months, and the nasal congestion is probably the worst part. I'd like a post nasal drip, just super congested all the time. We were taking everything we possibly could, but nothing really worsed. Kyrie was miserable until a friend recommended Nevage. Nevage offers immediate drug free congestion relief, flushing your nasal passages with refreshing sailing and sucking out mucus, germs and other airborne irritants. Don't live in misery. This cold season. Use nevage so you can breathe
easier, sleep better, and feel your best right away. The biggest thing Nevage has done has completely cleaned out my nasal passages. It was from the first use I was able to just clear out anything that was stopping me from breathing correctly. Novage helps me clear the way, literally clear the way for me to operate better in the rest of my life. Experience the Nevage difference yourself. Navage is available atnvage dot com or at Walmart, Walgreens, CBS,
and Write Aid. Nevage nav Age one eight seven seven Colors Kids ka as cars one eat seven seven Cars for Kids. Donate your cars today. Donate today at Cars for Kids dot org. Your car, running or not, could be picked up as soon as the next day. No title, no problem. Go to Cars for Kids dot org today seven seven Cars for Kids now accepting donations of land, homes, buildings, or any kind of real estate. I call it like I see it, and plumb Tight does
plumbing right. Visit plumbtight dot com. Today News, traffic and weather, News Radio seven hundred WLW