Welcome to Questions from the Closet. I'm Ben Schilaty.
And I'm Charlie Bird. Each episode we discuss the question that we commonly get asked as LGBTQ Latter-day Saints.
We're not trying to answer this question or come to a consensus but simply sharing our perspectives.
Today's question is, what should my pronouns be?
Charlie and I are not terribly diverse. We share many opinions and life experiences. For example, we both like to dance.
However, there are some pretty big differences. For example, I prefer a more raunchy hip hop style and Ben is currently taking a tap class.
Yeah, it's actually really fun. So one of my good friends has moved back here from New York with her husband, and he's in business school. And so he's very busy. And she works from home and she's like Ben, we have to take a class. I'm gonna be so bored. And she said, How about a tap class? I said, Yes, let's take a tap class. We're taking a six week tap class through UVU continuing education, and it has been incredibly fun.
I can't wait to not go to your performances.
We have zero performances so your wish is granted.
I went to a Dirty Dancing class once at the Vasa gym and I was really good.
I actually went to that same class like two years ago, some of my colleagues from the social work program, and afterwards, they're like how'd you like it? I was like, that's a thing that happened. And I felt very uncomfortable. Yeah. Anyway, we would like to provide a variety of voices and perspectives. So today, we're joined by Marina.
Hello.
Tell us a little bit about yourself, Marina.
I am a BYU student, film major. I play guitar. I'm a creative person. I'm also trans.
We should have you make a film of yourself playing the guitar about what it's like to be trans.
Yes!
We could put it as like a promo on the Instagram feed.
That would have been amazing. I should have done that.
We could have included all of your creative sides.
Exactly.
Yeah, well, Rina, one thing that Charlie and I have been talking about for a while, is we have not had a lot of trans voices on the podcast. And that's something that we want to do more of. And we're very grateful that you were willing to be on just talking about your experiences and perspectives with us.
Absolutely. Thanks for having me. I appreciate it.
Yeah. So today, we're talking about pronouns. So if you just help us understand what led you to choose what your pronoun should be, or how you came to that decision?
Yeah, so it's really complicated. And weird for me, because I identify as a non-binary trans woman. So the way I like to explain it is that I identify more with the one pole of this sort of idea of womanhood, femininity, but I'm also slightly more androgynous, leaning masculine, sometimes. I wanted to use, currently she/her/hers pronouns, because I think that's helpful to me. I don't think I necessarily have to communicate all of the nuances of my identity all the
time. You know, and I think that's easier, perhaps easier to, for other people to understand. So you would say like saying, man or woman, you find yourself in a space that's much more complex than just those two binaries? Yes, I identify more as a woman than as a man, but it's more, there's more wiggle room and space. I'm definitely not day to day life, saying, Oh, I'm a man and feel like a man today. You know, I definitely identify solidly in one side of if you are looking at it as a spectrum.
But the, it's that pull plus some more...
It moves within that side of the spectrum.
Yes.
Okay.
Absolutely.
And what led you to start using female pronouns. Like when did that happen? Just walk us through that. Yeah. So for the longest time, you know, I've been, I was in denial about my, my identity. And so I thought from an early age, as soon, when I discovered that trans people were a thing I said, "Oh, you know, that's so cool. That couldn't be me." Right? You know, that wasn't a thing and option for me. But then over time, I sort of started to realize, okay, well,
maybe this is true about me. But I didn't have a grasp on it or what it meant. And I felt it early on more non-binary, not identifying as a woman. So I initially thought, well, maybe I should use they/them pronouns, but then later, there was sort of, I guess some gender euphoria, I suppose, thinking of myself as a woman and having this sort of wiggle room. So then I decided for both, because, you know, I just like how it felt when people used she/her/hers pronouns for me.
And that I thought it was kind of easier to describe my situation. That way. That's how I decided. So Marina you used an interesting term gender euphoria.
Yes.
And I've heard of gender dysphoria, which is the discomfort someone feels. And so you're saying that this was like the opposite of discomfort? This was a good, pleasant feeling.
Yes, it was a good, it was a good vibe. You know, I, I felt like things made sense in that way.
I'm interested that you said that you're using female pronouns for now. And it sounds like in the process of deciding which pronouns to use and what you're most comfortable with, as you've explored and thought about yourself and opened your mind to different options, you kind of like settle on different things, and different words, or labels have felt better at different times in your life.
