1950 Broadcaster VS 1953 Telecaster - A Comparison by Nacho Banos - podcast episode cover

1950 Broadcaster VS 1953 Telecaster - A Comparison by Nacho Banos

Mar 19, 202421 minEp. 191
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

To Support the Channel:
Patreon  https://www.patreon.com/AskZac
Tip jar:  https://paypal.me/AskZac
Venmo @AskZac  
Or check out my store for merch  - https://my-store-be0243.creator-spring.com/

Nacho Banos, the patron saint of the Telecaster, compares a 1950 Broadcaster and a 1953 Telecaster backstage at a Brad Paisley concert in Zurich, Switzerland. He takes us fully down the rabbit hole comparing electronics, finish, screws, neck shape, and everything else you can think of.

To dive deeper on this subject, check out Nacho's amazing Pinecaster Book.
https://pinecasterbook.com/

Support the show

Transcript

well hello friends and welcome to ask


0:16

Zack so glad to see y'all again I've


0:18

been out for the last two weeks I was


0:21

out on the road with Brad Paisley I was


0:23

his uh guest along with the great nacho


0:27

BOS and we had a ton of fun talking


0:31

telecasters and so much so that I asked


0:35

nacho if he would do a little comparison


0:38

and so this was filmed backstage in


0:41

Zurich Switzerland and this is nacho


0:46

comparing his July 1953 Telecaster


0:50

against an original broadcaster that


0:52

another friend of mine Olivier alri that


0:54

lives in URI that lives in uh in


0:58

Switzerland he brought to the show for


1:00

us to to look at so from the patron


1:04

saint of the Telecaster nacho BOS you're


1:06

going to get to see and hear a


1:09

comparison between a 53 Telly and a


1:13

broadcaster my only regret on this was


1:15

that you know we just had this little


1:16

backstage area in one of the dressing


1:18

rooms and so we couldn't bring an amp in


1:21

to uh you know hear them but you're


1:22

going to get a really good


1:24

comparison now in thanks for nacho doing


1:27

this uh I'm going to give a plug for his


1:30

book the pinecaster book so this is a uh


1:34

a four volume set that is really the


1:38

Bible for early telecasters um it tells


1:44

this the context of what was going on


1:47

before the broadcaster Telecaster


1:50

Esquire was developed and it tells the


1:52

entire process it shows the prototypes


1:55

the guitars made of pine and such and


1:57

then there's all sorts of pictures of


1:59

black guards and it's amazing for the


2:03

photographs for the stories that are


2:05

told for the context that's given of the


2:08

time and also for the uh the drawings


2:11

and little caricatures that you get from


2:13

uh Billy Gibbons it's an amazing book


2:15

and you should go to pinecaster book.com


2:17

to check it out all right guys here's


2:22

nacho well hello friends you're not


2:25

seeing my face this is the face of Nacho


2:28

BOS and he has a


2:30

broadcaster and we also have my friend


2:34

Olivier URI with lead music in


2:39

Geneva and so we are going to have a


2:42

good time talking about telecasters


2:44

we're going to let nacho give take us to


2:47

school on the differences between this


2:51

broadcaster that uh that is owned by


2:53

Olivier and then we're going to talk


2:55

about this 53 Telly that Olivier is


2:59

holding and uh yeah just kind of the


3:01

evolution that these guitars uh went


3:04

through you know in a in a brief period


3:06

of time all right let's take it away


3:10

nacho so this is Olivier's guitar and um


3:16

it's a I have to say it's a beautiful


3:17

guitar this number


3:20

0725 I'm I'm guessing it's a November


3:24

1950 um because of the the way of the


3:28

body the finish and


3:30

um the neck shape


3:33

and and the you know


3:38

um the the looks of the of the of the


3:41

finish in general um it's a I would say


3:46

it's a very light guitar for being a


3:48

broadcaster I would I would be surprised


3:51

if this thing is over 7 PBS it will be


3:53

most likely six and something MH yeah


3:55

absolutely um the neck is a typical


3:58

November um guitar is more of a uh


4:01

medium D you know I would say be kind of


4:05

like


4:07

a 85 86 on the on the first fret uh it's


4:13

been refed which is good news because


4:16

you you can play it and it's a great


4:17

sound and and great playing instrument


4:20

um and it's it's got the typical you


4:23

know features of a of a broadcaster has


4:25

get um what I'm I'm we haven't plugged


4:29

it in but I'm going to assume this is a


