¶ High School Coach Retires, Returns
High school coaches . Imagine deciding to retire after an incredible career . You've done it all State title , hall of Fame inductions . Numerous players go on to play at the next level and , more importantly , become productive members of society . But , just like in the Godfather 3 movie , al Pacino's character , michael Corleone , is trying to retire from organized crime .
He says just when I thought I was out , they pull me back in . Back on March 3rd 2021 , scott Manahan joined me on the show and he talked about how he's enjoying retirement and having fun . He's enjoying retirement and having fun . Then he takes a phone call from a coach , an alum from Capital University .
Now , three years later , scott's trying to build the program at Capital University . Sometimes you return to the game you love and what you do best , and that's coaching .
In this episode , you'll discover why you should think long and hard about making the jump from high school to college coaching ranks , why good players struggle when they go to college , and great stories from fellow high school coaches . Next , on Baseball Coaches Unplugged .
Welcome to Baseball Coaches Unplugged with Coach Ken Carpenter , presented by Athlete One . Baseball Coaches Unplugged is a podcast for baseball coaches , with 27 years of high school baseball coaching under his belt , here to bring you the inside scoop on all things baseball , from game-winning strategies and pitching secrets to hitting drills and defensive drills .
We're covering it all . Whether you're a high school coach , college coach or just a baseball enthusiast , we'll dive into the tactics and techniques that make the difference on and off the field . Discover how to build a winning mentality .
Inspire your players and get them truly bought into your game philosophy Plus , get the latest insights on recruiting , coaching , leadership and crafting a team culture that champions productivity and success . Join Coach every week as he breaks down the game and shares incredible behind-the-scenes stories .
Your competitive edge starts here , so check out the show weekly and hear from the best coaches in the game . On Baseball Coaches Unplugged .
Baseball Coaches Unplugged is proud to be partnered with the netting professionals , improving programs one facility at a time . Coaches , are you looking to make your field one of the best ones in your area ? Then do what every college and high school coach that have the best fields do . They contact will minor and his team at the Nettick Professionals .
They specialize in the design , fabrication and installation of custom netting for baseball and softball . This includes backstops , batting cages , bp turtles , screens , ball cards and more . They also design and install digital graphic wall padding , windscreen turf , turf protectors , dugout benches and cubbies . Windscreen turf , turf protectors , dugout benches and cubbies .
They're not limited to just baseball and softball . They also work with football teams , soccer , lacrosse and golf courses . Contact them today at 844-620-2707 . That's 844-620-2707 . Or visit them online at wwwnettingproscom and check out Netting Pros on X , instagram , facebook and LinkedIn for all their latest products and projects .
Before I get to my interview with Scott Manahan , be sure to hit the subscribe button and follow the show . We put out a new episode every Wednesday and if you really enjoy it , text it to a friend or a fellow coach . Button and follow the show .
We put out a new episode every Wednesday and if you really enjoy it , text it to a friend or a fellow coach and tell them to check out our show . We would love the support . Now to my sit-down with head baseball coach at Capital University , scott Manahan . Hello and welcome to Baseball Coaches Unplugged .
I'm your host , ken Carpenter , and joining me today is Scott Manahan , head baseball coach at Capital University . Coach , thanks for taking the time to be on here . Baseball Coaches Unplugged .
No problem , ken , I love it .
Well , I want to start off with . You know you go from Hall of Fame high school coaching career to retirement . And now you know you've been the head coach at Division III Capital University for a few years now and is it kind of like the Godfather , where you got pulled back in ?
Yeah , I'll tell you what . You do something long enough and you love to do what you do , and and then you leave it . And you know I left at the right time because I wasn't dealing with all the COVID stuff , so I figured that was a pretty good idea . It just happened that way . Of course I didn't plan it that way , but it was okay .
And the first , the first year , you know , it was all dealing with all the COVID stuff . And then all of a sudden , you know , then the next year I'm going and watching games and I was there for two or three innings because it was just frustrating . And so you start to think to yourself I wonder if I could get into it again .