Yeah, yeah, for sure. I feel that way about names too where I, I picked a name when I was 19. Going to college, I wanted to reinvent myself, I was gonna be JoJo, right? Over time, you know, now, I'm, I'm much, I'm older, I have different life experiences. And I'm saying to myself, well, you know, I really shouldn't be beholden to my 18 year old, you know, 18,19 year old self, and what she thought about the world, right, and herself. So I decided recently
that I would go by Marina. And that's a lot more fulfilling euphoric to me. And I feel that it's the same thing with labels too. Like, I don't, I don't think it has to be something you necessarily pick once and stick with it. You know, if you ever feel the need to change. Yeah. And I think that's, a that's a really gracious way to look at yourself, and everyone else, like we're all trying to figure out who we are and learning things about ourselves and what, what feels right and
what fits best. As we've been asking these questions I've been thinking about if someone said, Ben, when did you choose to be gay? Or like, when did you decide you were gay? And those questions feel a little abrasive to me.
Yeah.
So when we're talking about pronouns, is it appropriate to say like, when did you like, how did you choose? Or how do you decide? Is that the right question? Is that rude?
I don't, I don't think so. I don't think it's a rude question. When you're talking about these sorts of things it depends on the time and the place and the person. For instance, it's, it's weird, it might be weird in a, you know, the context of a big group gathering or something where there's a lot of people or something that might be a kind of, on the spot, uncomfortable sort of thing where there might be this kind of social pressure.
I think if it's just one on one, or you know, in a smaller group, more intimate setting, I don't think that it's a rude question. I think a lot of the times trans people are thinking about this often and interested in it. So I think in the, you know, in this case, they might, you know, we might think, Oh, it's cool, you know, they want to know about me, right? What does it feel like when someone talks about you using the wrong pronoun?
Shocking. It's kind of a jolt. I can tell when people are making an honest mistake. And when they are trying to be malicious about it. When people mess up it's jarring and jolting and can be frustrating because it feels like they're not taking me seriously, or my identity, or my feelings about myself, my reality. I can usually point out, hey, you know, he misgendered me or they will catch themselves. And we can just move on, you know, quickly, we correct, correct it and move
on. What's hard for me is when we kind of stay in that moment, for too long, where they feel the need to like really apologize, like it's this giant thing. Like it is this shocking thing that bothers me but what bothers me more is the whole moment. You know, it's not necessarily that it happened or it's, it's staying In that
awkward space. So then they if people kind of feel the need to really apologize and make it this giant thing it feels to me like, somehow I have done something wrong, you know, when I haven't, you know, because it's like, Ah, now I have to, you know, I have to forgive this person, right, of this thing that I don't think should be that big of a deal. Yeah, I remember, Marina at one time, I was having dinner at your parents house. And I remember your, your mom
misgendered you. And I just remembered seeing your incredible graciousness with that. I think I even did that same night. And you were just always really gracious and I and thank you for for sharing that, that we don't need to make these big apologies or it's just don't live in that moment. It's a mistake for sure. Let's move on.
Kind of on the flip side of that, what does it feel like when someone talks about you using the correct pronouns?
Ummm most of the time. I don't notice. That's kind of what I was getting at. Does it feel like good? Or does it just feel normal? It feels normal. Um, I think sometimes when, especially if that person is prone to making the mistake of you know, misgendering me, right? It can be this sort of quiet, peaceful moment where I'm like, oh, this person is really, you know, trying really cares. And it's just nice and normal and warm. And I like that sort of feeling
of normality. Like I just a lot of the trans experience is about trying to achieve normality in our lives. You know, whether it feels like everything is kind of upended and weird. And there's o many things in our way, and hings that are hard and ifficult. And so when something s just normal, and it feels ike I can have a normal day, ou know, it's wonderful. You know, I don't know where
it's like to be misgendered. I think the closest parallel I can find is, when I was on my mission, I was Elder Schilaty. Every once in a while someone would, you know, want to know what my first name was? And I would sometimes tell them, and they were like, insist on calling me by my first name. I'm like, No, no, no, no, no, like, call me Elder Schilaty. And then when I got home and people that I like know and love called me, Ben. I hadn't been called Ben
for two years. It just like felt like home. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I completely understand that too. Yeah. I'm kind of trying to think back on my first exposure to the trans community. And it was around the same time I started getting involved in like, LGBTQ things. So kind of like, as I was coming out, I was meeting more people and gaining more education, and exposure to different walks of life and different people. And I remember going to this conference once.