4:31

very powerful oh yeah it


4:34

is um the finish on this guitar is the


4:37

typical November of 1950 which is a


4:42

very um brittle um and it's um it's thin


4:48

and it looks as if doesn't have any real


4:52

undercoat so if I were Olivier I


4:57

wouldn't play this guitar in Spain


4:58

during summertime


5:00

because the


5:02

sweat would destroy the finish and you


5:05

would be flagging all over uh with your


5:08

arm and you know uh it would it wouldn't


5:11

be blond anymore uh and some of them


5:14

Parts but you know other than that it's


5:17

a I think it's a beautiful condition um


5:20

it's got you know the tall knobs I'm


5:23

going to say it's it's got the blend


5:24

control uh um you know the to


5:30

guard it one half the diagonal route


5:34

here has got brass


5:36

Saddles and um you know all of the


5:39

screws are going to be uh Sloe head on


5:42

the back you see


5:45

how uh the ferles uh are not aligned so


5:49

that means that they were uh drilled


5:51

from the top and you know you can see


5:54

some it's a little funny that's that was


5:56

a question I had for you because I've uh


5:58

yeah were they drilled from the bottom


6:00

or the


6:01

top I I guess they were they were


6:04

drilled from from from the top without


6:07

having any any type of template each at


6:10

a time yeah each each one a time so


6:12

that's why it's not align if if you use


6:15

kind of like a template then they will


6:17

all go makes it better yeah and um of


6:21

course you know we have


6:22

the the broadcaster decal and uh and the


6:27

um the Clos shell tuners with Clos and


6:31

blocks PN apply on the on the


6:33

back


6:35

um this is


6:38

um the pots I'm going to guess are 304


6:41

stock pole um it would be 304 Z


6:46

something uh from 1950 it's got the


6:50

um the early style uh Jack


6:55

cap and um yeah you know it's a I think


7:00

it's a perfect example of a 1950


7:03

broadcaster it's a beautiful I like we


7:05

were talking about this before but I


7:07

really like how the finish on this or


7:11

the guitars is so complex because you


7:14

get so many different colors in one in


7:17

one single place you got you know some


7:20

some is darker some is more butter


7:22

scotchy you know some you got different


7:25

tones here different color here you know


7:28

here's total


7:30

different um on the sides you you get


7:33

you know different shade so it's very


7:35

very threedimensional looking it's never


7:39

a single color blonde uh finish which is


7:43

why it's so hard to replicate these


7:46

guitars and when you get to the worn out


7:48

areas like this you always get that


7:50

barewood and then a little lighter


7:53

collar and then there starts to get Dark


7:56

Water


7:57

Scotch it's a Beau with her I'm in love


8:00

I'm sorry yeah I think I'm going to take


8:02

it home me just


8:05

thing j is a nice place to stay you I


8:08

can stay


8:13

here it is a it is a gorgeous guitar


8:15

nacho it's a beautiful guitar I'm so


8:17

happy it yeah it's a it's a sickness oh


8:20

yeah it's a pleas I'm really appreciate


8:22

let's let's switch over to the uh unless


8:24

you have something else to say let's


8:25

talk about the 53 I um I think it's uh


8:30

you know you guys want to say something


8:31

else or ask any questions but I think


8:34

this is you know it's a perfect it's a


8:36

perfect practice what do you what do you


8:38

think is the sound difference with the


8:41

broad in just in general between the


8:43

broadcaster pickup and the pickup that


8:45

you that you would get in the 53 well


8:48

the construction of this pickup is


8:50

different because it's got It's got the


8:52

thinner wire and um in order to get the


8:57

body of a pickup that would do mortal


8:59

violence so it's a harder to pick up and


9:03

um you know um some you know we did the


9:08

research on the magnets and we found


9:11

that most of the ear guitars instead of


9:13

having onco fives would have the larger


9:18

diameter um po 195 Ono 3s or on e3s


9:23

don't have


9:24

Cobalt so that would give this sound


9:30

a different quality and the different


9:32

quality would be it would be a more kind


9:35

of like maybe a TD darker


9:38

sound uh more powerful you know um um


9:43

rounded off town maybe less um twangy


9:48

um um it it you know it will still be


9:53

the you know a great blood guard sound


9:56

but it will be um um