And all of a sudden the old coach at Capital had resigned right in the middle of the season . And then Tom Marker who I blame a little on Tangy Orange , the guy that graduated from Capital , so he's an alum and he called me and said would you like to take the team for the rest of the year ? I've already reached him up to the AD .
So I worked with the people at Waterston and they thought it was good to do . And now I'm going into year four .
¶ High School to College Baseball Transition
What would be your message to high school players who want to play college baseball , since you've been on both ends of the spectrum now ?
Well , especially at the Division III spectrum , and I used to tell my guys this when I was at watterson and hamilton , wherever I was at . You know it's all about academics and your gpa , right wrong or whatever . You have to get academically set so you can go ahead and use that to get money off the tuition to go to division three university .
So anybody that people that's going to look at you , your grades are going to be important , but in the Division III level grades equals money . So you know , I think the first thing I always talk about is if you have interest in playing at the next level , you better be ready , active and work Then after that that's your work ethic .
And don't tell me you want to play if you don't want to work at it . There's so many guys now that want to play baseball but they don't know what work ethic is . They get to college and they play .
For a guy like myself who's asking them to come in and do the things I'm asking them to do to get better shape physically , mentally , and it's a lot of time and they're not ready to do it . So you have to be academically set and you have to really make sure that you're working hard on your game weight room and all those kind of things .
What would you recommend for a high school coach who's maybe considering making that jump to becoming a college coach ?
Think long and hard . Think long and hard , I mean it's a whole different thing . I always ask myself . I remember years ago asking George Powell at Otterbein what he made to do what he did . And he told me all the different things that he did to make extra money and all that kind of stuff .
And I went home and talked to my wife about it and she said , no way , we can't afford to live on that . And I was on a Catholic school salary , so it wasn't like we were making a lot in the first place . So it became really out of my mind and then this whole thing is different . Now .
I don't want to say they're overpaying me , but it's really going to be a good wage for what I have to do .
Would you say that with Division III coaching , division III baseball , what is the time commitment ? I guess comparing offseason to inseason .
That's a great question . During the offseason again , we're talking about the 90 days of darkness . I have nothing to do in the summer when it comes to my players . They're gone . In reality I don't get to the Manahan tailgate of the house as much as I used to , because fall is busy . We're fundraising .
We're going to go to Vero Beach again this year , jackie Robinson . So we're going to Cedar Point raising money at Cedar Point and I'm staying at a dorm real much . My guys go to work for three days and that takes away time . But September and October is really busy , really busy .
And then November , december and most of January we're not allowed to do anything with the guys . And then , boy , when it starts in January , you know , february , march , april , everything's crazy . So it's as you know , in the summertime you're recruiting and you're doing the other things that you're doing , but that's really pretty much a weekend thing .
But with high school I spent a lot more time Just because of all the six-man hitting stuff . You know the great thing that Urban Meyer built the illness batting cage . All of a sudden , that batting cage . All of a sudden that batting cage was there . Everybody wanted to use it . Now , guess what ?
I didn't have it in me to just give a code to anybody If we were going to do it . Somebody was going to be there for liability reasons . I was usually .
It was a lot of time .
I had less time to call than I did in high school .
How has the transfer portal affected you as a D3 coach ?
Well , we lost a kid that went up to Division II last year , a kid from New Jersey . It's in Philadelphia is where he's going , so he made a jump up to Division II so we lost him . I haven't really done a whole lot of bringing guys in . I'm a real big believer of the high school guys coming in and graduating .
We've had them for four years so I won't say I won't get involved with the transfer portal , but I really haven't too much right now . We've lost a couple guys over the last couple years now and it's a good move for them , so good for them . Not a problem with bringing in guys and helping them move up levels .
You know you talked about the players , not really . Some of them haven't figured out the whole work ethic part .
¶ College Baseball Challenges and Goals
What would you tell their parents to kind of get them to kind of start talking that up with their son ?
