In Which Murderer’s Episode 5 Season 5 the girls talk about Divorce Murders - tricky to navigate! Holly starts you off with Irene Paterson before Mel tells you about the massive case of Broderick v. Broderick. Shoutout to Natalie for the awesome theme suggestion! Also to our Facebook followers for some hilarious discussions - especially surrounding clowns. The girls talk about drinks and Holly’s Starbucks obsession in a very judgemental way, Mel entertains Holly with her attempts to make sentenc...
Jul 15, 2022•32 min•Season 5Ep. 5
In Which Murderer’s Episode 4 Season 5 the girls talk about Murder for Survival cases. Mels starts off with the tragic tale of Valerie Bacot before Holly takes you back in time to the tale of Richard Parker and the code of the seafarers. Shoutouts to Natalie for the awesome theme suggestion and Michelle for the A+ supply of puppy and dog photos. It’s Rosie the dog’s birthday and the girls tell you all about her digestive system (you’re welcome), there is some confusion surrounding goats but the ...
Jul 08, 2022•34 min•Season 5Ep. 4
In Which Murderer’s Episode 3 Season 5 the girls talk about Online Dating Murders. Holly is first (which she forgets) and tells you about the disturbed killer Carl Langdell before Mel tells you all about Khalil Wheeler Weaver - which you absolutely cannot say five times fast. Shoutouts to the mystery review leaver who used a phrase that made the girls research mid-recording and grow at least 2 brain cells. Also to Caitlin for the fabulous suggestion!!! Holly tells you all about her first encount...
Jul 01, 2022•35 min•Season 5Ep. 3
In Which Murderer’s Episode 2 Season 5 the girls take a listener suggestion and cover Bus Driver Murders. Mel starts you off with the story of Darren Vickers before Holly tells you about Keith Bettison. Shoutouts to Jim who suggested this week’s topic and took Holly’s flagrant competitive challenging with grace (turns out she is not the F1 driver she thought), Cheryl for some good sleep advice and Carrie for telling Mel she said a super challenging medical word correctly. A special shoutout to K...
Jun 24, 2022•39 min•Season 5Ep. 2
The first episode of Season 5 brings you Murders Solved by Dogs! Holly kicks things off with the story of Shantay Leann Leyba-Huntington before Mel tells you about Duane Daniels who had quite the racket going in London. Shoutouts to Kristy who suggested this topic (which was loved by the girls!) and Natalie for epic memeing. This episode brings you more pathetic maths, Holly explains the perils of dash cams and dying while singing Disney tunes, apologies are made to Miami (Welcome to Miami) by m...
Jun 17, 2022•37 min•Season 5Ep. 1
In Season 4 Episode 52, the final episode of Season 4, the girls talk about European Murders. Mel kicks this special episode off with her case covering Ivan Kulesh before Holly tells you about Joachim Kroll. Shoutouts to Kirsty and Millie the Cat who submitted a great theme suggestion! The end of Mel’s first season brings you a very determined Mel still holding on tight to her Strictly Come Dancing dreams, Holly being dead inside and emotionless about the end of the season, Mel potentially becom...
Jun 10, 2022•32 min
In Season 4 Episode 51, the penultimate Season 4 episode, the girls talk about City Murders following on from last week’s Countryside Murder theme. Chester, UK and New York, USA! Holly starts us off with the insane story of Sadie Catherine Cook before Mel tells you about the famous case of Kitty Genovese. Shoutouts for Cheryl and Bailey! The girls are recording in Mel’s bedroom which Holly finds creepy, Holly is dreading Mel’s driving on the way to the HEN WEEKEND, the girls determine they need ...
Jun 03, 2022•42 min
In Season 4 Episode 50 the girls talk about Countryside Murders due to Mel living in the middle of nowhere. Mel starts things off with the story of Michael Stone before Holly tells you about a supernatural countryside case involving Charles Walton. Shoutouts near the end for some super fans! Mel shakes things up with her intro, the girls are still too tired to pass as humans, Holly’s theories about animals having meetings is proven correct, a horrible crime takes place where Holly used to live, ...
May 27, 2022•42 min
In Season 4 Episode 49 the girls talk about Honeymoon Murders courtesy of the soon to be honeymooning Mel. Holly kicks things off with a very sad story about Welsh couple Ben & Catherine Mullany before Mel tells you about Scott Robin Rolston. Shoutouts to Kirsty (and Kristy of course) for a podcast recommendation and topic suggestion and Cheryl for the great laughs. Holly starts off by dying from not sleeping to which Mel quickly follows with her own fatigue, the English language is challeng...