9:59

different from from a later lard in that


10:02

sense because that the construction of


10:04

this pickup was was a little different


10:07

yeah switch to the 53 we're going to


10:10

have the the careful handoff let's let's


10:12

make sure everyone's really careful this


10:14

is the most expensive


10:17

trade and and this is Nacho's guitar


10:20

okay this is his 53 yeah this is I don't


10:23

even know the s number but


10:27

2241 yeah this guitar is a 53 is to me


10:30

this is like another perfect time for


10:33

Fender is a July


10:36

1953 that's very specific which is very


10:40

specific for this this is the type of


10:42

neck that everybody likes to say like to


10:47

refer to as a baseball bat but it's it's


10:51

a large neck I'm I'm I don't remember


10:54

this by heart but I'm going to guess


10:57

this is over 90 uh 0 90 on the on the


11:00

first fret which may sound like a a fat


11:03

neck and it is a fat neck but it's so


11:07

comfortable the way uh ttio would shave


11:11

the back of a neck they you know the


11:13

shoulders on the back are like very


11:16

defined you know very subtle so it's a


11:19

nice grip uh it feels great and you get


11:22

a lot of tone because you got a lot of


11:24

mass in the wind mass in the neck so um


11:29

you know this um this is another great


11:32

example of a of a great year for for a


11:36

blood guard so here we have as you can


11:39

see you know the finish on this guitar


11:40

is totally different from that guitar


11:42

not even the color but how the finish is


11:45

is is applied and this buildup you know


11:48

here we have like the desert


11:51

sand undercoat which is which is like


11:54

makes the Finish look a lot flatter than


11:58

than that one and it's more stable so so


12:01

basically we have you know we have like


12:04

uh what they do here they they seal the


12:06

wood then they will apply the theer sand


12:09

then they would do the blonde and then


12:11

they would do a clear coat so um um so


12:14

you can play it in Spain I can play it


12:17

in summertime and um and somebody played


12:21

it you know cuz there's a there's a lot


12:23

of buckle wear here um but it is kind of


12:27

like what we were talking about the


12:29

blond finishes from this era it's kind


12:30

of like the same principle like you get


12:32

a lot of different shades and a lot of


12:35

different it's so three-dimensional you


12:38

have different colors here there there


12:42

there you know it's it changes uh and


12:46

it's beautiful in that sense um this


12:49

guitar is U the the only thing that was


12:51

changed in this guitar when I got it


12:54

many years ago was that the


12:57

fretboard had the plan


12:59

and uh it was it had been refereed so um


13:02

the guitar didn't look that bright


13:05

because it had a shiny looking new


13:07

looking


13:08

fretboard um so I what I did is I added


13:11

the um the grooves um the finger board


13:15

where uh to make it look a little better


13:17

but other than that you know it's the


13:19

Frets are perfect they're a little


13:22

they're not the Vintage uh size of Frets


13:24

but they maybe like medium I don't know


13:27

I haven't measured them but um the


13:29

pickups are original the everything


13:31

under here is original so it's got the


13:33

uh the second generation wiring which is


13:36

is not the blend control like that


13:38

guitar so um here you have a tone


13:41

control so you can here you know you


13:44

have a tone control on all three


13:46

positions and you you know and you can


13:49

see combine both pickups if you live the


13:52

uh the switch in the middle but it


13:54

that's not going to stay so so here you


13:57

have U this pickup with with a tone this


14:01

this pickup with a tone and here you


14:03

have the the cap with the with the neck


14:06

pickup why did the the scratch plates on


14:10

on these guitars look very different was


14:12

the finishing process different at that


14:15

point or you know again is that just is


14:17

that just the wear difference and we got


14:19

a little glare going on but I'm going to


14:20

look at that and we're going to try to


14:24

well this you


14:27

know Fender I think was getting folic


14:30

paper from from whoever was was making


14:35

it and and and I'm I'm pretty sure that


14:39

he was getting whatever they would


14:40

deliver so over the years um it doesn't


14:45