I'm going to knock on . You can hear my knocking on wood . Okay , I'm going to knock on wood . I don't deal with parents . I'm not calling their parents . I'm not going to motivate their parents . To motivate them , I'm not calling them about the kids' grades .
You know , in this world we live in , these young men , they want to be young men , but sometimes they want to be high school students and I'm not . You can't be both . You're in college now , so you're 19 years old , and if you have situations that we need to deal with , my door is always open .
My assistant coach's door is always open , and I talk to the kids , not to the parents .
Makes total sense . My wife's in the hiring business and she hears stories of parents trying to take part in interviews once they graduate college . It's a different world . It seems like I can see it .
Yeah , it really is , and we have to deal with it . Division III baseball if you're here to play Division III baseball at Capital , it's real simple . It's number one . It's faith and family . Whatever everybody's faith is , that's fine , but family's got to be very important to all these kids , and I want to preach that .
Number two is academics , because that's why you're here , and if you're here just to play baseball and your academics fails , you're not going to be here long . And then baseball is number three , because who's going to go out and play at the next level ? We don't know , but not most of them . Yeah , so we really .
I just really put the , I put it on the kids and I'm saying , calling them kids . I'm 61 years old , but they're not kids , they're young men , so you can't be both though . You can't be a high school kid , you can't be treated like a college guy . So we put it on them to take care of all that .
What are some of the biggest challenges that incoming freshmen struggle with outside of the work , ethic and things that Time management is the number one thing that incoming freshmen deal with .
They're away from mom and dad now , which 50% of their mom and dad have been on them for 18 years of their life over top of them . You know , making sure everything's getting done so they don't have the ability to be on their own and then how to manage their time . So most of the guys don't have a problem on the baseball field .
Their time management is not bad . You know , when we have all this free time , they got to come over and work on their own and you'll get a couple of guys that aren't interested in doing that . That's why you have a big roster . If you don't want to do it , you don't want to put the time in , it'll show and then we make decisions off of that .
So baseball the guys are really cool to get it , getting over here and getting their work in and they're in practice and they work hard and everything . But in that time in between you got to start playing video games and then get lost . All of a sudden it's 9 , 20 o'clock at night and then you try to get ready for class the next day and it's tough .
So we sit down with our freshmen right away and we get them a planner . I have an old OHSAA to-do list right on my desk that I use . We give all these guys a copy of this , make copies for them and use it , check it off and do all the things that you need to do . Some do a good job of it .
And get wins . Is it harder than it looks ?
I can go down the list , I don't want to forget anybody . But Ryan Harrison at Baltimore can care less about my high school career . George Powell , everybody in our league they can care less about what I did as a high school coach . And what I'm saying is , when I came here I thought I was going to be able to turn things around right away .
Those guys don't care , they're going to beat you , they're going to play the game . The way that they play . It's a great league . I've never seen anything like it . Of course the Catholic League was such a small little group that I co-founded for Waterston , but that was a great league . There just wasn't that many teams .
But you look up and down the OAC , you know it is year in and year out , one of the best leagues and we've been kind of hanging on up there in the bottom trying to work those things up . And you know , last year we got our first big win . We went and we were able to beat Paul and Wallace who were number two in the country .
So then the second game we played , we lost 4-1 . So you can see a little bit of confidence building in our guys . And then we finished with a win against Canyon and a real tough doubleheader against Marietta that we lost both of them . But you just can see that we're getting a little bit better . So the kids came back with a little bit more confidence .
This year we got a real good freshman class that we're excited about . So now , hopefully , we take another step . We won 10 games and the kids' goals are to win 20 . So every time we start slacking in the weight room or anything , I will see guys over here getting our score . All I just said on group is number 2-0 .
You guys said you want to win 20 games . It's not going to be easy . Our schedule has changed . You know . We tried to play some teams early just to get wins and we weren't getting those wins . So it's like it's time to get better . And then let's go ahead and let's take our chances and play hard and see how we end up this year .
So it's frustrating , but at the other time go ahead and let's take our chances and play hard and see how we end up this year . It's frustrating , but at the other time the pressure that I felt like I had all the time on Waterston was probably self-induced . If we didn't win the state of Waterston , it was a bad year .