And we had to write our names on like, a name tag, and then put our pronouns on it. And initially, I was like, Why? I was like, what? That's, that's weird. I've never had to do this before. I was like, okay, whatever. Like he/him/his, it's kind of obvious. You know, that's kind of the mindset I was in. I was thinking about that
experience. And then at the same time, as we were preparing for this episode, I thought about once when I was at BYU, and it was before I'd come out, and I was scared, I felt unsure of myself. And I was walking by just down the hallway. And I saw outside of one of the professor's offices, she'd put like a little rainbow sticker that said, safe space. And I just really needed to talk to someone. So I knocked on her door. And she opened it up and was like, Hi, come in, strange
student. And I sat down with her. And I was like, I saw your sticker. I'm gay. And I just kind of like, unloaded on her. And I really needed that experience. And we talked and her doing that one, like, seemingly not a big deal thing, really had an influence on the way I felt accepted. And the way that I felt like I really did
have a safe space. And I kind of was drawing a parallel between those two things of just me, perhaps at this conference, having my pronouns written underneath my name, gave someone else a safe space and made them feel like you're welcome here. We want to know more about you. You're not in any danger. And we're glad you're here. As I thought about it that way. I was like, really grateful that like, a couple years ago, me was like, You know what, even though I think this is weird, I will put
these pronouns on. And I think if we can all have that mindset going forward, is, like even if something's you know, foreign or feels weird, or you don't really know why it's important, as we realize that it is important to somebody else, to somebody else, then we can just build a better community.
So Marina, when people introduce themselves, would you prefer that we would introduce ourselves with our pronouns?
First, first off, I think, yes, it would be so cool. If just everyone would just introduce themselves, names and pronouns. That way we all know, you know what ground we're on, you know, who's who, what's up. I think if we can move towards that communities and just the world will be better, right? At certain times, though, there's this way in which people don't feel safe in a space, even if we are sharing our pronouns, right?
So I think, what the expectation should be is that when we introduce ourselves, you know, allies should totally pronoun, you know, like, like, we should just normalize the practice of giving pronouns out, right. But sometimes, you know, I've been in situations where it's, like, weird, and I don't necessarily feel safe, or, and it would feel weird in that situation to kind of to out myself, right. So yeah, I don't know, I'm of two minds about it. You know?
That's tricky. Like, like, let's normalize this experience of introducing ourselves with our pronouns. Then if we're requiring that of people, then you're putting them in a position where they have decided they're gonna be out in that moment.
For sure, yeah. Right.
It's interesting, because Charlie said, you know, I don't think about introducing myself with my pronouns, because I feel like, obviously, I'm male. And, and I think that just comes from my my cisgender privilege. And as we're talking, I'm thinking, maybe I should put that in my email signature. One thing that I was thinking, as I thought about this is when I'm using someone's pronouns, you know, I'm speaking directly to you, I'm using, you know, second
person pronouns. And so when I'm using third person pronouns, it's usually when I'm talking about the person and not to the person, so they often have no idea that I'm using the correct pronouns or not. As I've gotten to know the trans community more, I've become more aware of the respect that it shows to use someone's preferred pronouns, even when they're not in the room. Yes. Sometimes, you know, in my situation, until very recently, I was not out, but I was out
with particular people. So in those situations, I would have conversations, one on one with people, and they would come to me and ask me, you know, what pronoun should I use? What should I, you know, should I tell, should I tell people, you know, should I use these pronouns when I'm talking about you? In certain situations I would say no, like, I think it's just good for you to know who I am. So we can talk. So we can have this space, this friendship, this connection,
right? But I don't think that's necessarily something that we need to share with the world, right? But now, I'm more out. So it's less of, in my case now, it's less of a big deal. I would just, rather than having to have the conversation with every single person coming out constantly, you know, if people can just say, "Oh, yeah, you know, Marina, she's doing great", right? That is this very nice thing for me.
What would you say to someone who, who, because their belief system, they believe that there are two genders, there's male and female, and your gender is, is congruent with your sex assigned at birth? You know, what would you say to someone who believes that way? Who is wondering, well, would it be against my beliefs if I, if I use a trans person's preferred pronouns?