May 20, 2022•38 min
In Season 4 Episode 48 the girls cover cases of Hospital Murders which is a pretty terrifying thought! Even for them. Mel starts you off with the case of a very busy man named Charles Cullen before Holly tells you the French tale of Romain Dupuy. Shoutout to Kirsty (and by default Kristy) for this week’s theme suggestion as well as Cheryl and Kenda. This episode is full of pigeon apologies, detective puppies (with a legend of a Homicide Hunter shoutout), a firm rule that no tummies should be in ...
May 13, 2022•37 min
In Season 4 Episode 47 the girls cover cases of Murder on a Night Out. Holly tells you the sad tale of a young woman named Jennifer Moore before Mel chats through the strange case of Lorraine Cox. Shoutout to Mel - by Mel - for her own suggestion. The girls start off teaching you about light before Holly lays down a highly scrutinised earth sciences fact complete with hand gestures, Mel laments her lack of interest in school, Holly fills you in on an Edinburgh icon she is emotionally invested in...
May 06, 2022•32 min
In Season 4 Episode 46 the girls cover cases of Kidnap and Murder. Mel starts us off this week with the infamous and tragic story of Polly Klaas before Holly tells you about a murderer who inspired on of the greatest thrillers of all times - Gary Heidnik. Shoutout to Michelle for the topic suggestion and adorable puppy photos! Mel comes to you in her professional podcasting onesie with added distracting pom-poms, Holly fills you in on her new hobby which of course includes animals, Mel flat out ...
Apr 29, 2022•35 min
In Season 4 Episode 45 the girls talk about Lockdown Murders. Holly starts you off with the sad case of Kelly Fitzgibbons before Mel tells you about the story of Penelope Jackson and her rather unapologetic murder story. Shoutout to Caitlin for another great suggestion, Terry for the great feedback and the country of Kenya. Technical difficulties plague the girls from the start, Mel gets a happy surprise field trip, gun safety issues set off a small Melnado, the audacity of Mel’s murderer gives ...
Apr 22, 2022•40 min
In Season 4 Episode 44 the girls talk about Solved Cold Case Murders. Mel starts you off with the difficult to research story of Sara Lynn Wineski before Holly tells you about the murder of Krystal Beslanowitch. Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion - we did them all! The girls provide you with a comprehensive review of the Scottish Midge phenomenon - 0/10 do not recommend - before Holly offends Mel. With good cause. Geography strikes again and ruins Mels life, conclusions bring back t...
Apr 15, 2022•35 min
In Season 4 Episode 43 the girls talk about victims who were Murdered by Poison. Holly starts you off with a very tragic story about a little boy named Garnett-Paul Thompson Spears before Mel turns things around with an actual real life super villain named Graham Young. Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion and the amazing double act that is Kirsty and Kristy. The month of April is discussed with very different focus points for the girls, Mel reveals her dream date, you will witness Ho...
Apr 08, 2022•46 min
In Season 4 Episode 42 the girls talk about Murder Involving the Elderly. Mel kicks things off with the stuff-of-nightmares case of Leonarda Cianciulli before Holly tells you about the soon to be saint Jacques Hamel. Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion and Michelle for her adorable puppy baby photos. Mel gifts you with body air while managing to live with less teeth, she is also shocked by the Scottish rain in Scotland as a Scottish person, Holly is following squirrels to her apparen...
Apr 01, 2022•37 min
In Season 4 Episode 41 the girls cover Murders Solved Online via those incredible people we call Web Slueths. Holly tells the sad rags to riches story of Abraham Lee Shakespeare before Mel talks about Greg May. Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion, Mark for always giving us encouragement and glamorous Emma for sharing the podcast and keeping Mel sparkly. Buckle up for this episode….it’s a gong show. The girls are rather flippant about the WW3 situation, Holly needs a place to stay in ...
Mar 25, 2022•37 min
In Season 4 Episode 40 the girls cover a very sad topic (yes sadder than murder) and tell you about some murder cases involving animals. Mels starts things off with the massive case of BTK before Holly almost follows the theme with Clive Sharp's crimes. Shoutout to Saraid for another great suggestion! You will learn all about Holly’s teeny tiny appliance woes, Mel’s wordle woes - she is not amused with America by the way, there is a tv show suggestion which Holly can’t remember but swears is ama...
Mar 18, 2022•38 min
In Season 4 Episode 39 the girls take a hilarious (in an ironic way) topic suggestion from Mel’s soon to be mother-in-law and cover Wedding Murders. Holly starts us off with a gem of a character named Scott Samson before Mel tells you about another winner named Arthur Hutchinson (who may or may not be dead). Shoutout to Jenny for this amazing suggestion and also to Michelle for her puppy photos. Please keep the animal photos coming! Mel gets in quick this week with telling you who we are given H...