Now I'm just trying to take this group to another level and I've never been involved in anything like it . I have no ego . I have no ego . I have no ego , I have no . It's all gone . I'm starting over again and I've probably lost more games in the four years of capital than it took me 15 years of water , and that's tough , but get over yourself .
But get over yourself . You get over yourself . It's not about me , it's about these guys . You know we're doing things in our field . Now that we're improving some things , I think we're doing some things the right way . So I didn't retire and get out of here . I can look back at it and say it's better than it was when I first started .
Yes , and there's no doubt that that's going to be the case . That , yes , and there's no doubt that that's going to be the case , that's for sure you know . You mentioned earlier about summertime and , when it comes to recruiting , what do you think travel ball is getting right and where does it need to improve ?
That's a travel ball question , you know .
I just go back to the day when it was the Worthington , it was 239 American League and you had the best players from Thomas , roentgen , watterson at the time and Kilbourne , you know , but it was like that all-star team of four or five guys that came together and they were pretty good and then everybody else played summer baseball .
Remember we'd have summer baseball leagues . I had three teams in Waterston at one time in the summertime .
And that wasn't good .
¶ Recruiting Baseball Players From Multiple States
So then the parents started to get away and that food started to fall down a little bit because of their own issues , and then it became travel ball . And then at the end of my Waterston career , the parents were asking me if we could get summer teams together because travel ball was going to be too much .
And I just laughed at them and said no , I'm not doing that again . That was a lot of work to do that and these kids wouldn't commit if somebody picked them up to go somewhere . Then all of a sudden they were not coming to play for us at Waterston .
So where's it at now , man , being in Columbus , I don't have to travel the state of Ohio because everybody somewhere comes into Columbus for one of these tournaments . So for me I'm not going to complain much about travel ball because it gives it an easy way for us to see these guys . I remember George Powell back in the day .
He would be at everybody's summer games . I'd never seen a guy run along so much . He would show up and do all these different things . Now I can just go to one spot , my assistant can be in another spot , my other assistant can be in another spot and we're recruiting . So back to the travel ball question .
The only thing that bothers me , the travel ball question , the only thing about travel ball anymore , is the overuse of the pitchers . We've got so many kids that come to us as incoming freshmen . We had one kid last year , 50 innings in the summer , 50 innings in the summer after pitching in the spring . So guess what His arms hurt .
He's seeing our athletic player before we just got to school . So whose fault is that ? It's the summer coach's fault , it's the parent , it's the kid . Somebody just say , no , this is too much . So you know , you get the position guys , they're getting swings , they're getting reps , they're getting as many ground balls as they can get in a game .
But I guess the only other issue that I have with travel ball is the fact that these guys show , don't practice , show up on Thursday , you know , play Thursday , friday , saturday , sunday , go home on Monday , tuesday , wednesday , do nothing , no-transcript . But the pitching thing is really my biggest concern .
When you consider bringing a player to Capital , how important is your conversation ? Is it more with the travel coach or more with the high school ?
Right , okay , yeah , I try to do both , especially if I know the high school guy , which I do know most of them I'm still being involved with HSBCA and all that kind of stuff . I do reach out a lot when we get guys . Probably half of our roster in North Carolina is from out of the state .
We have kids in our roster from the Dominican Republic , from Puerto Rico , from Florida , louisiana , california , all over the place . So those guys are even those guys . Just to even recruit them now is usually through Twitter or some kind of videos that they'll send me .
But then I'll reach out most of the time or my assistant coach will reach out to the high school coach or the travel coach . If it's a real good travel coach and I don't have a high school bag , I may call the travel coach .
I usually if a guy's got a 3.5 and this or that thing , he's usually probably not a problem in high school , so that helps me a little bit . If I have somebody on the 3.0 that we like , I'll call the coach just to make sure it's not because of a lack of effort or anything like that . 3.0 may be the best thing to do , so good for him .
