Are You My Podcast?

Sarah Colonna & Mary Radzinski•are-you-my-podcast.simplecast.com

Comedians Sarah Colonna and Mary Radzinski laugh their way through trending topics, pop culture, and entertainment — peppering in personal stories along the way. And yes, they're obsessed with Married at First Sight.

Last refreshed: July 28th, 2025 at 5:29 PM ⓘ

Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.

Follow on

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

RSS

Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app

Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Right Tracksuit, Wrong Friend (Lifetime Movie)

In Lifetime's “The Wrong Fiancé,” Mary concludes that Abby is a garbage human being and not even worthy of stalking. Sarah questions small town law enforcement practices, smartphone fonts and where on earth she can get Vivica A. Fox’s tracksuit—because it’s amazing. Without ever having been shot in the leg, both Sarah and Mary agree that they’d handle it better than Richard did. Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us on Twitter , Instagram , and Facebook . sarahcol...

Jan 12, 2021•1 hr 18 min

Creeping Toms (Lifetime Movie)

Due to Charles's ill-fitting suits in “The Wrong Real Estate Agent", Sarah becomes suspicious of Lifetime’s wardrobe budget. Mary is in awe of Julie’s impeccable moisturizing regimen and stylish jammie game, plus Sarah wows Mary with her detailed knowledge of raccoon grooming habits. The main character's grasp of common sense is repeatedly called into question—and neither Sarah nor Mary can be bothered to find out if a vole is a real animal or not. Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you get yo...

Jan 05, 2021•1 hr 13 min

Loathe Thy Neighbor (Lifetime Movie)

In this week's episode, the Lifetime Movie, “The Baby Stealer.” Sarah is perplexed by Peter’s dependence on a clock radio, which—along with his mother’s use of a boombox—indicates these characters are from the 90’s. Mary is shook by the idea of someone taking her phone away, and questions when, if ever, she’d call 911. They both lose their patience calling out several plot points that go absolutely nowhere. Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us on Twitter , Instag...

Dec 29, 2020•59 min

Screw Your Matching Pajamas (Lifetime Movie)

'Tis the season for Lifetime's “A Christmas Break". Sarah thinks the enthusiasm and dedication of “Hollywood Dylan’s” manager, Garth, is completely unrealistic – or is it just that all of Sarah’s managers have been lazy? Mary is (rightfully) furious with the poor execution of the middle school play. Both Sarah and Mary confuse middle school and high school throughout the entire movie and – as it turns out – it doesn’t make a bit of difference. Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you get your po...

Dec 25, 2020•1 hr 6 min

When Your Mom’s A LOT (Lifetime Movie)

Sarah struggles to make a few plot connections in Lifetime's “Pretty Little Dead Girl” and is not happy with how the “detectives” handled their crap investigation, she then loses focus and shares some hot bartending tips. Mary scoffs at debate clubs and wonders if Emma might have benefited more from a personality transplant than a new heart. They both agree that the mom is shady and the dad’s a doofus, but whatever -- everyone deserves love. We suppose. Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you g...

Dec 22, 2020•1 hr 25 min

Kentucky Fried WTF (Lifetime Movie)

Who knew that Lifetime's fifteen minute drama, “Recipe for Seduction,” starring Mario Lopez as a young Harland Sanders, could stir up so much conversation? Villainous moms, croutons, a bizarre sweater, and an obsession with Pizza Hut are just a few topics of discussion. A full circle “aha” moment is one for the history books. Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us on Twitter , Instagram , and Facebook . sarahcolonna.com maryradzinski.com © 2020 Are You My Podcast?...

Dec 15, 2020•48 min

Chad Michael McConaughey (Lifetime Movie)

Some family dynamics and shoddy plot lines in “Too Close for Christmas” cause Sarah to lose patience with Paul. Squinting, hooking up at weddings, and whittling (yes, WHITTLING) are just a few topics discussed. Mary misses a big theme presented in the movie, but this is a surprise to no one. Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us on Twitter , Instagram , and Facebook . sarahcolonna.com maryradzinski.com © 2020 Are You My Podcast?...

Dec 08, 2020•1 hr 5 min

Double Bed or Double Beds? (Lifetime Movie)

Lots to unpack in People's "Once Upon a Main Street", including: good looks, bad personalities, estranged daughters, and rivaling towns. Mary has a bone to pick with Amelia’s sense of entitlement and Sarah is concerned about Vic’s day job(s). Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us on Twitter , Instagram , and Facebook . sarahcolonna.com maryradzinski.com © 2020 Are You My Podcast?...

Dec 08, 2020•1 hr

Phoebe Sucks (Lifetime Movie)

Mary’s loathing of the main character, Phoebe, in Lifetime's Christmas movie “Candy Cane Lane” is borderline obsessive while Sarah’s reminded of some less than ideal situations she’s experienced at a vet’s office, causing her to question Eric’s sanity. Subscribe, like, and review—wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us on Twitter , Instagram , and Facebook . sarahcolonna.com maryradzinski.com © 2020 Are You My Podcast?...

Dec 08, 2020•53 min

← Prev

For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android