some of the phenolic paper that they


14:47

were getting was more of a


14:50

uh uh


14:53

plasticy feel and look you know it would


14:55

it would be more more less of a five


14:59

fiber and more of a plastic right and uh


15:02

the first um the broadcasters that the


15:05

very first ones from October


15:08

1950 don't even have any ler on top so


15:12

and it's a very different uh uh phenolic


15:16

uh


15:17

paper it's a shiny it's a very shiny uh


15:21

paper and then on this guitar this is um


15:24

this is very you know it's different


15:26

from that one and this is you know this


15:28

spot is something that's you know kind


15:30

of hard to replicate and kind of


15:32

something that you see from that era


15:33

guitar also yeah it's


15:37

U yeah it's got uh again you know this


15:41

is paper pressed with


15:45

um um with some kind of of plastic you


15:50

know so it's uh it's they call it's a


15:54

it's a bake light but it's a it's a it's


15:58

a compress


15:59

paper with oh so those are the light the


16:02

layers you see here yeah


16:05

yeah um so you know again we have the


16:10

the Saddles here with the brass but on


16:12

this guitar it's different than that


16:14

that that guitar cuz they are noted on


16:17

the on


16:18

the on the high e and on on the low E


16:21

and the high string I don't know if you


16:23

can get that with the camera but but in


16:26

order to get a lower action Leo would uh


16:31

with add a notch on the on the back side


16:35

of the of the saddle so you can lower it


16:38

down


16:41

further and um the knobs


16:44

are kind of like shorter and they have a


16:48

different Dome


16:49

shape this is different too this is uh


16:53

kind of like the second


16:54

version U the broadcaster verion version


16:57

is open on the top this is


17:00

closed um as you can see here you know


17:03

there's a mix of U Phillips and and


17:07

Flathead screws um the broadcasters got


17:10

all of them are Flathead screws but on


17:13

this guitar everything is Phillips but


17:17

the switch


17:22

and yeah the switch everything else is


17:27

Phillips um the 2 ERS are different this


17:30

is open shell um no


17:33

brand um CL and Tuners which is where I


17:36

came


17:37

in early I would say spring of


17:43

1952 and uh yeah I um you know very


17:48

similar guitars but very different


17:50

guitars can you hold both of them


17:53

carefully or bring them in close so


17:56

people can kind of this is this is


17:58

lighter than this


18:00

one


18:04

um they they have different


18:07

personalities but they're both great


18:10

yeah I appreciate you uh giving us a


18:13

little uh his history in a comparison


18:16

you know again we're we're backstage at


18:18

a at a at a concert hall in zurk


18:22

Switzerland and uh it just such a a


18:25

prize to have you know these two you


18:28

know cool guitars here so I had to take


18:31

the opportunity to uh pester nacho into


18:34

uh talking a little bit so are you still


18:36

selling the pinecaster book yes I am


18:39

okay that is an amazing book that if you


18:41

have any level of Interest any serious


18:44

interest in the book you need to check


18:46

that out and that's pinecaster decom yes


18:48

sir yes there's pinecaster book or just


18:50

pinecaster pinecaster pinecaster book


18:53

pinecaster book.com yeah and Olivier of


18:56

course has lead music in in Geneva


18:59

really appreciate him uh letting us look


19:01

at his broadcaster so it's a pleasure


19:04

really you know and we got some hint as


19:07

well so that's really interesting yes


19:09

really appreciate yeah he G he gave us a


19:11

little bit of a little he gave away a


19:12

little bit of the magic just a little


19:14

bit but not too much thank you nacho


19:17

thank you guys thank you so much for


19:19

watching uh I need to thank my uh


19:21

patreon members that really make this


19:23

show possible you are the best and uh if


19:27

you want to find out more you can go


19:29

down in the description there's a link


19:31

there uh also again I need to thank


19:33

nacho and I need to thank uh Olivier URI


19:36

for uh you know bringing his broadcaster


19:39

the show in Zurich and of course to Brad


19:41

Paisley for uh letting me ride on the uh


19:45

on the train so thanks


19:49

[Music]


19:51

[Applause]


19:54

[Music]


19:57

bye-bye

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android