I try to reach out . Yep , I try .
¶ Coaches Reflect on Winning and Losing
Do you hate losing or love winning ?
I really hate to lose , but I love to win . But I love to win , I love winning . You know , at Watterson we used to spell fun W-I-N , and that was just where we were at . When we win it's damn fun , when we lose it isn't , and you all feel that way and I feel that way . So why don't we do everything we can every game to have fun and win ?
So I love winning more than I hate losing , but I hate both . I hate losing . That was fun .
I almost felt like you know , when you won , you kind of were you expected it , wanted it , and then all of a sudden you're moving on to the next one and then when you lose , it just seems like it sticks with you .
Well , without a doubt , You're right , you've been around it long enough to know that . and that's really the issue is just trying to get past that loss and move on to the next one . But I did not enjoy all the wins that we had at Waterston . If I knew better now , I would have enjoyed them a little bit better , because I can't tell you much about wins .
I can tell you a lot about losses . I remember a lot of them . I remember a lot of them Now at Capital . I can tell you about the wins . We haven't had them as many as two . I mean you really appreciate it . I mean , when we got done at Baltimore last year , I really felt , finally we had this made it . It was a good feeling .
You know we were finally able to do something and taking it step by step , you just have to be really patient .
If you could convince three Central Ohio head coaches , past or present , to join your staff at Capitol , who would you pick ?
Do I want to win ? Do I want to win and have a lot of fun ?
That . Those were the two things win and have fun . That's what I was going to say .
You know I don't want to offend anybody , but you know you got guys in high school and I saw these guys last night . Okay , I'm going to get real serious and we're not going to have as much fun , but we're going to be . Because these guys aren't fun , it's just because I'll focus on them . I'll take I can't believe I'm one because I Tom Markert .
You know , in Tangier Horns , central District Hall of Famer last night , ryan Alexander , craig Kyle those guys would be so into it and so serious I could just sit back and watch . Practice would be done All these young guys and it would be done . Stats analytics all these young guys and it would be intense . Now can we have fun ?
Okay , I'm going to have Ray Benjamin , tom Newbert and for somebody to pick on all the time , tim Saunders .
I thought Tim would jump in there at some point , that's for sure .
No , there's so many good coaches , man , and young coaches too . Well , I said the other group , but you know Dave , mike Rance from Delaware and Michael . Slandon and Chris Fugate . There's so many great coaches in Central Ohio so I could pick and choose from a lot of different dudes .
But you asked me I don't know how much I'd ever be home if I had Ray and Tom and Timmy on my side . It probably wouldn't be good for my 37 years of marriage , but we'd have fun .
Yeah , I had the pleasure of being around Tim and Joe Carbone and watching those two play off of each other . That was .
I still have drinks . I have drinks with Tim and Joe and Brian . Thomas and Brian's over helping Tom Newberg out with the scales Between Timmy and Joe . We're working on each other . I'm just like . These two are a piece of work and I enjoy everything on the road .
To me , one of the most memorable things was we were riding a bus at the end of the season and Tim looked back at Joe on the bus and said we're having the banquet tomorrow . We're just going to do a cookout and I need you to be there .
And Joe looked at him and said well , it's actually my 75th birthday and I was kind of going to do something with my family . And he's like ah , you've had 74 of them . He goes you're good , you know , save a little money and come have a hot dog . Yeah .
Oh yeah , I can't imagine . You just didn't have Snickers and Pepsi for the banquet . I did watch that little guy eat three meatballs last night next to me at the Central District Hall of Fame banquet . I told Timmy . I said , man , you're really starting to get crazy .
That's the thing that I don't think parents realize is how much coaches enjoy being around each other .
Yeah , I'll tell you what Baseball coaches are really good . I was always the remember . For the longest time I was the young guy and I would just I would go to the clinics and I would just hover around these dudes , man , and everybody that they would share and the things that we would discuss , and you know the fun we had . It was unbelievable .
So I'll have a hard time missing the clinic because I've learned so much from so many great coaches , on stage , at the bar and then in the rooms , you know , sitting here and talking baseball .