Mar 11, 2022•42 min
In Season 4 Episode 38 the girls cover murders connected to Exercise - double terrible if you ask Holly. Mel tells us all about Ahmaud Arbery before Holly chats through the case of Daniel Lugo. Shoutout to Robyn for the theme suggestion and for sticking with us! Be like Robyn - send us suggestions! The girls discuss Holly’s birthday gifting (food related), the general breakdown of their bodies, they debate jogging routes that involve running through houses, Holly stretches the theme yet again an...
Mar 04, 2022•31 min
In Season 4 Episode 37 the girls cover some well known Retail Murders - which is ironic because retail in general is Murder. Holly kicks us off with the Lululemon Murder before Mel dips into the HiFi Murders from the 70s. Shoutouts to Kirsty (not Kristy) for the suggestion and also to Jordan who came to us via a recommendation from beloved LouLou. Beds are the topic of the day leading to snuggle chat, Mel is under the impression she is mellowing, Holly has an excessive amount of Lululemon clothi...
Feb 25, 2022•35 min
In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job. Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains on a health not-kick, we learn that Holly skates like a sailboat, Mel tells us about her love for...
Feb 18, 2022•42 min
In Season 4 Episode 35 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Hatecrime Murders. Holly starts with the sad story of Nikki Kuhnhausen before Mel tells you about the horrific murder of Matthew Shepard. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Also Caitlin who is a quickly rising superfan and Natalie who Holly is ‘real life many years’ friends with but has no recollection of HOW they became friends. Holly talks about her neverending flood curse, Mel talks about her ne...
Feb 11, 2022•49 min
In Season 4 Episode 34 the girls talk about Hybristophilia suggested by a listener. (n. sexual interest in and attraction to those who commit crimes. In some cases, this may be directed toward people in prison for various types of criminal activities.) They didn’t know what it meant either. Mel kicks it off with the story of the killer Canadian Paul Bernardo before Holly tells you about a Hillside Strangler. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Hope all is well in the middle of nowhere. Mel tr...
Feb 04, 2022•38 min
In Season 4 Episode 33 the girls talk about Families Who Cover Up Murder - which they would absolutely not do for their families. Holly starts you off with the case of Patricia O’Connor before Mel goes over the infamous Robert Durst (The Jinx) story. Shoutout to Carrie who tuned in on Christmas Eve while wrapping presents last year. Good job on those corners girl! Holly believes she has finally matured as she has full bladder control 75% of the time now, Mel has reached the age of hand cream gif...
Jan 28, 2022•34 min
In Season 4 Episode 32 the girls talk about Brits Murdered Abroad which was suggested by fiance Dave. Mel jumps into things with the story of Lucie Blackman before Holly tells you about Joanna Parrish. Shoutouts to Kirsty and Kristy - WE ARE CONSTANTLY CONFUSED BY YOUR NAMES and Michelle - there were pet sharing photos and Holly was blissed out for days. Mel struggles with her English due to her storing alcohol in her left cheek since December, Holly gets someone in trouble accidentally, Mel is ...
Jan 21, 2022•28 min
In Season 4 Episode 31 the girls take a listener suggestion from VIP future mother-in-law Jenny and cover Trusted Profession Murders. Holly kicks us off with the case of Andrew Lindo before Mel goes into the recent and controversial story of Wayne Couzens. Shoutouts to Ansley and Rosanny from the distant land of Instagram! The girls are recording for the first time since last year and have declared themselves fat, sad and skint. Mel once again manages to offend an entire profession, Holly has mu...
Jan 14, 2022•46 min
In Season 4 Episode 30 the girls take not only a listener suggestion, but a listener’s case! Mel tells you about Graham Staines before Holly covers the story of Werner Groenewald. Both are terribly tragic. Shoutout to Michelle for allowing us to tell her family’s story. Welcome to the first podcast episode of 2022 where we find out just how literal Mel is, Holly apparently now lives off the land, the girls don’t need to debate this case very long although they do manage to talk about other thing...
Jan 07, 2022•35 min
In Season 4 Episode 29 the girls wish you a very happy 2022 with MURDER. New Years Murders to be exact. Holly talks about murderer Scott Watson before Mel tells you all about John Allen Mohammad. The girls continue with the Covid chat which annoys them both, they touch their microphones a lot in this episode so…. good luck listeners, the girls tell you how much they hate New Years Eve but also have a great New Years Eve everyone, Holly chooses a challenging case in regards to the entire premise ...
Dec 31, 2021•38 min
In Season 4 Episode 28 the girls talk about Christmas Murders! Merry festive homicides all ‘round. Mel begins this seasonal episode with the murder of Sameena Imam before Holly tells you about a local Edinburgh Scotland case involving Melissa Young. Shoutouts to Cheryl who made some drinky suggestions and Kirsty who had a tragic death in her family related to one of our topics. We find out Holly is in Christmas limbo and moving hell, Mel is festive and prepared which is highly suspicious given h...
Dec 24, 2021•42 min