When I think about Jesus Christ, I think about a man, a person, the Son of God, right, who was just kind and loving and understanding of all people, right, no matter who they were, what they, what they did, you know? He was not spending his time with the most educated, the most wealthy, you know, the people, the kind of things we prioritize here on Earth, right? I think that Jesus would use the right pronouns. Like that's just honestly, that is, I mean, that's my own sort of, warm,
fuzzy feeling about it. And this, the way I have felt God affirming my gender. So I don't feel like it's incongruous, what we should prioritize as being kind and loving, to all people. Right? You know, and once again, this isn't, these aren't parallels but but I remember when President Nelson asked us to stop using the term Mormon and Mormon church and say, members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and Latter-day Saints, and there are a lot of people who don't think
we're Christians. And here we're saying, call us members of the Church of Jesus Christ. And that might be, that might not fit with how they view us. I remember a number, a number of my friends who aren't members of the church started using the term Latter-day Saint because I said, you know, I'm referring to myself as a Latter-day saint now, and not as a Mormon. And it just, it was just really meaningful to me, when people were willing to change how I labeled myself, because I had asked them to.
For sure, there's a level of respect.
When I started writing my book, that's kind of when this change happened. And I was like, oh, gosh, that makes it so much more difficult. Because before I could just say the word Mormon, and then it would like, convey everything, and it's a short word. It's packaged. It's very nice. I was like, Oh, it's gonna be so much more difficult for me to write about this, and
so much more wordier. And, again, like, I don't want to make a direct parallel, because you can't, but in a way, like, if it's harder to use the correct pronouns, you have to think about it more. Like, it means you're doing something meaningful for that person, and you're doing a good thing. And I think it's really amazing. Like, that's what charity is right giving of ourselves, and going the extra mile, to accommodate, to love, to show support and respect for another person.
For sure, the hard things are the things that are probably worth doing.
I remember some of my friends who identify as non-binary who used they/them/theirs pronouns. It was hard for me. Like it used, it took mental energy, for me and I, and at first I kind of like rolled my eyes, but then, you know, like us, were saying, you know, that that's kindness and respect, kind of won out, and I've thought, if I feel uncomfortable, whatever I'm going to do the thing that the person's asked me to do.
As a gay person, I see evidence in my daily life that I don't fit in, right, that there's things about me that go against the grain, that provide friction for people, that other people don't sit well with. And I think, as a trans person, there must be so much more of that. Right? Like it's everywhere. And because I'm thinking about even the way you are talked to and talked about, can either connote a sense of acceptance or
rejection. I was recently going through like, suicide rates for LGBTQ individuals, and comparing, you know, gay males versus bisexual females, and transgender males. And almost every study, in every case, transgender individuals have a higher risk of depression, and anxiety and suicide. And to me, it just kind of makes sense, because there's so much social pressure, and social messaging that says, You don't belong here
you don't fit in. And so just the simple act of using your words, using a correct pronoun, to bring someone into your fold to say, "You can be on my team. You can sit next to me. We can be together." Like think of what that could do to someone who maybe is struggling with some of these really difficult feelings of depression and loneliness and
anxiety. And to just use something simple as to say he, or she, instead of he or she, or them, and you know, just a simple pronoun can make a huge difference in someone's seeing that they have space.
Absolutely.
So what would you say to someone who's saying, I don't really know how to identify I'm not sure which pronouns to use? I would say, try them out. And then you know, see how they feel. See how other people you know, respond to that. And how, how, how it makes you feel when they use those pronouns for you. And then if you don't like the way that those pronouns feel, choose different ones, you know,
use any pronouns you want. I guess just as a final message to people who are listening, if you are questioning your identity, questioning if you should be using different pronouns, know that you are valid and loved and that it's a process. It's not something that you immediately try once and are perfect at and understand completely. It's
always a process. And I think it's important to find joy in the process of finding yourself out and realizing that you've taken steps forward toward a better you. And Marina as we've been talking, I'm just realizing my, my cisgender privilege that I have never even considered my pronouns are, because everything just fits.
Yeah.
Always has. And so just thank you so much for sharing your story, and your wisdom with us and we really appreciate being on.
Thank you for having me.
Thank you for joining us today. If you have enjoyed this or other episodes, please consider leaving us an apple podcast review. And as always, please remember that we do not represent the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints or Brigham Young University. We are not trying to be prescriptive or tell anyone what to think or what to do.
You heard three perspectives and there are many, many more. We encourage you to listen to other voices in here a wide variety of experiences. If you would like to submit a question or share a comment about today's episode, you can email us at questionsfromthecloset@gmail.com. Until next time.