One of the greatest pictures I'll have is sitting in the lounge in the state clinic with Donnie Thorpe from Lakewood and Rich from Florida West Mr Christian , I don't know his name . He was A-Rod's coach , two of the most winning coaches in the country , and I'm just sitting there with my notepad and somebody took a picture of us .
I'm a 42-year-old coach and I'm still , you know , I'm still learning from these guys and we're having a drink . We're having so much fun . Yeah , I've never been in a lot of other clinics , but baseball coaches are the best .
Well , I know you've got things you've got to do and I want to finish up with one last one and I'm going to take a real chance here . You know I don't really say a whole lot about myself as far as the podcast goes , but here's my chance I'm going to take . Go ahead and share your best or funniest story about me .
Usually I'm asking it the other way but something that you shook your head about I still don't . I still have no idea why in the hell you did it . So we have our fall meeting for scheduling of planks . Everybody's eating pizza . Everybody's eating pizza . Everybody's eating stuff .
And what did you order ?
Chicken and noodles , chicken dumplings , yeah , or something yeah , and I'm looking at you like when the hell is he eating chicken , dumplings or whatever at that plank ? Well then , what ?
A week later you're like ready to die and I'm talking to you and you're like , oh , you know , I'm in really bad shape and I'm like , well , you dumbass , you were eating chicken and dumplings at Planks and when you made it and you were okay , then it was really easy to give your shit about that one . So that's really my best one .
Can I tell my second favorite one ? Sure , why not , let's go . So we're going to play a district tournament at Dublin-Coffman and you remember it well , and we won't even use any names of the umpires that did that , but they happened to be from your county and I was really excited because I think I knew who the umpires were and you didn't .
Yet I think Tim told me or something . So we're standing and talking or doing whatever , and here come these two umpires around and I'll never forget the look in your eye like , oh my God , we are screwed . And you were .
Every call went my way and I think TC's in the dugout with me and I'm like , I know this is the district final , but I kind of feel bad for Ken , but I think you brought it all upon yourself .
Yeah , you brought it upon yourself in earlier games , but I'll just never forget those two umpires showing up and the look in your eye was just like my God , we're already playing Water Center and now we got these two guys .
Yeah , it was a huge challenge to begin with .
And every other game had Central District umpires . You know Franklin County . In our game we had umpires from your group of guys that umpired and it was amazing .
I'd be willing to bet that the assigner at that time probably had a little something to do with that too .
Who knows . But , man , I was like the look in your eye was just unbelievable . And then the last thing is the fact that your beloved wife would like talk to me for like two years because we beat you guys and then I had to show up to her somewhere and let her know that I was that bad of a guy , so I think she likes me now .
Well , scott , I can't thank you enough . You've been such a great friend over the years and you never took any mercy on me , just like you say the coaches now at the D3 level are and I wouldn't have had it any other way because I , you know , the memories is what I'll always , you know look back on and wish it could have went some different ways .
But hey , that's life and you know I .
I can't wish you nothing but the best at Capitol . I appreciate it , man . We . Those are good days and I do miss the high school days . But you find out who your friends still are .
You know , and a lot of those guys are all my former high school coaches that we played against and you know there's , like I said , there's so many good coaches around here and what they're doing with their programs are deeply and above levels , you know , with the things they have and the facilities they have and the time that you guys , that high school guys ,
have , man , I'll tell you what they're intense . So I'm still learning . I'm still learning and hopefully I can teach my kids .
All right , Well , thanks again . It's Scott Manahan , head baseball coach at Capital University here in Columbus , Ohio . Scott , thanks again . Take care .
Thanks , Ohio Scott thanks again , Take care . Thanks Ken .
Today's podcast was powered by the Netting Professionals , improving Programs one facility at a time . Contact them today at 844-620-2707 , or visit them online at wwwnettingproscom . As always , I'm your host , coach Ken Carpenter . Thanks for listening to Baseball Coaches Unplugged .
